Fruit, completely good or a bit bad

KyleS1

Distinguished Member
So I know you need 5 a day or fruit and veg, and most should be made up of veg, but fruit is much easier to get more of.
So, this leads me on to, is too much fruit bad? I know you should limit citrus fruits due to high amounts of sugar, but what is a bad amount to eat? Are there any fruits that are completely good, and you can pretty much eat as much as you like, and on the other end of the scale, are there some that you really should avoid?
 

BT Bob

Distinguished Member
I think the sugars in all fruits mean they are a bit bad, to use your phrase. I think this is a particular problem with home-made smoothies - it's very easy to go overboard sugar-wise.

Having said that, I guess it's better to get your sugar intake from fruit, rather than a Mars bar ;)
 

Steven

Senior Moderator
Assuming you are talking about weight, you would have to be eating huge amounts as fruit is a low calorie density food (with some exceptions, e.g. avocado)
 

KyleS1

Distinguished Member
I guess for weight, but more specifically over consuming sugars.
 

Elrond

Member
I guess for weight, but more specifically over consuming sugars.
I would be more concerned about the sugar as it can be quite high. I got a fruit smoothie for lunch once in Sainsburys meal deal and while sitting at my desk I noticed that the sugar contents were somewhere between 40-50% of the RDA. Plain apple juice was just as bad at around 35% I think and that's because the sugars occur naturally in fruit.

On a side note, I dread to think what the sweet and sour chicken balls I had for dinner did for my daily sugar intake after I noticed the RDA on the apple juice I had drunk earlier in the day :rolleyes:
 

Steven

Senior Moderator
Fruit is still a low and natural source of fructose compared to the quantities in pre-packaged food

In terms of moderation I apply common sense
 

GBDG1

Distinguished Member
So I know you need 5 a day or fruit and veg, and most should be made up of veg, but fruit is much easier to get more of.
So, this leads me on to, is too much fruit bad? I know you should limit citrus fruits due to high amounts of sugar, but what is a bad amount to eat? Are there any fruits that are completely good, and you can pretty much eat as much as you like, and on the other end of the scale, are there some that you really should avoid?
Depends what you're looking to achieve. Most people are overweight because they eat loads of crap. Chocolate, pies, fried food etc. It's defo not caused by eating too much fruit.

In fact, if most people swapped off their crappy food for fruit, they would not be overweight.

However, if you want to go beyond just being a healthy weight, and achieve a very low % body fat, then the amount of fruit you eat does start to be something to watch.

In terms of which things are better than others, berries in all forms, melon and other things are high water.
 

YankTank

Well-known Member
12 ounces of >>>>>>> Coca-Cola Orange Juice Apple Juice Cherry Juice Grape Juice
Total carbohydrates 40 g 39 g 42 g 49.5 g 60 g
Carbs from sugar 40 g 33 g 39 g 37.5 g 58.5 g
Sugar (teaspoons) 10 tsp 8 tsp 10 tsp 9 tsp 15 tsp
Calories 145 165 165 210 240

I think the table makes interesting reading - OK, I appreciate the table talks about Juice, not whole fruit, and thus there is a significant difference in sugar content; I think anyone looking to reduce their weight definitely needs to be mindful as to how much fruit/what type of fruit they are consuming. Its also worth remembering that depending on if fruit is 'juice' or 'whole', will effect its GI - lower GI, slower release of energy - higher GI, faster release of energy and higher insulin reaction.

Sorry, table came out bad - but just track the columns along !

Often people say - 'well, we have been eating fruit just like this for years'...well, we haven't!....... for the most part. Fruit (and loads of other stuff) is nowadays considerably different, since growers have modified crops to make them, plumper, larger, juicier, sweeter etc etc......so its not the same ! Same as man has done with wheat/grain etc etc.
 
Last edited:

KyleS1

Distinguished Member
I'm not necessarily looking to achieve anything really. Nothing that adding some cardio to my weekly activities wouldn't fix. I was more just curious as I eat a fair amount of fruit. On a typical day I will eat a banana, an apple and a couple of oranges (satsumas/clementines). I snack a lot throughout the day as I get a lot of boredom hunger (I would on a computer all day), so have always just snacked on fruit or a low fat yog, occasionally a few nuts, but the more reading I do, the more it suggests that eating too much fruit, even though it is obviously more healthy than crisps etc, can cause weight gain. Also the combination of the sugars in fruit, and carbs in other foods.
 

nwgarratt

Member
Eat as much or little fruit as you want. Sugar doesn't bother me as there is much more benefits in the vitamins and minerals. If you want to stick to low sugar ones then eat berries. My favourites just happen to be the medium to high sugar ones - apples, bananas, pineapple.

With regards to fruit juice, have the ones without added sugar and low in calories (12 calories per glass). Tesco Light Choices do Cranberry, Cranberry and Raspberry, Orange, Apple.
 

KyleS1

Distinguished Member
I rarely drink juice, it's just fruit I was referring to really.

It appears I also like the fruits high in sugar. I didn't realise bananas were high in sugar though.
 

mpn

Banned
I have one pre gym banana every day. After that the only fruits I eat are blueberries and blackberries. However I tend not to worry too much with regards to sugar in fruits as its all natural.
 

