Worth upgrading my graphics card?

Tech_Boy

Active Member
Hi I currently run a 3.4GHz P4 with a 256MB ATI Radeon X600 Pro graphics card. I've started watching HD content and was wondering if I'd get much of a benefit upgrading this card to one of the newer HD 2600XT cards? I don't play any games on the PC so the reviews I've read about these cards not being very good for gaming don't concern me much as long as they can do the business when it comes to HD material I'm happy. I currently use Zoom Player with it's multiple codecs for watching movies and don't really experience many problems when watching HD content apart from my computer sometimes sounds like it's about to take off and I had a few instances of jumping during LOTR: Return of the King last night. The picture looked good to me but would I get better with the newer card? I can see one of the big benefits being the HDMI connection which will free up my VGA for my Xbox 360.

Does anyone know if the GDDR4 version is that much better then the GDDR3 version as you pay a ~£20 premium for GDDR4. Lastly what's the difference between all the manufacturers? Is one better then the others as I've seen HIS do versions which come with better cooling and improved GPU Core speed and Memory speed at 1908MHz as apposed to 1800MHz. Sorry for all the questions but I'm pretty clueless when it comes to this kind of thing.

Thanks

Alex
 

Decadent Fool

Active Member
Try running task manager while watching a bit of film; if your cpu usage is 100%, then perhaps a new one may help.

Perhaps one of the new ati jobs, of which I am an owner, but still cutting my teeth on :D
 

sptburty

Standard Member
upgraded couple of weeks ago from a Radeon X700 to a hd 2600xt with gdr3 mem, works great fo me on athlon 4200 dual core with 2 gb ram.
a 720p works about 25% cpu and a 1080p about 55% cpu this used to be around 95% cpu so card is doing a lot more work
ps mine is a Sapphire make not sure of differences but you get all software upgrades from ati site allso using mediaplayer classic with fdshow and ac3 filter (great for outputting dd to amp)
 

Tech_Boy

Active Member
Thanks for that, it's exactly the info I was after. I think I'll also be going with the Sapphire one too as it's one of the few that include the DVI-HDMI adapter while the majority of others say it's optional. Anyone know the cheapest place for graphics cards? Thanks again
 

Tech_Boy

Active Member
Thanks again they do free delivery as well which is a bonus and therefore they are actually the cheapest I've found.
 
Hi Tech_Boy, i run the x600xt card in my latest gaming pc. It runs games sweet and no problems at handling any game as yet, but if you are going to watch hd films then i would upgrade to a higher memory card. I know the 512Mb XFX 7900GTX is great for hd quality films

( http://www.scan.co.uk/Products/ProductInfo.asp?WebProductID=364166 )

I hope this is of some use to you, if you do decide to upgrade maybe we could sort a deal out for the x600 pro card :thumbsup:
 

badbob

Banned
Hi Tech_Boy, i run the x600xt card in my latest gaming pc. It runs games sweet and no problems at handling any game as yet, but if you are going to watch hd films then i would upgrade to a higher memory card. I know the 512Mb XFX 7900GTX is great for hd quality films

( http://www.scan.co.uk/Products/ProductInfo.asp?WebProductID=364166 )

I hope this is of some use to you, if you do decide to upgrade maybe we could sort a deal out for the x600 pro card :thumbsup:

Bad advice. The difference between your card and the 7900GTX for video playback will be EXACTLY THE SAME on CPU load. The ATI X600 is a budget gaming card that is several generations old. A 1950 Pro or 1800XT will slaughter it.

Looking into 7900GTX v 8800GTS performance..
 

Tech_Boy

Active Member
Thanks guys, I've read alot of the comparisons and this is why I've chosen the ATI HD 2600XT for HD playback as it takes the majority of processing on it's own GPU so the CPU works far less. The X600 was more then capable when I used to play games on the PC but obviously has been surpassed over and over. If you still want the card UnTrue I'm sure we can come to some sort of arrangement :D
 
Thanks guys, I've read alot of the comparisons and this is why I've chosen the ATI HD 2600XT for HD playback as it takes the majority of processing on it's own GPU so the CPU works far less. The X600 was more then capable when I used to play games on the PC but obviously has been surpassed over and over. If you still want the card UnTrue I'm sure we can come to some sort of arrangement :D

Hi yeah im interested in the card at a good price tech :D
 

PD_BARBS

Active Member
I also have a problem and I am seeking some advice.

My current card is a Radeon X1550, but some of the new games coming out will work on 1650 or greater cards. Now my machine is a DELL with a PSu kicking out 304 watts. But I heard somewhere that alot of the newer cards require a PSU of 500 watts or more.

I do not want to have to shelve out 100 for a new card plus £60 for a PSU as my machine is less than a year old.

Can someone advise me on whether this is the case or on cards that will run with the 304 PSU.

Any help would be appreciated.

Thanks
 

badbob

Banned
Using a gaming card with a off the shelf no-name 300W isn't such a good idea. A 450W quality PSU will be enough for mid-end gaming cards, or even X1800XT.

If you want a to fit a gaming card you'll need a PSU. It's also possible your Dell PSU is non-standard, so might not fit your motherboard.

Just buy a new machine.
 

PD_BARBS

Active Member
Using a gaming card with a off the shelf no-name 300W isn't such a good idea. A 450W quality PSU will be enough for mid-end gaming cards, or even X1800XT.

If you want a to fit a gaming card you'll need a PSU. It's also possible your Dell PSU is non-standard, so might not fit your motherboard.

Just buy a new machine.


