Pulp Fiction / Jakie Brown Packaging

Oblivion

Standard Member
Just revieved the above special EDS from play this morning and the Packaging is so poor :mad:

Both come in cardboard sleves and fold out disc holders. In the past these cases IMO looked much grander than an Amray case. Eg Fight Club, Se7en, The Simpsons to name a few. But the quality of these two new is dire. Pulp Fiction was all bent and not square, and when I opened Jakie Brown the plastic parts which hold the discs just fell to the floor due to the fact they had come unstuck from the cardboard. Which seems much thinner than the box sets mentioned above.

After waiting so long for these to top SEs I am very disapointed.

Has anyone else found this with these SEs? Or is it just me??

Paul
 
S

Squirrel God

Guest
Originally posted by Ian J
This was covered as recently as yesterday http://www.avforums.com/forums/showthread.php?s=&threadid=45521
Ian, That thread was about snapper cases ;)

Originally posted by Oblivion
Has anyone else found this with these SEs? Or is it just me??
Got PF and JB today and have to agree about the cheap digipaks.

The cardboard is so thin, they may as well be made from paper not cardboard. The worst thing though is the ridiculous tray holders which are made from just a flimsy bit of plastic - reminds me of those clear egg cartons you sometimes get. Should have been proper, tough plastic tray holders, like other digipaks. My plastic trays have not come away from the cardboard yet, but I'm sure they will in a few days time.

My PF has to go back anyway as one of the disks cracked during transit (no surprise really considering the poor packaging). :( At least it's CD-WOW though, so they'll send me another one immediately and let me return this one at my leisure :D
 

Oblivion

Standard Member
My PF has to go back anyway as one of the disks cracked during transit
Would it be the second disk by any chance??

I have just closely checked both my copies and the second disks on both titles have huge cracks going from the inside to the outside edge :mad:

I wont blame play because they were posted the same as always and after over a 100 discs from them this is the first I have recieved damaged. So will be calling them later to get a refund, which leads me to the next question.

My copies are Canadian R1 and distributed by aliance ( LOTR ) Is the R1 American version distributed by them aslo? if not who buy and is the packaging any better??

I have only used play for my R1 DVDs and know that their are many other online retailers. So who is the best for American soursed R1 DVDs? Cost and time of delivery are most important.

Paul
 
S

Squirrel God

Guest
Originally posted by Oblivion
Would it be the second disk by any chance??

I have just closely checked both my copies and the second disks on both titles have huge cracks going from the inside to the outside edge :mad:
No, mine was the feature disk (disk 1). Same place as yours by the sound of it. Basically, the centre ring on my disk is cracked and the crack just edges onto the inner disk surface too.

Both of my Jackie Brown disks are fine.

Originally posted by Oblivion
I wont blame play because they were posted the same as always and after over a 100 discs from them this is the first I have recieved damaged. So will be calling them later to get a refund, which leads me to the next question.
I wouldn't blame Play either mate. Mine were bought from CD-WOW who use far better packaging than Play and I still ended up with one cracked disk. It's the digipaks themselves - they provide absolutely no support for the disks.
 
D

denonman

Guest
Want my advice? get the US versions (movietyme) not the canadian version (play, futureent, cdwow) as there IS a definite difference in quality. The US version is much heavier due to the fact they used proper card & heavier plastic on their cases, they are thicker too, plus the US PULP has the menu inside the alliance atlantic set does not.Corner cutting me thinks ...:mad: :mad:
 
D

denonman

Guest
OH and PS the canadian cases and discs have bloody frenchie all over them. :mad: why are the french always so angry? Their fishermen are angry, their lorry drivers are angry, their french traffic control are angry. WHY COULD'NT THEY BE THIS BLOODY ANGRY 60 YEARS AGO WHEN IT COULD HAVE DONE A BIT OF GOOD?
 

Ian J

Banned
Originally posted by Squirrel God
Ian, That thread was about snapper cases ;)

Sorry, I quoted the wrong thread. I have deleted the reference to save me looking for it but the thread developed into a discussion between those pro and anti these types of case.

I can only recall that Lex liked them. My Pulp Fiction (complete with French Writing) arrived yesterday and I must admit I quite liked the packaging.
 

Ian J

Banned
Originally posted by denonman
WHY COULD'NT THEY BE THIS BLOODY ANGRY 60 YEARS AGO WHEN IT COULD HAVE DONE A BIT OF GOOD?

I don't know what history book you have been reading but I think that you'll find they were a bit cross.
 
D

denonman

Guest
yeah but what did they do about it apart from bend over & asy bieunividue hitler
 
G

GearHead

Guest
The region 1 (Canadian) packaging for these disks is poor I agree.

