Philips 963SA Vs Pro-V Vs HCPC

J

Jonny1973

Guest
My Sony 735 DVD player is almost dead. What should I replace it with?

I have a HCPC which gives a great picture in WIDE480 but I don't like the inconvenience.

The 735 and a Pro-V gives a pretty good picture but not as good as the HCPC, still good though.

Would a Philips 963SA using Prog Scan via component be better than the Pro-V???

My other option is buy a cheap player with S-Video out and continue to use the Pro-V.

Has anyone tried the 963SA with the Panny AE100???
 

Timh

Well-known Member
Hi Jonny

I have compared progressive scan from my Toshiba sd-510 against the s-video output from the 510 into the ProV, IMHO the Prov will no where near match the picture quality of a Progressive dvd player.
The ProV displays Jaggies shimmering pixel blead and odd streaking lines on fast moving objects, you get none of these with a good progressive player like the 963sa.
If you have the cash go treat your self to the 963 (£335), I know I would :)

Or you could maybe go for the new Limit 9900 (£200) which also offers prog pal, but you new that.
 
J

Jonny1973

Guest
Hi Tim,

I've heard bad things about the Limit player on here.

Unbeatable have the 963 for 317.96 inc VAT +7.99 P&P.

Did you compare your Prog Scan player against a HCPC?
 

Timh

Well-known Member
Did you compare your Prog Scan player against a HCPC?
Yes I did, but only for a short time, the HCPC offers the best image quality, no scaling, but you do get some scaling with the progressive players via componant, its still a great picture though.
I just coudn't do with all the hassle of using a HCPC, I want it simple but with good image quality, thats why I opted for the Toshiba sd-510, wish I had waited now, because of the Philips 963 sa which is only £30 more than what I payed for the 510 :(
I think I might wait for a progressive scan dvd recorder for under £500 before I upgrade again, I am currently on my Third DVD player.
 

Technophobe

Standard Member
Timh

Any sign of the 963 hitting UK stores in significant numbers yet?
I'm still interested in the 963 scaling potential to 720P.

Technophobe
 

Timh

Well-known Member
Originally posted by Technophobe
Timh

Any sign of the 963 hitting UK stores in significant numbers yet?
I'm still interested in the 963 scaling potential to 720P.

Technophobe
Your guess is as good as mine, it was reported in another thread that dixons would be stocking them.
 

Guest
I'm still interested in the 963 scaling potential to 720P

I don't think the 963SA HAS any scaling potential to scale to 720P.

To clarify - yes the Faroudja chipset supports this mode, but the surrounduing electronics also have to support this mode (especially the video DACs) and I don't believe that Philips have built this level of redundancy into the player.

The 720P mode of the Faroudja is aimed for at the internal de-interlacer Projection market I feel, rather than at players.
 

Technophobe

Standard Member
Puddleduck

Good points,
Any idea where I could find out what Video DACs it uses, and how much frame store memory philips have fitted?
If all the supporting H/W is present it should be a simple matter of altering the internal register configuration of the chip, which is done by a serial I/F. I was hoping to use a PIC microcontroller or perhaps a PAL to take over the chips configuration.

Technophobe
 

Rookies

Distinguished Member
Your 735 sony nearly dead, What up wiv it? Aint that old is it?
 
J

Jonny1973

Guest
Originally posted by Rookies
Your 735 sony nearly dead, What up wiv it? Aint that old is it?
The picture stutters, breaks up and gets C:13:00 errors. This is a common problem with Sony players and it's pretty much fatal. There was a lawsuit in the USA over this.

The player is 3 years old but has been playing up for the last 18 months. It cost £500 new.

I will never buy another Sony DVD player ever again.
 

Rookies

Distinguished Member
Oh :S

I was thinking of getting a Sony 905 dvd player in the next few days now your comments about this error and wont buy a sony ever again have now put me off it. Do you know if sony have corrected this problem?
 
