How do you know people are blindly calling for it? How can you claim to know all the details of people's lives?
The EU dictates taxation in many areas.
There has to be a tax on energy use. You couldn't make pensioners exempt from paying tax on heating even if you want to.
It controls tax on fuel. You can't reduce tax on fuel in rural garages. People in rural garages need a garage as it can be their supermarket and because otherwise they might have to drive miles to fill up. If you wanted to help out rural garages by having them set less tax on fuel and have more money to stay in business you can't.
VAT is governed by EU and the upper and lower rates it is set at. The UK can't voluntarily remove VAT on tampons.
The UK couldn't individually have stronger regulations on children's clothing regarded as fancy dress regarding being fire proof. Fancy dress clothes were regarded as toys.
To bring about any kind of change required a long process of being agreed by all member states. A countries sovereign government can change things incredibly rapidly if necessary.
The UK government is directly accountable to its people. As a result some things brought in in a budget were scrapped in less than 24 hours. A UK government is very aware it can be voted out.
When we leave the current UK proposal regarding our farming is that farmers will have to be more eco friendly to continue to get subsidys. Something those on the environment side have pushed for for years and never happened. In the past France blocked any such proposal as their farmers used to spray merde round Paris to prevent it happening.
Want more?
Thanks for your summary. Not sure it needed the aggressive sign off but I appreciate the effort.
That's the first I've read about the EU taxation laws so I've just done some investigations. From my first search, I brought back two particular results which address the statement of the EU forcing the UK VAT.
Result one - Daily Telegraph Article from June 2016;
We cannot set fair taxes as long as Britain remains in the EU
Clearly a passionate anti-EU article that leads with the headline, "
We cannot set fair taxes as long as Britain is in the EU". It lays out a similar argument to the one you put above and specifically highlights the "
Tampon tax", and reduced tax rates on domestic fuel then leads on to a bit of a ramble about Corporation Tax avoidance and the EU taking sides with the companies attempting to avoid tax (rather than focusing on the actual companies themselves?). But, the underlying theme of the article is that the EU forces the UK to set higher tax rates because it's part of the same club. Ok, seems like a pretty conclusive article. However, there's a summary box at the bottom which states;
***********************************************************************
At a glance | What Brexit will mean for… your money, investments and currency
- UK taxes and state pensions are set by the UK Government, so there is no change anticipated in those areas.
- Isas are exclusive to the UK too, so would not be at risk.
- The Financial Services Compensation Scheme protects deposits of up to £75,000 per bank, and £50,000 at investment and mortgage firms. Compensation limits are harmonised across the EU. After leaving, the UK would have free reign to raise or lower these.
- It is unclear exactly what the UK equity markets will do in the run up to Brexit. For example, falls in the value of the pound could stand to benefit companies with high proportions of foreign income. However, domestically focused sectors would stand to fall, and there would be a fog of trade uncertainty to contend with.
- Uncertainty may hold back British markets in the run up to Brexit. Markets could also be swayed by credible polls or information that show a change to the status-quo as the date grows near.
***********************************************************************
I've highlighted the first statement. So, which one is it?
The second alternative result I got from the same search is a BBC 'Reality Check' article;
Does the EU control UK VAT rates?
This begins by summarising the option available to the UK Government (that it chooses not to implement)
**************************************************************************
Reality Check verdict: EU rules mean the UK cannot reduce VAT on goods and services below 15%, the standard rate of VAT in the EU. The standard rate of VAT in the UK is 20%, so
the government could reduce it by up to 5% today if it wanted. Domestic fuel is on a special list of pre-approved goods and services that are subject to lower VAT rates and it would require the agreement of all other EU members to reduce it further.
****************************************************************************
It also addresses the "Tampon Tax" and it appears that the proposal to cut that tax to 0% has been agreed with by EU and is being progressed?
"The EU is currently dealing with allowing the UK to lower the VAT on sanitary products to 0%. The EU finance ministers have endorsed the plan, which the European Commission pledged to finalise in 2016."
According to what I can find, the tax on sanitary products was reduced to 5% in 2001 and is standardised across all EU member countries as part of the trading block, which is the point of the EU.