Quantcast

Cart upgrades

Just Old

Banned
I am currently using a Rega 3-24 with AT95e cart,PM7001 amp, and MA RX8 silver.
I like the sound, and detail is good.
Is it worth upgrading the cart and if it is what benifits would I get?
My other thought is that if I should upgrade, how do you go about ensuring you purchase the best cartridge for the set up and your personal sound preference?
Can you audition carts?

It seems at the moment for me a bit pot luck, picking one.

I would appreciate any views you have.
 

Mr Pig

Novice Member
It seems at the moment for me a bit pot luck, picking one.
It usually is with carts. It's hard to dem them. The best option is to ask for something like what you have, but better!

The AT95e is an ok cart actually but it's the baseline for a Hi-Fi cart more or less. So yes, upgrading it should give you a better sound. What I would do it take your time and buy a new cart when the AT wears out. That way you'll have plenty of time to gather information and hopefully pick the right cart.

Virtually any other cart will sound different from the AT though so there is never a guarantee you'll like it.
 

BlueWizard

Distinguished Member
Unless I'm mistaken the cartridge is an Audio Technica AT95E ... correct? That is worth about £40 -

Superfi - AUDIO TECHNICA AT95E MOVING MAGNET CARTRIDGE

As to the turntable, can you give us some perspective on how much this turntable cost? Is Rega 3-24 the full model number? Is it the RP3? Is it a P3-24? How old is the turntable? Does it have an clear acrylic platter?

Do you know anything about the tone arm? Does it have a separate model number?

I'm guessing the nearest current model would be the RP3 which sells for about £500.

For a turntable like that, you need a much better cartridge. I would say the cartridge needs to be between half the cost of the turntable to equal to the cost of the turntable. Though, if your budget is tight, cartridges in the £75 to £150 range are in something of the sweet spot.

One good choice is the £79 Ortofon 2M Red Moving Magnet cartridge; very high critical acclaim in its price range.

Personally, though a few details are missing, I would never consider a £40 cartridge on a £500 turntable.

I've got a turntable that originally cost me about £200, though that was many years ago, and it has a cartridge worth about £110.

The cartridge that comes with the new RP3 models is the Rega Elys 2 which sells for about £115. That gives you some idea of the range of cartridges an turntable like this should have.

But then, that's just my opinion.

Steve/bluewizard
 
Last edited:

coruja

Novice Member
Also depends on what music you predominantly listen to, as some carts, for example, can be good with rock but not so great with classical, and some are all rounders.

I wouldn't go above £250 max for a moving magnet cart on your TT.

At each price range the available carts will be better built and the sound quality will improve but they will all sound different. Tell us your budget first then go on from there.

You're right about demoing carts - now there a business model just waiting to be taken up, ranted about this often enough!
 
Last edited:

Just Old

Banned
Thank's for the replys
to clarify
It's a Rega P3-24 TT with the RB301 tone arm fitted.
Usually listen to everything except classical.

The TT cost was listed at arrd £500, but a new model was introduced so I got this in clearance.

It originally had the elys2 fitted but I already had a brand new AT95E, so didn't need the Elyse, and it reduced the cost of the TT package....the other point was that reviews of the Elyse were not very good,,,but this sells for arrd £115.

Would I have liked the elys 2 sound.....who know?

As for budget...the next upgrade in cartridges from the AT 9E that will give sound improvement, clarity etc
Hence my question.
 
Last edited:

BlueWizard

Distinguished Member
Once again, at £79 the Ortofon 2M Red is highly rated, though there are two or three models above that in the 2M series.

Alternates would be the Grado Prestige series. Personally, I would consider nothing less than the Grado Prestige GOLD at £130. The Ortofon 2M Blue is about £155. Blue is one step above Red.

While I say, a cartridge should be from half to equal to the cost of the turntable, in reality, I personally would look at cartridges in the £100 to roughly £150 range. This is typically what I've had, and they seem to work very well. I currently have the now very rare Stanton 681EE. I like the sound of Stanton, but they have all but abandon the HiFi market in favor of DJ cartridges.

If I were doing it again today, the Grado Gold or the Ortofon 2M Blue would be at the top of my list.

I also agree that there isn't that much point in going over about £250 for a moving magnet cartridge. That would be the equivalent of the Ortofon 2M Bronze (£279) or the Grado Reference Platinum 1 (£255).

