Directors Commentaries

wither2000

Novice Member
I've recently expanded my DVD collection from around 20 films which I watched, then I watched the extras, then the commentaries by the driectors and crew etc. I now have around 100 films and have spent much more time just watching and enjoying the films, and have hardly watched any extras. Spending a couple of hours watching a commentary can be great - I enjoyed the Sam Mendes commentary on American Beauty almost as much as I enjoyed the film - which I love:clap:

Other films with commentary which I have enjoyed have been things like Donnie Darko where the film has alternate meanings to different people and its good to hear the directors take on things.

So are there any commentaries you really enjoyed or found enhanced your understanding of the film that you'd recommend sitting through? :smashin:
Alternatively - who are the directors that add nothing to their work on celluloid by talking over it?:boring:

Ian.
 

Rambo John J

Distinguished Member
Commentary by cast/crew on Evil Dead 2 is good, The Thing and Escape From New York (Russell/Carpenter on both), the original release of Alien had a good solo one by Ridley Scott, the Tom Savini commentary on the UK release of Dawn of the Dead's another good one. David Fincher always does some good ones mixing techie stuff with stories although his group commentaries have the edge (Se7en, Fight Club) on his solo ones (Panic Room).
Solaris (remake) had a very good one with Soderberg and James Cameron. Terry Giliam's always good value too (Time Bandits and Fear and Loathing in Las Vegas spring to mind).

Thos are some standout ones I can think of anyway.

Avoid Tim Burton though, he's a cure for insomnia if ever I've heard one
 
A

Azrikam

Guest
Kevin Smith is usually great (Mallrats in particular), but he really "phoned it in" on the Clerks DVD, IMO.
 

Rambo John J

Distinguished Member
Originally posted by Azrikam
Kevin Smith is usually great (Mallrats in particular), but he really "phoned it in" on the Clerks DVD, IMO.
was the clerks one where they were doing it during a break in filming Mallrats, with Jason Mewes comatose on the floor for half the track?
iirc it sounded like they were all crowded into one of those chemical toilets
 
F

FoxyMulder

Guest
I always find Ridley Scott commentaries entertaining.

Bruce Campbell's commentary on The Evil Dead is very good :)

I also like any John Carpenter/Kurt Russell commentary track as those guys together are so funny and informative and i agree about Verhoeven he does pretty good one's.
 
C

cosmokramer2004

Guest
By far the funniest/oddest commentary i've listened to is for Blood Simple.

Worth buying the DVD for the commentary alone! The movie itself is an astounding 1st effort from the Coen bros.
 

cybersoga

Novice Member
The commentary track on Dark City (R1) by film critic Roger Ebert is interesting to listen to as is the track on Fight Club SE (R1) from writer Chuck Palahniuk. On more cerebral movies i'm more interested in how the story came about rather than how they made the special effects. Donnie Darko is another one with great commentary.
 

Miyazaki

Novice Member
I like the commentary on 'Solaris', it's really good.
 
D

DamH

Guest
Guy Ritchie's and Matthew Vaughan's commentary on Snatch is appalling. Easily the worst I've heard.

There is even a bit where the recording is stopped and they are told to say something interesting or relevant, which Guy then mentions when the recording is started again.
 

RobTheLegend

Well-known Member
Hi
I really like the commentary on R1 Memento se,
When it gets to the last 15 minutes or so the disc branches in to one of 3 different commentaries!
Really enjoyed that.
Rob
 
A

Azrikam

Guest
Originally posted by Rambo John J
was the clerks one where they were doing it during a break in filming Mallrats, with Jason Mewes comatose on the floor for half the track?
iirc it sounded like they were all crowded into one of those chemical toilets
Yeah, Smith imparts some decent information, but he just seems ready to fall asleep.

The Red Dwarf commentaries are interesting just to realise how little the actors know about the show. :laugh:
 

DVD-Man

Well-known Member
Thought I'd bring this thread back to include some of my favourite commentaries and why

John McTiernan - Die Hard, Predator & HFRO - informative stories about making the film and cast.

Jim Cameron - Terminator 2 EE - The weird dual channel stero commentary with someone else - informative over and above what you already know about the film

John Carpenter - Halloween, The Thing, Escape from New York, Big Touble in Little China - often not alone but funny and informative

Paul Verhoeven & Co - Robocop DC - crazy commentary with the three trying to talk over each another, sounds crazy but works

Henry Hill and former FBI Agent Edward mcDonald - Goodfellas SE - not a director but informative

Thats just a small selection, I could go on at length erm maybe I'll post up more of my faves but for now I'll say that I found the following boring!

Roger Donaldson - any commentary by this Aussie, sleep inducing.

Russel Crowe and Ridley Scott on Gladiator, hmmmm just didn't grab me.

Liam
 

domtheone

Distinguished Member
Like the commentary by Martin Campbell on Goldeneye.

John Carpenter/Kurt Russell on The Think is a classic:D

Ridley Scott is usually good value. Alien one is very good.

Apollo 13 as well.

Enjoyed the commentaries on The Omen and Superman too (Richard Donner).
 

nwgarratt

Member
I can't listen to commentaries in the normal way. I prefer to rip them to a mp3 player and listen to them in the car.

My favourite was Freddy v Jason with Robert Englund and the Director Ronny Yu.
 

Mendes

Well-known Member
I enjoyed the LOTR EE and the Bubba Ho Tep commentries, even the one by 'The King' himself........
 
Yeah, The Evil Dead commentary is good. I haven't listened to many.

One Foot In The Grave... The Beast In The Cage.. is a good commentary.
 

the_pauley

Banned
Best audio commentaries in the world are from John Waters. Hilarious - both on his own movies and on other people's films, where he's been roped in on several occasions to deliver a commentary where the original director is dead.
 

Knyght_byte

Novice Member
The Red Dwarf ones are superb IMHO.
definitely :D

altho i found the first series to be the best for this.....
Black Books is another good TV series commentary to listen to...


filmwise, i'd say its a toss up between Oceans 11 and Fight Club as my favourites...with the actors doing it that is.....directors commentaries dont interest me so much usually.....not unless its a very directorial type film as opposed to a generic hollywood blockbuster......

cant remember which others i've listened to now....got so many films...lol....a lot i wouldnt bother with the commentaries tho.....watch the other extras however....
 

featherhall

Distinguished Member
I enjoyed the '7even' commentary (on the SE).
It has 4 commentaries, but the one with David Fincher, Brad Pitt and Morgan Freeman is brilliant. :thumbsup:
 

Similar threads

The latest video from AVForums

Podcast: LCD TVs for Movies, Physical Discs?, RIP Ennio Morricone, AV & Movie news, B+W Matt Damon

Trending threads

Latest News

AVForums Podcast: 12th July 2020
  • By Phil Hinton
  • Published
QDC Blue Dragon earphones on sale in UK
  • By Andy Bassett
  • Published
TV licence fee now applies to over 75s from 1st Aug
  • By Andy Bassett
  • Published
New H.266 video codec promises 50 percent data saving
  • By Andy Bassett
  • Published
Toshiba launches UL20 4K HDR TVs from £299
  • By Andy Bassett
  • Published
Top Bottom