Discussion in 'Blu-ray & DVD Players & Recorders' started by noyce, Nov 10, 2003.
Anyone know much about this dvd player. Can anyone confirm PAL progressive scan?
Look in What Viedo & Widescreen TV December 2003 issue. The Yamaha is on test. According to the mag, the player is capable of outputing pal and ntsc progressive signal.
I'm also interested in this player as well. Richer Sound has it at £109.95 multi-region.
Cheers mate. The price seems a little bit too good to be true.
My Brother has this player, stay well clear, it has a very poor de-interlacer.
Its ok as just a normal player connected to a Tv. Not good enough for Projector or Plasma.
The new Toshiba sd-530 may be a good one from RS at £180 MR.
OK mate, thanks for the honest opinion. I was a little bit curious when i noticed how cheap it was.
What did the magazine review say?
I have one of these on my 28" Panasonic TV, nice picture and sound however the drive makes quite a racket sometimes
I'm happy with the amount of Media and formats it can read compared to my old Samsung DVD-511 (which was showing it's age)
I too had one for a couple of days. For the money, the specs looked too good to be true - well they are.
Definitely don't get one if it's the PS features you are after. The Limit players that Richer Sounds sell, whilst not perfect are a far superior picture in PS than this Yamaha.
This is only viewing on a 42" screen, I dread to think how awful it would look projected.
another glowing recommendation
Think I'll remove the damn thing from my Signature
BTW What does the de-interlacer do?
Anything to do with making colours on sky, clouds and walls etc seem patchy?
Wouldn't worry - interlaced output on a 28" screen is probably fine - the reason for the interest in this player is that it's from a 'name' manufacturer, supports PAL Prog Scan, and is cheap.
Unfortunately the de-interlacing is not good.
I did like the 'resume' function that remembers the last 5 dvds though. My 757ai can't do that
Thx for the words of comfort Nike
Can you explain what the de-interlacing does/is?
Check out the 'sticky' thread over on the Progressive Scan Forum.
Err...Dunno if there was a dodgy batch of these players but I have to tell you guys that I use one connected to a ThemeScene projector and I watch it on 7 and a half foot screen and the picture in pal prog is breathtaking. I note that some of you are using the player with 42" Plasmas....could it be that you've just realised how much money you've wasted on cruddy screens and you need to blame something?
You could be right there, as I can't believe the one I had was working properly.
FYI, I've had my plasma for nearly 2 years now and am more than happy with it - I'm not looking to blame anything.
Out of the 3 PAL/NTSC PS players I've used with it the Yamaha was the worst by a mile. (as you point-out though, It could have been a faulty unit - my experience with it is not unique though)
I'm not looking to 'diss' anyone's kit, but posted because I have experience of the player being asked about by the original poster.
Finally ended-up with a 757ai and have not looked at another player since
bought mine on advice of chrissandgate (cheers) - using with X1 and hoya filter. Well chuffed with picture- also on 7.5 foot screen. Don't know if its just me but the dreaded rainbows seem to be substantially decreased. For 129 smackers delivered on time , multi region and rce have no complaints.
Hi Pugwashgreg, so pleased to hear you like the combo. Be honest now mate, do you think you could possibly have done better for the cash? Please tell me a bit more about the filter, I don't see many rainbows at all and even when I do they are so fleeting as to not bother me at all, but I'd be interested to see what the filter can do.
Dear Nike, pleased to hear that you're happy with your 757ai-I would be too if I'd payed around 6 times the price of the Yamaha. Can you honestly show me why this machine is around 500 quid better?, bearing in mind that I only want it to play dvds.
I wasnt attempting to compare the 2 machines, just saying what I ended up with: obviously there is a large price difference.
Is the 757ai worth £500 more? Compared to the Yamaha I had; yes as the picture I had with it was nearly unwatchable artefact city. Anything like window blinds or car radiator grilles would completely phase it and background detail was not stable. I was expecting this to be an improvement on the Limit player I had and it was not as good. The Yamaha I had did not improve any of the aspects of picture quality that Progressive Scan is supposed to improve. Whilst using it I could improve the picture by outputting an interlaced signal and letting the screen do the de-interlacing.
As an added bonus, the Pioneer was an upgrade in sound quality over both previous players.
No, I cant show you why its better, as to do so would involve a side-by-side comparison. As I said earlier, I posted on this thread to give an opinion on a player I had experience of, not to get into a pi**ing contest with someone whos opinion differs from mine.
Yes, I ended-up spending more that I originally intended to, but I have a player that Im now totally happy with and thats the main thing.
Separate names with a comma.