Calibration sticky?

Peter Parker

Distinguished Member
I've always thought that people who have projectors should as a minimum, use something like Avia to set white and black levels. This ensures you aren't losing any shadow or bright details, and can help reduce mpg artefacts, especialy from the darker areas.

Having recently taken an interest in calibration (as have others - you know who you are Buns), and the miriad of questions it's brought up (for me at least), I wondered if there was some kind soul out there who could make a calibration 'sticky' for the forum so that someone could learn the basics, and others with some calibration equipment, could learn something more advanced.

Having recently chatted with the likes of Jeff Paynter, Paul Hayword, Gordon Frasier and others on the US forum, I realise this is no easy and simple task to put in a simple post, but maybe some basics combined with some web links would do the trick.

Anybody else got any thoughts on this? :)

Cheers,

Gary.
 

CrispyXUK

Well-known Member
well to start, is it true that you should leave the source (dvd, htpc etc.) untouched and only calibrate the display? I would be very interested in this as my PJ should turn up soon.

To start though, most people have the THX optimiser which for most will be a good start it can be found on the T2: ultimate edition & Star Wars EP2
 

Peter Parker

Distinguished Member
Hi Crispy,

Yes, I believe you're correct and that's how I've always tried to do mine anyway (HTPC gamma is another story...), but hopefully we'll get something a bit more definitive from those who know what they're doing. :)

The THX optimiser is a start, but unfortunately you'll find that each optimiser is only optimised for the disk it's on - use another and your settings will be out. It may be ok to get you in the ballpark so to speak, but I wouldn't use it as a blanket calibration in the same way Avia or VE can be used for example.

I have found that the THX drop shadow test for black level doesn't always have a shadow you can reveal. Some disks do, others don't, so that was one issue I had with them and why I use Avia instead.

Gary.
 

beecee

Well-known Member
i have tinkered with the thx optimiser in fight club but found that limiting. so after reading here i picked up Avia for my NTSC sources and then DVE for PAL as Avia dosn't do pal (as far as i know) but some help in calibration is always helpfull as i am a complete newbie to the pj scene.
 

Gordon @ Convergent AV

Distinguished Member
AVForums Sponsor
No its not true you should do the display only.

I will dip in and out of this with comments that can be added where appropriate.

You need to calibrate the chain. There are actually standards for the electrical signals that come out of consumer goods. That's not to say that manufacturers stick to them, or that tolerances within a manufacturers range is such that all devices will be the same. If you want under 1% errors then buy a TAG or Linn etc.

Many DVD players have their own settings for colour, contrast brightness and even gamma. SKY boxes even have contrast controls! I have come across one manufacturers product that crushes white detail on its default! So you need to make sure the sources are outputting the correct signal first, then you need to make sure any video processing is not cocking it all up before finally getting to the display itself.

Here's another little one for you. Some DVD players alter the level they stick black out at dependant on whether there is macrovision on the disc. With one of these players using AVIA for brightness may result in incorrect settings when playing back copyprotected discs (ie most dvd's except Superbits it seems) Lumagen at least allow you to create service menu offsets to fix this "feature" when you partner their scalers with such DVD players.

Cheers,

Gordon
 

theritz

Active Member
Gary - good idea..............

Gordon,

So you need to make sure the sources are outputting the correct signal first, then you need to make sure any video processing is not cocking it all up before finally getting to the display itself.
I understand that if a dvd player/ hcpc/ whatever is crushing whites or blacks in its signal then a display device can't "uncrush" them..... but how do you calibrate a dvd player in the first instance... how do you establish which device in the chain (the dvd player, processor or the projector) is the one causing the problem ?

The display capacity (and tweakability) of the AE100 is very limited by comparison to pjs of the HT1000 class, but I fixed the settings on my hcpc by connecting it to a monitor set to 6500k, default brightness etc. before connecting it to the projector and then calibrating the projector using avia. While the AE100 suffers the normal "green mist" in very dark scenes associated with LCD, I am very happy with the skin tones and overall balance of the image on the whole.


Sean.
 

RTFM

Novice Member
Good idea Gary.
Won't be easy as there are so many ways of measuring contrast,
brightness etc. ie. direct or reflected (screen characteristics come into play) But i'm sure with some input from the likes of Paul and Gordon it could be very worthwhile.
Maybe we could even get some of our pals from AVS to contribute like we do on their forum.
 

Similar threads

The latest video from AVForums

The Best Movies and TV Shows Coming To Amazon Prime Video in August 2020. Tom's Thumbs.
Top Bottom