Sky Phone Line Problems

DanStanDaMan

Standard Member
Hopefully someone can assist me with some advice that will save me £99 + £65 an hour for a SKY engineer!

Where the phone line comes into the house there is a BT phone line box (althoug my provider is SKY). Into this plugs an adaptor with two sets of blue and white cables plugged into it.

Into this adaptor I plug my ADSL micro filter which allows me to use the phone and modem on the same line. The Sky Plus HD box is shown as plugged in but appears to be on a seperate line.

My problem is I have no dialling tone at all on my phone line so I cannot make / receive any calls. For the last two weeks I could but the line was AWFUL! Weirdly, and rather confusingly the internet is working fine.

I have tried changing the connection cable for the phone, and I have changed the actual phone as well (and changed the handset batteries!) - neither makes any difference.

I have taken the front off the box to get to the master BT phone line - the phones do not work, but plug the ADSL filter in here and the internet is fine.(in fact it is far better than usual!)............

Can someone assist please! SKY have told me that there is a call out fee PLUS hourly rate if the problem is found to be inside my house...... o_O
 

fernandez

Distinguished Member
To begin with the Sky call out charge is £65 which covers the cost of the visit and whatever needs to be done, parts etc. and that's it.
As the problem is with the phone line rather than Sky equipment what you have been quoted may well be correct if the job is passed on to Openreach.
There is usually a slight improvement if the router is plugged into the test socket.
If what's connected to the phone is the ADSL router, a Sky box and one phone the simplest way, I think, would be :
Microfilter plugged into phone socket
Lead taken from ADSL out to router
Two way adaptor into phone out on microfilter with one lead to phone and the other to Sky box.

On the other hand do you really need the phone line connected to the Sky box?
If you're within the first 12 months of a contract it's supposed to be connected but single box installations are rarely checked - Multiroom is, of course, a different matter
 

DanStanDaMan

Standard Member
Hi Fernandez,

thanks for your help.

My knowledge of what the adapters are called is bad - I apologise!

The TV line is totally seperate and working fine.

Currently I have the ADSL microfilter plugged directly into the MAIN BT phone point (under the facia plate!). Into the Microfilter are the phone cable and modem cable. The internet is fine but there is jut a crackly dead line on the phone!
 

Miss Chief

Distinguished Member
The charges you have been quoted are for a BT Openreach engineer visit, which, if my memory serves me right from when I had a problem around £99 callout and somewhere around £65 as an hourly fee.

Basically if you have a removable BOTTOM faceplate take this off and plug a phone (and only a phone, no splitters, filters, double adaptors) into the test socket and try it. if it still doesn't work either check your phone works somewhere else or try another phone. Did the advisor run a line test and did they say what the result was?
 

DanStanDaMan

Standard Member
Hi Miss Chief!

I have taken the bottom plate off but with just the phone plugged in there is nothing. I have tried a different cable and a different handset (and changed the batteries as well!).

The advisor did run some tests and said there were vaious faults but they couldn't rule out the problem being inside my house (although that was before I had taken the bottom facia plate off.).
 

Stevenage Neil

Distinguished Member
Take the bottom face plate off and plug a microfilter into the Test Socket. Plug your phone into the phone connection on the microfilter and test it.
Plug your modem/router into the ADSL socket of the microfilter and check everything is OK.

If the above works then you have a problem with your internal wiring and BT,(Openreach), will charge you £125 just to come out and tell you you have a fault with your internal wiring - without fixing it!!
 

fernandez

Distinguished Member
It's looking more and more like an internal wiring/configuration/equipment problem and nothing to do with Sky.

However, I'm a little confused (nothing new there) with these statements:

1
"Where the phone line comes into the house there is a BT phone line box... Into this plugs an adaptor with two sets of blue and white cables plugged into it.

Into this adaptor I plug my ADSL micro filter which allows me to use the phone and modem on the same line. The Sky Plus HD box is shown as plugged in but appears to be on a seperate line."