Steve/bluewizard
 

Mr Pig

Novice Member
While I say, a cartridge should be from half to equal to the cost of the turntable...
I use a Linn LP12 and my Denon DL103 cartridge costs about £150. A new turntable of the same sort of quality as mine would cost around three-grand...
 

BlueWizard

Distinguished Member
Denon DL103, is that one of the High Output MC cartridges? I was disappointed when Denon discontinued the 160 HO-MC. I heard nothing but raves about that cartridge.

As to today's prices, I bought my turntable back in 1978, using in on-line caculator, in today's money, it would cost about £800. Though, I think in modern turntables in today's market, I could top it with a pure manual TT for that price.

Mine is a very basic, second from the bottom of the line, Pioneer PL-35A, which is not remotely in the same league as the Linn LP12, but has none the less served me well for decades. The nicest feature is the Auto arm return and shut off. If an album is playing, and by slim chance I happen to be in a smoke filled alcohol fueled haze, and an album ends, it doesn't sit running in the end groove until I get up and stop it. The Auto Start/Auto Stop feature is very very convenient. But it really doesn't add to the general quality of the turntable. Still I like it.

As to the topic at hand. If this is a £500 turntable, it really deserves one of the cartridges I've suggested. At Minimum the Ortofon 2M Red, and preferably the 2M Blue or the Grado Prestige Gold. Goldring cartridges are also worth considering, they definitely have their fans.

A £40 cartridge belongs on a £100 turntable.

At least, in my opinion.

Steve/bluewizard
 

Just Old

Banned
This is getting confusing.
The ortofon red cart sells for £80
The ortofon stylus replacement sells for £62

So I am paying £18 for the cartridge.

This just doesn't add up
I thought the cartridge was the component that made the difference, not the stylus.
 

steveledzep

Active Member
A good example might be the previous Goldring range of MM cartridges. They ranged from 1006 to 1012 to 1022 to 1042, between £100 and about £250 if memory serves me right. The cartridge body was the same throughout the range, it was only the stylus that differed. Maybe the cantilever differed too, I'm not sure, but the stylus profile and type made most of the difference. My understanding is that it was a combination of getting deeper into the groove and agility. It baffles me too, but I can hear the difference, as you will notice a huge difference if you upgrade your AT95.
 

Mr Pig

Novice Member
I thought the cartridge was the component that made the difference, not the stylus.
With a moving magnet cart the removable part is more than just a stylus, it's effectively half of the cartridge. But it's not just that. The cost of actually building the cart is only a small part of the total retail cost. The other costs, packing, distribution etc, will be much the same for a whole cart or for just the stylus.

Denon DL103, is that one of the High Output MC cartridges?
No, the 103 is very low output. The 160 was high and so is the cheaper 110 which as far as I know is still available.
 

Just Old

Banned
hummmmmmmm
mr p

Still doesn't make sence because you might as well pay the few % difference and get the complete cart with stylus??

and

The manufacturer could do away with selling replacement stylus and just get you to buy a new cartridge....
which if you look at the throw away society we live in makes me wonder why they haven't?

Maybe the manufacturers are just edging on the fact that most people..although I may be wrong...stick a cartridge in and don't bother changing it???..
or the cost to make a replacement stylus is so low they make the profit from selling them at the price they do?
 

Mr Pig

Novice Member
Maybe the manufacturers are just edging on the fact that most people stick a cartridge in and don't bother changing it? Or the cost to make a replacement stylus is so low they make the profit from selling them at the price they do?
Could be, makes sense. Like tyre manufactures practically giving tyres to car companies because they know that a lot of people stick to the tyres fitted to the car when it's new.

Plus, changing a stylus is much easier than changing the whole cart. I'm sure a lot of users just buy a new stylus for this reason.
 

BlueWizard

Distinguished Member
This is getting confusing.
The ortofon red cart sells for £80
The ortofon stylus replacement sells for £62

So I am paying £18 for the cartridge.

This just doesn't add up
I thought the cartridge was the component that made the difference, not the stylus.
Try building an automobile from parts. For a basic £20,000 car, plan on spending about £200,000 to build it from parts.

Also keep in mind that cartridge is made from copper wire, and the Stylus is made from a tiny precision cut gem stone; usually Diamond, occasionally Ruby or Sapphire.

Steve/bluewizard
 

Just Old

Banned
steve
see where you are coming from but.....

something you can't readily audition and compare..

and we all go out and buy them on someone elses subjective comments of them...

plus the repacement part we need to use them costs 80% of the whole..

then we decide to upgrade them to a more expensive model, because of someones subjective view, tells us they are better??????

