Yes, I know it's been talked about before but I need to clarify a few things as I'm having a, eerrr, discussion with someone on another forum about Sky+ and 5.1 He claims that most digiboxes have some form of digital out which I know is not right. He also says that his sony box (with optical out) is decoding the 5.1 signal that is connected directly to his Tosh TV. This could be right although I'm not upto date on Tosh TV's and if they have built in decoders/amps. His final claim is that Sky+ is not transmitting 5.1 now. And that only the Matrix was done as a test. Now I don't have Sky+, and I'm only going by information that I have been reading here. But I was under the impression that the only box 100% compatible with 5.1 was the Sky+ box and that they are transmitting 5.1 now, but only on selected films. Who is right here?