2
"Currently I have the ADSL microfilter plugged directly into the MAIN BT phone point (under the facia plate!). Into the Microfilter are the phone cable and modem cable. The internet is fine but there is jut a crackly dead line on the phone! "

If the modem works then so should the phone - voice and ADSL are filtered/separated by the microfilter (plus you're saying the Sky box is shown as connected)

Have you tried a different microfilter?
 

logiciel

Moderator
On the other hand do you really need the phone line connected to the Sky box?
If you're within the first 12 months of a contract it's supposed to be connected but single box installations are rarely checked - Multiroom is, of course, a different matter
DSDM - what's your comment on this?
I'd definitely take it out before testing anything.
 

Miss Chief

Distinguished Member
If he's gone into the test socket and only has a telephone plugged in and he's still not getting anything then he's already isolated all of his internal wiring. The next step is to try another telephone. If that still doesn;t work then really it needs to be an openreach visit. The master socket marks the point where your responsibility ends and Sky's starts. If you still get nothing in the test socket and you've tried another corded phone (£3.50 from Argos if you don't have one, handy as usable in a powercut too, cordless phones aren't) then it's an openreach visit as it's unlikely there's a fault internally.
 
My problem is I have no dialling tone at all on my phone line so I cannot make / receive any calls. For the last two weeks I could but the line was AWFUL! Weirdly, and rather confusingly the internet is working fine.

I have taken the front off the box to get to the master BT phone line - the phones do not work, but plug the ADSL filter in here and the internet is fine.(in fact it is far better than usual!)............

I think people (maybe just me) are confused because this is a Sky TV forum and this (to me) sounds like purely a phone line issue.

Just to clarify. You've removed all connections to your main socket, removed the flaceplate, attached a single phone directly to the master socket and you get no dial tone?

If you've done this and also verified that the phone itself definitely works (ie tried at a friend's house), then it's definitely NOT internal wiring. You should go back to Sky with this information and they should fix the problem (ie get OpenReach to fix it) as the problem is the external line coming into your house.

EDIT: Miss Chief beat me to it.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

fernandez

Distinguished Member
As I've said before this appears to be a phone problem but I'm still puzzled that the internet works whilst the phone doesn't.
After all it all comes down the same phone line and is split off by the microfilter into ADSL and voice
HowStuffWorks "ADSL Standards"
So, if the internet works, why doesn't the phone? Faulty microfilter?
Other than that it certainly looks like an Openreach job
 

Stevenage Neil

Distinguished Member
If he's gone into the test socket and only has a telephone plugged in and he's still not getting anything then he's already isolated all of his internal wiring.

Into the Test socket via a microfilter!!
 

Miss Chief

Distinguished Member
Hi Miss Chief!

I have taken the bottom plate off but with just the phone plugged in there is nothing. I have tried a different cable and a different handset (and changed the batteries as well!).

The advisor did run some tests and said there were vaious faults but they couldn't rule out the problem being inside my house (although that was before I had taken the bottom facia plate off.).

Once you've checked your phone or have tried another, plug the phone only into the test socket. It will work regardless of a microfilter or not, although, of course, your BB won't work without one, but that's not the issue at the moment. At that point get back onto Sky to get another line test run. No automated line test is 100% accurate, hence the possibility of charges and the statement but if you've proved the phone works or tried another and you're in the test socket then it's extremely unlikely that Openreach can charge you in any way.

Into the Test socket via a microfilter!!

If his broadband works, and he's said it does, he should be testing the line without a Microfilter, to rule out the filter or his Router/modem as the cause of the problem.
 

Stevenage Neil

Distinguished Member
If his broadband works, and he's said it does, he should be testing the line without a Microfilter, to rule out the filter or his Router/modem as the cause of the problem.

Wrong way round me thinks! The broadband will always work, without a phone/fax machine/Sky box etc, filter or not.
Phone/fax machine/Sky box etc, will not work without a filter.
Houses with phone lines purely for broadband do not require a filter.

Check this: http:
 
Last edited:

Miss Chief

Distinguished Member
If you plug a phone straight into the socket with BB enabled on the line you'll still get a dial tone and can still use the phone. Whilst in order to use the BB along with the phone you need one, to check the line he should have the telephone connected only for testing purposes.
 

DanStanDaMan

Standard Member
Hi!

Sorry for not replying quicker - it was my wedding anniversary yesterday so that was my priority!

I have had another play / look at the cabling.

I have tried all the recommendations (although I will pop to argos to pick up the cheap handset to try as well!)