J

Jonny1973

Guest
Originally posted by Rookies
Oh :S

I was thinking of getting a Sony 905 dvd player in the next few days now your comments about this error and wont buy a sony ever again have now put me off it. Do you know if sony have corrected this problem?
It's not the sort of thing they would admit to. Try searching for "C:13:00" in the forums for other peoples woes.

C:13:00 is basically read error caused by dirty discs or laser failure.

I believe the repair would cost around £100 for a new laser which i'm not prepared to pay when I could get a new player for that or upgrade to prog scan for another £200.
 

jonny m

Standard Member
Jonny1973
The 735 and a Pro-V gives a pretty good picture but not as good as the HCPC, still good though.
If you think that then the 963 will blow you away when used via prog scan component out.

I've used both svideo + prog scan and the prog scan component is significantly better as it uses 13-bit dacs + the next generation fl2310 chipset, the colour detail it pulls out of the image is amazing.

Also the dcdi de-interlacing is miles better than the prov. With dcdi any diagonal lines are prefectly smooth.

John
 

Timh

Well-known Member
Jonny m
the colour detail it pulls out of the image is amazing.
Stop it! I can't afford one yet :( ;)

I also get the C:13:00 message on my Daughters $ony player, only on one disc so far, but the disc looks mint.
 

MontyUK

Standard Member
Originally posted by Jonny1973
Hi Tim,

I've heard bad things about the Limit player on here.
You have ??? I've read minor problems regarding the remote control, but everything I've read about the performance of the Limit suggests it's absolutely amazing value for money, and an incredibly good picture in both PAL and NTSC using prog scan . . .

Monty.
 

richard plumb

Distinguished Member
I have the 963 and an AE100, and the picture is fantastic. I haven't tried HCPC yet, but it is quite a lot better than interlaced s-video into a ProV. The ProV is great for terrestrial TV and my games consoles etc, and probably good enough for DVD, but progressive scan component is better.
 

Guest
The layer change on the 963 is very good - probably a 2 or 3 frame pause.

MUCH faster than my Pioneer 737.
 

richard plumb

Distinguished Member
mmm. Layer change is OK - much improved over my pioneer DV505, but still noticable.

With my old player it was like - oh, its paused for a second or two, must be the layer change.

With the philips its like 'wha-oh, layer change'. As soon as I notice that its frozen, its continued again.

Still waiting for the mythical 'no layer change' machine. You'd think it'd be easy really...
 

Rookies

Distinguished Member
Dunno if I am right or not. Someone was telling me yesterday that the Sony 905 is hard to spot the layer change. Cos it got a twin laser or somthing? I aint saying this is correct as I aint a clue just somthing I was told.

Maybe one of you can shed some light on this?
 

Donnacha

Distinguished Member
Its one of the reasons I'm still tempted by HCPC - no noticeable layer change!

Still is it worth the HCPC hassle for a seamless movie experience?
 

Rookies

Distinguished Member
Sorry if I sound thick here but I am pretty new to this. i do know abit but not alot like most of you do.

What is HCPC
 
J

Jonny1973

Guest
HCPC. Home Cinema PC. Any PC with a DVD-ROM drive and a soundcard (usually capable of dolby digital 5.1)

Play the DVD on your PC and connect it to a projector using a VGA cable.

By setting the PC resolution to the same as the projector panel , you get a perfect picture and avoid using the projectors internal scaler.
 

Similar threads

The latest video from AVForums

Podcast: Samsung HW-Q950T Soundbar Review, Filmmaker Mode, Disney+ $30 for Mulan, AV news and more

Trending threads

Latest News

AVForums Podcast: 9th August 2020
  • By Phil Hinton
  • Published
Linn announces Majik DSM digital streamer upgrade
  • By Andy Bassett
  • Published
Sony announces WH-1000XM4 noise cancelling headphones
  • By Andy Bassett
  • Published
McIntosh launches C22 Mk V preamp and MC1502 power amplifier
  • By Andy Bassett
  • Published
Marantz unveils 12 Series Special Edition models
  • By Andy Bassett
  • Published
Top Bottom