I'm really not trying to rain on anyone's parade. If you're getting something out of it, that's great. For me, it annoyed me from the off and went downhill from there.
The thing is, Rocksteady had done all the hard work - the mechanics, the world, it was all there. Yet somehow we end up with a game that was broken at launch with a needlessly tacked-on multiplayer. Seriously, why does the MP exist other than to tick a box? Is anyone really enjoying it?
The story has none of the great moments of the previous games. The boss fights are mediocre, and the Deathstroke fight is essentially glitched (when he attacks, Bats blocks a couple of hits automatically - if you try to parry you get hit).
I found the combat significantly more buggy than in previous outings, with the flow often ruined by something inexplicable happening. The predator rooms were less interesting too, and those new Crime Scene sections were basically glorified interactive cutscenes (they should have been awesome, like in that show Continuum).
Basically, I think WB have seen the opportunity for a cash grab. Think about the great foundation laid out by Arkham City and all those cool moments (the end credits, for example). How can anyone justify this being worse? Being broken? We are entitled to expect more than this annual regurgitation for our hard earned £40.
Viva la revolution etc.