On AVForums there are many enthusiasts that embellish the benefits of features. They have to have something to demonstrate their superior knowledge and so they way over state the differences between certain TVs/features.
When your on AVForums any question is going to get varied extreme opinions from a multitude of "experts".
For me I find Dodgexander's input to be the most practical and useful. He is very knowledgeable and presents his information as a way to help individuals make a rational choice rather than trying to impress you with how much he knows by embellishing the differences between features. For me I would read through what Dodgexander has written and make my choice based on his input.
Note: The only difference of opinions I have with Dodgexander is his views on IPS panels, especially if you don't watch your TV in a dark room, and sometimes he recommends unreliable TV's, such as Vizio TV's.