BK Gemini vs REL quake...?

B

badhairday

Guest
Hello All,

Can anyone help me make a decision on which one to go for - maybe someone has has the pleasure of both
(I know its all subjective in the end!)

thank you!

:smashin:
 

Ian J

Banned
I think that you will be out luck as so far as I am aware only one Finnish member has heard the Gemini and the chance's of him having heard the Quake too will be fairly slim.

We need a guinea pig :D
 

Knyght_byte

Novice Member
dunno about versus, but if thats your price limit and the room isnt massive then the Quake is a fairly good little sub.....very nice with bookshelf speakers.......you might find if pairing it with floorstanders its a little outclassed if they already go deep and powerful tho.....
I'd recommend you audition it first to be sure......i like mine with my Mission bookshelfs, but my Monitor Audio Silver S6's outclassed it to so i got the Strata 5 as something more comparable....
 
B

badhairday

Guest
Thanks for the feedback chaps....looks like the quake in black has gone from ebay - too slow! :(

Now considering the MJ 50 Pro / Ruark 100 / BKxls200......?

Very interested in any of the above if anyone has them for sale..!!


:thumbsup:
 

conkerman

Active Member
Hi there.

I MAY have an MJ ref 100 for sale soon.

Just re jigging the lounge and my speakers all need to go :(

Bah!
 
B

badhairday

Guest
conkerman said:
Hi there.

I MAY have an MJ ref 100 for sale soon.

Just re jigging the lounge and my speakers all need to go :(

Bah!

Let me/the forum know about the MJ - very interested if its in black!

:thumbsup:
 

PJTX100

Distinguished Member
conkerman said:
Just re jigging the lounge and my speakers all need to go :(
Ouch.

That's not a re-jig, that's an infringement of human rights! :D
 

Falp

Novice Member
badhairday said:
Hello All,

Can anyone help me make a decision on which one to go for - maybe someone has has the pleasure of both
(I know its all subjective in the end!)

thank you!

:smashin:
I'm interested in a used Rherry REL Quake... but the 1/2 price BK Gemini is probably a great choice! ;)
And has an oak finish! :thumbsup:

I would like to have more info too... :cool:
 
A

alek

Guest
Ian J said:
I think that you will be out luck as so far as I am aware only one Finnish member has heard the Gemini and the chance's of him having heard the Quake too will be fairly slim.

We need a guinea pig :D
I've heard rumours that the BK Gemini is very close (although not identical) to the MJ Reference 100. So a Quake vs. Ref 100 -comparison might give a hint of the differences. Regarding these two subs there may be seasoned guinea pigs on this forum already :) .

If I remember correctly, according to a Finnish hifi magazine the MJ goes louder, but the little Rel (surprisingly) goes deeper (at least on the minimum xo-setting). I think Quake absolutely requires corner-loading, which also helps in not tripping on it :D .
 

Falp

Novice Member
I heard the REL Quake in a few setups and loved it!
I heard the MJ Ref 100 in my house and liked it too...

I would prefer the Quake because it's smaller but would prefer the MJ oak finish...

Maybe the Gemini has everything for 1/2 the price... :p
 

Knyght_byte

Novice Member
the Quake is actually quite nice in the grittex black finish...lol....its quite unobtrusive like that.......it also works well if your hide it anyhow, it seems to relish being boxed in for an extra kick.....
 

Falp

Novice Member

Knyght_byte

Novice Member
the quake does benefit from being in the corner, but its not strictly necessary, i had mine just on a wall for a while and it still gives you a very deep sound....but to get the extra weight the corner is useful.....
 

Knyght_byte

Novice Member
Ian J said:
I have this vision of Humpty Dumpty :rotfl:
:rotfl: :rotfl: :rotfl: :rotfl: :oops:

guess i coulda phrased that better...lol
 
B

badhairday

Guest
badhairday said:
Hello All,

Can anyone help me make a decision on which one to go for - maybe someone has has the pleasure of both
(I know its all subjective in the end!)

thank you!

:smashin:
Thanks for everyones comments - and man, it's been a very tough decision!

3rd place - Rel Quake (cos it's £370 with a high level cable).
2nd place - BK Gemini (cos it hasnt had enough exposure as yet)

What finally swayed my choice was the... FEAR....

(The fear of getting an underpowered sub for 100 sov's more than this baby...)

The BK XLS200DF!!!

Placed an order today and cant wait

:D :D :D
 

Qublai

Novice Member
Let us know how you get on with the BK. Very interested in one myself, as my KEF PSW 2000 seems to have developed the usual amp fault with this model and I'm still waiting for an email reply from KEF. :boring:
 

Kazman

Well-known Member
Myself, stu_mcc and eviljohn2 will be conducting a head to head with the Gemini, BK XLS200 and Rel Quake within the next few weeks. Look out for it, just waiting for the Gemini to arrive.
 
B

badhairday

Guest
Kazman said:
Myself, stu_mcc and eviljohn2 will be conducting a head to head with the Gemini, BK XLS200 and Rel Quake within the next few weeks. Look out for it, just waiting for the Gemini to arrive.


Dear Jim,

Please can you fix it for me, so the BK XLS200 wins this test.

Yours gratefully,

Badhairday.

:)
 
Y

Yaroen

Guest
Kazman said:
Myself, stu_mcc and eviljohn2 will be conducting a head to head with the Gemini, BK XLS200 and Rel Quake within the next few weeks. Look out for it, just waiting for the Gemini to arrive.
I'm looking foreward to your reviews...
 

Ian J

Banned
badhairday said:
Dear Jim,

Please can you fix it for me, so the BK XLS200 wins this test.
It will as BK aren't stupid enough to try and sell a sub that outperforms their own more expensive sub and those that have heard both the XLS200 and the Quake seem to agree that the Essex offering is the better sub.
 
A

andyturner28

Guest
Ian J, i have just realised that BK are based in southend. Do they have a listening room as i am considering an xls200.
 

The latest video from AVForums

Podcast: Marantz SR7015 & NAD T 778 AVR + Mission LX2 MKII Speaker Reviews, AV & Film News and More

Latest News

LG SIGNATURE OLED R TV now available in South Korea
  • By Andy Bassett
  • Published
LG Display teams with Disney for OLED Projects
  • By Andy Bassett
  • Published
Campfire Audio updates Vega and Dorado earphones
  • By Andy Bassett
  • Published
Oppo launches S1 and R1 4K smart TVs
  • By Andy Bassett
  • Published
Lithe Audio AirPlay 2 ceiling speakers world's first
  • By Andy Bassett
  • Published
Top Bottom