Two different reviewers who are going to have different views.How come this review does not mention that the movie was already reviewed couple of months ago on this same web-site? Did this reviewer forget about the past review or didn't want to mention it?
That review gives an Unmissable award (grade 9, movie 8) Waterworld Blu-ray Review
This review grades it at 6, and the movie gets a 6.
Yes, I understand that these are two different editions, and two different versions of the movie, but a full review (especially if done after a couple of months) should mention that there are several editions (and edits) of the movie, and that some are better/longer/more-complete that the other ones, and if the reviewer knows that there is a better option, he should recommend the better option.
Otherwise what is the point of the review?