Whale Rider R1

[Phil Hinton]

Matt Brown looks back to the Oscar nominated Whale Rider on R1 DVD.

Read the review Here

 

[Miyazaki]

I'd have given it an 8/10 personally, but nice review.

Are your reviews skewed towards the actual content of both the feature and/or extras, rather than sound and picture quality, or are all areas equally weighted?

Cheers!

 

[Smurfin]

I rate them as an entire "package", so I think the score I awarded it was deserved, but I must admit I'll be easier on a disc on the extras front rather than poor audio or video (or film) - all of which are unforgivable imho

 

[Miyazaki]

What I mean is.

Say a film is low budget, so they can't afford to produce extras, generate an stupendous soundtrack or the soundtrack is dialogue heavy with no exploding helicopters etc and is only shot on a DV cam, but is an exceptional film.

So for instance with this film

Film itself : 10/10

PQ: 5/10

SQ: 6/10

Extras: 3/10

Will the dvd get a 6/10??

Compared to another vacuous action flick

Film : 5/10

PQ: 9/10

SQ: 9/10

Extras 8/10

Will the dvd get a 8/10??

Just a query! Cheers for any correspondance.

 

[Smurfin]

Originally posted by Games Guru
So for instance with this film

Film itself : 10/10

PQ: 5/10

SQ: 6/10

Extras: 3/10

Will the dvd get a 6/10??

Compared to another vacuous action flick

Film : 5/10

PQ: 9/10

SQ: 9/10

Extras 8/10

Will the dvd get a 8/10??

Just a query! Cheers for any correspondance.

Interesting question. From my own personal point of view, regardless of how good the extras, sound and picture quality are, if the movie sucks the big one then I can't justify giving it a good "overall" score. However it doesn't quite work the other way; if a movie is good but presentation is sloppy, it will still get a poor overall mark. BUT, the exception is...if there's an extremely low budget movie - say a 2004 Blair Witch Project - and due to the nature of how it was shot it has a grainy picture etc, but which is an excellent movie, the overall score will take its "budget" roots into account.

Does that make sense? Not sure if I've explained it correctly, but as you can tell from what I've written, it's not straightforward! (scoring can be difficult sometimes).

 

[Miyazaki]

I think that answers the question. Cheers!