Having had a look at the box / wiring again the box is telewest broadband (NOT BT as I previously thought - Sorry). Next to the box there is a hole in the wall (from outside) and a cable coming into the house (I assume THIS is the phone line????). This cable connects into a white block using two blue/white wires (both wires seem to still be in place). Alongside this in another connection is the SKY TV box cable again connected using the blue/white wires (both wires seem to still be in place).

Before there was a problem the MICROFILTER plugged into the fron of the telewest wallbox. Into this was the connection box for the phone line/sky tv box as well as the Broadband connection. Everything worked fine!

After the phone line stopped working I tried all the different recommendations above.

i) Using just the phone into the master box - NOTHING
ii) Using the phone into the microfilter (and a new one to boot!) into the master box - Nothing
iii) Using phone into blue/white cabled connector box and that into the master box - Nothing
iv) Using phone into blue/white cabled connector box into microfilter and that into the master box - also nothing................................

Now for a call to sky - I will update shortly! Thanks for your advice so far!

Dan
The phone into
 

DanStanDaMan

Standard Member
OK so I spoke with Sky and they believe that the problem is outside. They ran a line check and found a line fault which they are arranging for an engineer to sort.

Thanks for all you help guys and gals!

For info the call out fee as quoted by them is £99.88 with £64.** per hour labour charge.

Also I hope I have added some pics to show what a mess of cables I have!

http://i317.photobucket.com/albums/mm363/danstandaman/P1010771.jpg
Pic 1 shows my phone line setup as it was before the problem. (Ignore the large white box thats an old virgin box no longer in use.)
The master socket has a cable going into it but I believe that is the old Telewest line. The NEW phone line is the single cable through the hole in the wall on the left!

http://i317.photobucket.com/albums/mm363/danstandaman/P1010774.jpg
Pic 2 is a close up of the connector block of the BT/Sky phone line (the one through the wall on pic 1) with the Sky+ connection. This unit was plugged into the master socket (Telewest).

http://i317.photobucket.com/albums/mm363/danstandaman/P1010775.jpg 3 shows the whole connection before it plugs into the master socket.
The black cable to the right is the Sky+ TV cable. The other one is the phone line (coming in through the wall on pic 1!). The phone line is then split by the Microfilter between the phone and broadband.


I hope this makes sense! If and when I get any update from the engineers I will update here. Thanks.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

logiciel

Moderator
The last pic wasn't linked properly - I've corrected it - OK?
Logi
 

DanStanDaMan

Standard Member
Not sure whether any of them are working now??!!

I will try this way!!

PIC 1

P1010771.jpg



PIC 2
P1010774.jpg


PIC 3
P1010775.jpg
 
Last edited:

logiciel

Moderator
One and two were working, three wasn't so I corrected it and then it was working.:D
I'll leave the new post though with the pictures showing.
 

fernandez

Distinguished Member
Who left wiring in a state like that?:eek:
Especially pics 2 and 3

But, although Sky are helping, this is a problem for BT and/or the cable provider
 

Miss Chief

Distinguished Member
Openreach won't touch internal wiring without a hefty bill.

In the first pic, get rid of the double adaptor and put the Filter direct into the socket first.
 

DanStanDaMan

Standard Member
That is how the engineers did it during the original install!

I had not touched it until this problem occurred!



When I first phoned Sky about the problems they quoted me the openreach prices - hence the reason for this thread! I wanted to do everything possible to ensure the problem was not my fault / inside my house!
 
Last edited:

The latest video from AVForums

Star Wars Andor, Woman King, more Star Trek 4K, Rings of Power & the latest TV, movies & 4K releases
Subscribe to our YouTube channel

Latest News

What's new on Netflix (UK) for October 2022
  • By Ian Collen
  • Published
Starzplay streaming service rebrands as Lionsgate+
  • By Andy Bassett
  • Published
JVC adds Filmmaker Mode to latest D-ILA projector firmware
  • By Andy Bassett
  • Published
Bowers & Wilkins launches Px8 headphone
  • By Andy Bassett
  • Published
Sky set to launch its plug-and-play Sky Stream solution
  • By Ian Collen
  • Published

Full fat HDMI teeshirts

Support AVForums with Patreon

Top Bottom