New Patreon Tier and Early Access Content available. If you would like to support AVForums, we now have a new Patreon Tier which gives you access to selected news, reviews and articles before they are available to the public. Read more.
I don't, although being a Fincher fan, 'The Game' is one of a few exclusive HD titles i'd got on my 'must have in HD list', a list that collectively might tempt me to dip my toe into the HD-DVD pond. It's rather disappointing to read that they've made a hash of this!
As for Payback, whilst the film's colour palette isn't one of those that lends itself to the 'pop' effect and there's quite a bit of grain, it still looked incredibly crisp and detailed throughout imo - certainly one of my better BD discs!
I've spun it up and watched the first 10 minutes or so, but don't think it's as bad as they made out. I do have pretty much every incarnation of the movie (LD, Criterion LD, DVD and now HD).
Put it this way - I watched Layer Cake at the weekend on Blu-Ray. I don't visit other review sites as a rule of thumb, but The Game seems better as LC has some really bad artifacts in the night-time scenes. I've no idea what anyone else has said re LC, but that's my take on it (as they're the last 2 HD discs I've spun).
I watched this tonight. Yep, it's no a demo disc to spin to your mates but then again it wasn't the "stinker" that some describe it as. The film is dark almost all the time and this doesn't help. I'm still glad with my HD-DVD purchase.