KyleS1

Distinguished Member
My wallet won't allow for blueberries everyday. You get so little for so much cost, plus my daughter seems to inhale them at a rate of knots. If I started eating them daily too, I'd go broke! :)
 

reiteration

Member
12 ounces of >>>>>>> Coca-Cola Orange Juice Apple Juice Cherry Juice Grape Juice
Total carbohydrates 40 g 39 g 42 g 49.5 g 60 g
Carbs from sugar 40 g 33 g 39 g 37.5 g 58.5 g
Sugar (teaspoons) 10 tsp 8 tsp 10 tsp 9 tsp 15 tsp
Calories 145 165 165 210 240

I think the table makes interesting reading - OK, I appreciate the table talks about Juice, not whole fruit, and thus there is a significant difference in sugar content; I think anyone looking to reduce their weight definitely needs to be mindful as to how much fruit/what type of fruit they are consuming. Its also worth remembering that depending on if fruit is 'juice' or 'whole', will effect its GI - lower GI, slower release of energy - higher GI, faster release of energy and higher insulin reaction.

Sorry, table came out bad - but just track the columns along !

Often people say - 'well, we have been eating fruit just like this for years'...well, we haven't!....... for the most part. Fruit (and loads of other stuff) is nowadays considerably different, since growers have modified crops to make them, plumper, larger, juicier, sweeter etc etc......so its not the same ! Same as man has done with wheat/grain etc etc.
yeah, exactly, it's just the modern day supermarket that has allowed us to get say bananas in every village / town etc at any time of the year...think back to the 70s for example... and then times before that...

just my thoughts anyway :)
 
Last edited:

KyleS1

Distinguished Member
and how far will 120g get you?
Plus I don't shop at Lidl so would be an extra trip... :)
 

nwgarratt

Member
My wallet won't allow for blueberries everyday. You get so little for so much cost, plus my daughter seems to inhale them at a rate of knots. If I started eating them daily too, I'd go broke! :)
£1 for 125g blueberries from Iceland or on offer at Tesco/Morrison's. More than 125g and the go soggy before they are eaten.

125g can last a few days.
 

KyleS1

Distinguished Member
We do pick them up a lot in Tesco's for our daughter, and I do steal a fair few of them. I might try and supplement the apples/oranges for berries and see how the shopping bill looks at the end of the month. :)
A tub that size would only last me 2 days I would imagine. 120g isn't much.
 

KyleS1

Distinguished Member
Time is of the essence! :)
 

sniffer66

Distinguished Member
It appears I also like the fruits high in sugar. I didn't realise bananas were high in sugar though.
pretty sure I read somewhere that the riper the nana the higher the sugar as well

I try to eat em greenish but not easy to stop them ripening in this weather
 

KyleS1

Distinguished Member
pretty sure I read somewhere that the riper the nana the higher the sugar as well

I try to eat em greenish but not easy to stop them ripening in this weather
But when they are greenish, they are unripe and are starchy. The body has trouble breaking down starch - What Happens When I Eat An Unripe Banana? | LIVESTRONG.COM

But you are right about them ripening and having more sugar. The link above confirms that but says it is limited to certain species.
 

nwgarratt

Member
pretty sure I read somewhere that the riper the nana the higher the sugar as well

I try to eat em greenish but not easy to stop them ripening in this weather
I ignore that. I can't eat green ones as they are too hard. I have a banana everyday. A decent size one will give 10% of the daily recommended amount of potassium.
 

IronGiant

Moderator
But when they are greenish, they are unripe and are starchy. The body has trouble breaking down starch - What Happens When I Eat An Unripe Banana? | LIVESTRONG.COM

But you are right about them ripening and having more sugar. The link above confirms that but says it is limited to certain species.
your link said:
If you like yours green rather than ripe, you're eating a larger quantity of indigestible starches and fewer easily digested sugars. This can cause bloating, abdominal cramps, flatulence and diarrhea.

Read more: http://www.livestrong.com/article/523547-what-happens-when-i-eat-an-unripe-banana/#ixzz24C3RWW3H
In contrast to that link others say this resistant starch is supposed to be good for you: eg: Why You Should Eat Green Bananas | Aviva.ca

Eat whichever you like I say :)
 
Last edited:

KyleS1

Distinguished Member
I like them somewhere in the middle. Nice and firm, but not hard, and defo not mushy - fnar fnar. :)
 

Similar threads

The latest video from AVForums

Podcast: Samsung HW-Q950T Soundbar Review, Filmmaker Mode, Disney+ $30 for Mulan, AV news and more

Latest News

NAD launches T 758 V3i surround sound receiver
  • By Andy Bassett
  • Published
Sky unveils next tranche of HDR content
  • By Andy Bassett
  • Published
Acoustic Energy launches AE520 flagship speakers
  • By Andy Bassett
  • Published
Disney drops all 20th Century Fox branding
  • By Andy Bassett
  • Published
Kitsound launches Funk 25 wireless earphones
  • By Andy Bassett
  • Published
Top Bottom