Is there a HD ONLY recorder?

Discussion in 'Blu-ray & DVD Players & Recorders' started by fuc847, Jul 10, 2004.

  1. fuc847


    Products Owned:
    Products Wanted:
    Hi, like most of you, i only plan on using the recorder as a TV recorder for shows etc. I personally dont really need to have them on any media, so are there any HD ONLY recorders (w/o the dvd record function).

    I'm looking for a price range of $300 CDN max

    However, I've been reading this 'DVD-RAM' thing, and it seems to be a cheap viable solution to what i want. Basically i buy a DVD RAM disk and just put it in the Recorder and leave it there forever(since it can rewrite many times w/o flaws) :p But do all DVD recorders support recording DVD RAM media..? I see lots of DVD-R and DVD-RWs, but not DVD-RAM...

    For people who have expierence in recording tv shows using dvds, are 'skipping' or 'errors' common while recording..? I mean, in PCs, lots of coasters happen during dvd record so i was wondering...

    ANd one more question, do the prices of such 'new' technology drop quickly..? Say if i waited for 2 or more months, how much would they drop do u think?

    I'm currently eyeing Panasonic DMR E55 right now.. but even that's $500 CDN :(
  2. Rasczak

    Distinguished Member

    Apr 3, 2002
    Products Owned:
    Products Wanted:
    Trophy Points:
    To be honest if you want to do this your probably better off with a dedicated HDD recorder as you get more capacity. Don't get me wrong, DVD-RAM recorders are excellent but if you just intend to use just one disk then you should consider other alternatives.

    The main benefits of DVD-RAM machines can be summerised as:
    - A one box soultion for DVD playback and HDD functionality.
    - Ability to transfer already editted recordings to a PC for for authoring on DVD-R.
    - Ability to record onto highly compatible DVD-R media
    - Ability to export from a camcorder/digital camera (some models only) onto DVD.

    From you post you don't seem to want to do any of this. So I would suggest a HDD standalone instead.

    No - but most of the machines from the major Japanese firms do, i.e. those machines from:
    - Panasonic
    - Toshiba
    - JVC
    - Samsung
    - Hitachi
    All write to DVD-RAM and DVD-R and several models (Toshiba and JVC) also write to DVD-RW.

    fuc847, I notice you quote a price in US Dollars - are you from North America? The only reason I ask is that these forums are UK based and much of the knowledge base/members only have experience in UK marketted equipment which can differ substantially in features and performance from it's North American equivalent. The HDD versus DVD-RAM explanation I have given above is as valid in the US as the UK - but I can't really suggest a HDD model that would suit you as I don't know what factors effect you most in the US. May I suggest looking at:
    I'm not trying to fob you off or anything but many of the issues that affect our purchases here are 'non-issues' in the US/Canada.

Share This Page

  1. This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
    By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.
    Dismiss Notice