I can't comment on either of those two specifically, but I can say that the first guitar I ever bought was an 80's Tokai Les Paul (love rock) and it is still one of the best feeling & sounding Les Paul's I've ever played, better than a lot of Gibson USA ones i've owned/played. The quality and construction is fantastic. I still own it to this day even tho I've got other real Gibsons
I know the recent (2000's) Tokai Les Paul's arent of quite the same quality as the 80's ones, but they are still better than a lot of the cheaper Les Paul copies, so I dont think you would be disappointed with the Tokai RG40. It's also got a more accurate-shaped headstock than the Indie