However, being realistic 99.999% of the time they are just going to be sandwiched amongst the rest of your collection and the only time they will get handled before they are replaced by the next latest and greatest format is the five or six times you get them out to play them.
 

Ron240

Well-known Member
Originally posted by captaineyecatch
Has anyone watched Pulp - is it fully uncut now??
I got mine yesterday morning from Play. Im not impressed with the packaging or French writing all over it. I would rate the pakaging the same as Speed and Predator.I wish they would stick to Amaray cases.
I looked specifically for the only scene that i knew was cut in the UK release,the blood in the syringe,and yes it is there.
 
S

Squirrel God

Guest
Originally posted by Ian J
Sorry, I quoted the wrong thread. I have deleted the reference to save me looking for it but the thread developed into a discussion between those pro and anti these types of case.
:kisses: ;)
Originally posted by Ian J
I can only recall that Lex liked them. My Pulp Fiction (complete with French Writing) arrived yesterday and I must admit I quite liked the packaging.
I love the French and all their writing. It adds an extra touch of class to the covers I think. :D

Yeah I like the packaging per se, with the nice artwork, foldout nature, etc; just a little disappointed with the flimsy nature of it. Tucked in among the other DVDs on my shelf (in alphanumerical order of course :D), it'll get a little crushed too. I shall have to take extra care with it. Naturally though, I wouldn't dream of paying extra money for the US version, just to get better packaging.

CD-WOW shipped me a replacement yesterday so I hope my new "Fiction Pulpeuse" arrives undamaged this time :D
 
S

Squirrel God

Guest
Got my replacement Pulp Fiction from CD-WOW this morning and both disks have arrived safely this time
clap.gif
The trays on this one seem to be glued down better too :)
 

BIONIC MAN

Member
I also got my Pulp & Jackie from CD-WOW and I have to agree
that the Cases are S***T ,
There is one Thing with Jackie Brown on the back of case is states the Picture is 2.35 when when I tryed it looked more like
1.85 ? ? is the wording wrong ? ?

Anyone had some problem ,

One last thing is the Usa disc's the same as Canada apart from
the cases ,

:D
 

-Spike-

Well-known Member
No it's not just you, got my Jackie Brown from Future Ent-says 2.35 on the case but looks more like 1.78 on my pj.

Received this and Pulp Fiction on Saturday with all discs loose inside. No scratches luckily

Regards
 

Confucius

Active Member
Appalling packaging .

I'm not sure if digipack is a trade name or genre, but I don't think I'd call it a digipack anyway - a cheap, tacky, poorly made digipack rip-off maybe, but not a digipack.

The disc 'holding' system is a joke (both discs loose on arrival - no scratches though), and the gloss finish of the card is very cheap looking.

On inspection the logos suggest to me that this is an Alliance Atlantis Communications 'exclusive'. No need to worry about proper digipacks from other studios using this design I'd say.

I just hope Alliance don't have the rights to many more tv shows and movies that I'd like to own.
 
S

Squirrel God

Guest
Jackie Brown was filmed in 1.85:1 and Pulp Fiction was filmed in 2.35:1, so that's what they should be on the disks (I haven't played mine yet).
 
R

RichMercer

Guest
Originally posted by Ron240

I got mine yesterday morning from Play. Im not impressed with the packaging or French writing all over it. I would rate the pakaging the same as Speed and Predator.I wish they would stick to Amaray cases.
I looked specifically for the only scene that i knew was cut in the UK release,the blood in the syringe,and yes it is there.
I've got the original no thrills Region 2 release of Pulp which I bought two years ago or so. That has the blood in the syringe:confused: You sure it was cut?
 
V

videonastie

Guest
Is this the US Region 1 version with the pic of Uma Thurman peeking through the leather looking case?

What is the Region 2 packaging like?
 

The latest video from AVForums

Oculus Quest 2 VR headset + Rotel A14 MkII Amp Reviews & Best of the Month
Subscribe to our YouTube channel

Latest News

JBL announces L52 Classic speaker and L75ms all-in-one
  • By Andy Bassett
  • Published
Sony Bravia XR X95J TV range gets 65-inch model in August
  • By Andy Bassett
  • Published
What was new on Blu-ray for July 2021
  • By Mark Costello
  • Published
Samsung QD-OLED TVs primed for 2022 launch?
  • By Andy Bassett
  • Published
Sky to add NBCUniversal's Peacock service
  • By Andy Bassett
  • Published

Full fat HDMI teeshirts

Support AVForums with Patreon

Top Bottom