You and I wouldn't do that now......
would we???

But I am being flippant...so
I have asked Ortofon to comment..if they will.
Take care
 

BlueWizard

Distinguished Member
You can't audition and compare, but you can find semi-subjective/semi-objective reviews. Again, if I were in the market right now it would either be the Ortofon 2M Blue or the Grado Prestige Gold. Both have very good reviews from people who have actually tried them. Yes, to some extent, the choice is based on perception, but none the less these are well regarded manufacturer's with long and proven histories.

The Ortofon 2M Rad has received rave reviews from multiple sources for being outstanding in its price range, and the 2M line in general is highly regarded in MM type cartridges.

And once again, I remind you that the cartridge, for the most part, is made from copper, and the stylus is made from a Diamond cut to high precision.

The common types of stylus are -

1.) Conical - cone shaped - usually used by DJ's for scratching since the angle of the stylus to the groove is not relevant.

2.) Elliptical - more or less oval shaped. The narrower edges track the grooves of the vinyl with more precision, but the angle of the stylus to the groove is more critical

3.) Hyper-Ellipical and Hybrid-Elliptical - these are actually general terms and can refer to a variety of semi-elliptical shaped stylus. As an example, the back edge or trailing edge might be a standard elliptical shape, but the leading edge might be more of a triangular shape, or it may simply be a very shallow/narrow elliptical shape. Cutting the stone this way makes the edges that contact the groove much sharper and they therefore are able to capture more detail.

4.) Shibata - is either a very shallow elliptical, again for the purposes of have a wide face, but a narrow edge to track the groove better. I've seen some Shibata that are elliptical along the back, but are cut with concave leading faces. Again, think triangle with faces that cave inward. The purpose of which is to make the edge as narrow as possible and increase the amount of contact surface between the stylus and the groove.

Use the image at this link and scroll about 3/4 of the way down for the profiles of various stylus.

Sick Of Talk

http://www.sickoftalk.com/whyvinyl/fig12_18.jpg

Keeping in mind these are tiny Diamonds cut to very precise shapes.

In general, the stylus listed above are listed in order of their quality. Each will cost progressively more, and each will sound progressively better, in general.

Steve/bluewizard
 

Just Old

Banned
Steve you are.....
spot on.
Ortofon confirm the cost of the diamond and polishing & cutting the stylus profile is the main cost of the cartridge.

They also add that the blue and red stylus are interchangeable. So by putting the red cartridge in you can upgrade by replacing the red sylus with the blue stylus.

Thanks all for advice.
 

steveledzep

Active Member
the cost of the diamond and polishing & cutting the stylus profile is the main cost of the cartridge.
Told you all of this two days ago with reference to Goldring cartridges. I clearly don't fit in with the clique on here. I'll retire gracefully.
 

BlueWizard

Distinguished Member
Told you all of this two days ago with reference to Goldring cartridges. I clearly don't fit in with the clique on here. I'll retire gracefully.

Don't take it too hard, we were simply re-affirming the point.

Further, at I pointed out, when you buy something in parts, the cost is higher than if you buy it all together in a single unit.

Also, consider the scale they are working on. Many elliptical stylus are very tiny.

I think the radius of the arcs of the Ortofon 2M Red are 8 µm x 18 µm, which I take to mean 8 millionths of a meter.

I also vaguely remember common dimensions of Elliptical Stylus being -

0.3 Mils X 0.7 Mils

A "MIL" is one one thousandth of an inch or 0.0254mm.

Many will have two or three precision cuts, then contouring, and polishing. No small task.

Steve/bluewizard
 

Just Old

Banned
Crikey steve...
bit drastic mate...

all comments that are given to my posts are of value....cos I'm just old and thick!!!!!

You know some times what people think they say when they post, and what is actually written can get lost in translation by whoever reads the post, and I think that is maybe what happened.

You won't find a better, more friendly forum.....
 

Similar threads

Trending threads

Latest News

Sky announces combined Sky Sports and BT Sport packages
  • By Andy Bassett
  • Published
Qobuz drops MP3s and introduces Studio Premier Plan
  • By Andy Bassett
  • Published
Micro LED TV alternative to modular design on the way?
  • By Andy Bassett
  • Published
Musical Fidelity announces M8xi integrated amp
  • By Andy Bassett
  • Published
Sky announces price rises for UK
  • By Andy Bassett
  • Published
Top Bottom