Bookshelf’s or bipoles in a 5.1 setup?

liamgdr

Active Member
I’m currently in the process of acquiring some av gear, the plan is to have a basic 5.1 setup with a projector, maybe Atmos in the future but that isn’t a priority right now.

In the past I’ve been blessed with pretty basic rooms but in my new house the door leading into the living room is where I would ideally place the right surround speaker, the sofa is also right up against the wall so that isn’t great either. My two thoughts are either bi poles on the rear wall or bookshelf’s high up on the side walls, there’s just enough space above the door opening.

My main concern with bipolar speakers is I believe they’re meant to be in line with the front LR channels, as you can see from my pictures the front channels are very wide, they could be moved inwards but they then be very narrow (either side of the tv) I think our wide is the better compromise. Also anyway sat on the lounger part of the sofa would be sat on the outside of the rear left channel, that just seems a little strange to me. I could maybe fit down firing ceiling speakers but that would scupper the plans for Atmos.

What do you guys think? Pictures below.

Cheers.

Liam.

48EF34CD-857A-46EE-B412-AE140236D0CA.jpeg
8A6C0DB0-E70C-41C3-8F09-3B93180020EA.jpeg
5F2B6069-D649-4F5D-B89E-0CB98AA90C19.jpeg
 

Gasp3621

Distinguished Member
I would go with bipoles mounted high up on the rear wall so about 2feet from seated ear height. Spread them good amount apart and leave some space to side wall (1feet minium). They are so close to listeners that normal bookshelf speakers would be annoying and too directional. Bipoles would create bit more dispersed soundfield. Example Monitor Audio Bronze FX has low depth (124mm) and will be installed flush against wall with two screws. There is white finish so it will blend with walls better too. You can hide the wires with D-Line trunking (amazon uk).


BronzeFX2020-1.jpg


ma_bronze_fx_back_white.jpg
 

meep

Well-known Member
For 5.1, I would go with bi poles for the diffusion effect.

If you want to do atmos in future, bi poles are not recommended as they are not as good as direct radiators for helping pinpoint the audio in 3d space.

Best of both worlds? Get a bipole / dipole that an also be configured as a direct radiator in the future.
 

rccarguy2

Well-known Member
I'd go with bipoles in that room. I'm using bipoles as sides in 7.1 system they're about 65cm to 1.8m away.

They're a better choice where you're close to side/rears and they're more tidy install rather than regular speakers.

I'm using definitive technology bp-2x
 

liamgdr

Active Member
So Ive purchased some MA bi poles, lets see how i get on.

cheers guys.
 

Mango Bob

Active Member
Hang the door so it opens outwards?
We're very space constrained and have quite flat Kef T101s mounted on the rear wall just behind the sofa.
 

liamgdr

Active Member
I did think about that, I also though about those very low profile Dali speakers, but I’ve never had no poles so going to give them a try, my only worry is that the left surround will baicially be in the middle of the sofa, that’s ok for me in the main listening position but rubbish for anyone else (not that they’d care haha)
 

The latest video from AVForums

AVForums Movies Podcast: Streaming Theatrical Releases And The Future Of Cinema
Subscribe to our YouTube channel
Support AVForums with Patreon

Top Bottom