Thanks

I may as well hang up my keyboard and start playing with my kids.

As the machine is less than a year old, this option will be a non starter. I will just have to stick to my boring BF2142.
 

Tejstar

Distinguished Member
I also have a problem and I am seeking some advice.

My current card is a Radeon X1550, but some of the new games coming out will work on 1650 or greater cards. Now my machine is a DELL with a PSu kicking out 304 watts. But I heard somewhere that alot of the newer cards require a PSU of 500 watts or more.

I do not want to have to shelve out 100 for a new card plus £60 for a PSU as my machine is less than a year old.

Can someone advise me on whether this is the case or on cards that will run with the 304 PSU.

Any help would be appreciated.

Thanks
I recently upgraded a Dell machine and stuck a Corsair HX520 PSU and Sapphire X1950Pro 256MB graphics card. They seem within your budget and I see no reason why it wouldn't work.

Which Dell do you have btw?
 

PD_BARBS

Active Member
I recently upgraded a Dell machine and stuck a Corsair HX520 PSU and Sapphire X1950Pro 256MB graphics card. They seem within your budget and I see no reason why it wouldn't work.

Which Dell do you have btw?


I have a Dell dimension E521. I have read some posts on Dell community use groups, that updating the PSU is not always necessary, so I am somewhat confused as to whether I need a PSU or not.

I am also confused as to why my existing card will play BF2142, but is not capable of the Quake Wars demo :suicide:
 

Barbs

Novice Member
I have a Dell dimension E521. I have read some posts on Dell community use groups, that updating the PSU is not always necessary, so I am somewhat confused as to whether I need a CPU or not.

I am also confused as to why my existing card will play BF2142, but is not capable of the Quake Wars demo :suicide:

Don't you mean PSU? :D
 

PD_BARBS

Active Member
Don't you mean PSU? :D



Yes

A bit more details, on doing some research on the Dell community website, alot of people are saying that the PSU on the dell is understated and is capable of supporting cards upto 8800 GTS. Although in some cases a splitter is required.

http://www.dellcommunity.com/supportforums/board/message?board.id=dim_upghw&thread.id=110776

But I think I know someone who can give me a 6600 GT to get me going in the meantime.

So hopefully that will help.
 

Tejstar

Distinguished Member
My Dell PSU did not come with an extra molex connector to power a X1950Pro or above. Therefore a new PSU was needed. Just open your PSU and check to see if it has one for the graphics card, i fit does you can always try and buy a new graphics card to see if it works okay.

My guess is still though that a new PSU will be needed.
 

PD_BARBS

Active Member
My Dell PSU did not come with an extra molex connector to power a X1950Pro or above. Therefore a new PSU was needed. Just open your PSU and check to see if it has one for the graphics card, i fit does you can always try and buy a new graphics card to see if it works okay.

My guess is still though that a new PSU will be needed.


I think a suck it and see approach is the best way forward. Hopefully I may be alright
 

psikey

Distinguished Member
I also have a problem and I am seeking some advice.

My current card is a Radeon X1550, but some of the new games coming out will work on 1650 or greater cards. Now my machine is a DELL with a PSu kicking out 304 watts. But I heard somewhere that alot of the newer cards require a PSU of 500 watts or more.

I do not want to have to shelve out 100 for a new card plus £60 for a PSU as my machine is less than a year old.

Can someone advise me on whether this is the case or on cards that will run with the 304 PSU.

Any help would be appreciated.

Thanks

I've done a lot of investigation and came to the same as many others that this: http://www.ebuyer.com/UK/product/128946 is excellent value for money and should not use much power. I read someone was using it on a good quality 250w dell supply.

My system has a 350w in a small case & the GDDR3 version is also shorter than the GDDR4 one so great for limited space yet only around 10% less fps performace but £25 cheaper!! (GDDR4 ~£85 , GDDR3 ~£60)

This takes all it's power from the PCI-E slot & doesn't need an extra power supply feed to it.

I'm replacing an old 6600GT with this to play Bioshock.
 
ok tech_boy, u let me know when your ready m8 :smashin:
 

PD_BARBS

Active Member
I've done a lot of investigation and came to the same as many others that this: http://www.ebuyer.com/UK/product/128946 is excellent value for money and should not use much power. I read someone was using it on a good quality 250w dell supply.

My system has a 350w in a small case & the GDDR3 version is also shorter than the GDDR4 one so great for limited space yet only around 10% less fps performace but £25 cheaper!! (GDDR4 ~£85 , GDDR3 ~£60)

This takes all it's power from the PCI-E slot & doesn't need an extra power supply feed to it.

I'm replacing an old 6600GT with this to play Bioshock.


Can you let me know how you get on, I read some posts on the dell forum of people who have done this. It looks promising. This is a good price for this card, but I certainly don't want to start changing my PSU.

Thanks
 

The latest video from AVForums

LG G1 OLED Evo TV and SVS SB-1000 Pro subwoofer reviews, Samsung OLED rumours and more...
Subscribe to our YouTube channel

Latest News

Samsung's 110-inch Micro LED TV on pre-order at Harrods
  • By Andy Bassett
  • Published
Bang & Olufsen introduces Beosound Emerge speaker
  • By Andy Bassett
  • Published
Sony launches native 4K VPL-VW290ES and VW890ES projectors
  • By Andy Bassett
  • Published
AVForums Podcast: 14th April 2021
  • By Phil Hinton
  • Published
Ruark introduces R5 Signature audio player
  • By Andy Bassett
  • Published

Full fat HDMI teeshirts

Support AVForums with Patreon

Top Bottom