My 2 most scary games are both Thief and Thief the Deadly Shadows. In Thief the first time the scariest his you is out of the blue and Zone told me of a very funny incident what happened in his house. The scariest level in the game is The Haunted Cathedral where you hear all manner of noises and you are literally frightened to open a door for what may be on the other side. I use to be classed as the most scariest level of any game up to last year. Thief the Deadly Shadows. Is also scary and many sight The Cradle as the worst, but for me it was the following one The Lair Of The Hag with the stone statues giving me chase didnt half get my heart going.