The reviewer states that they prefer the original theatrical cut of the film so it seems to fit that they would rate the Final Cut version of the film a little lower so an 8 isn't that surprising.Decent enough review, but only 8 for the movie itself?
Hard to understand, given that virtually every film critic worth reading reckon it's the best Vietnam war film ever made, (and arguably one of the best films ever made, period).
Especially when dross like Iron Man 3 and Shazam get a 9 rating.
That aside, looking forward to viewing this.
Opinions are fraught with personal interpretations... But a valid reason for scoring anything different to anything else could simply be because it sets out to achieve something different.Decent enough review, but only 8 for the movie itself?
Its a 10/10 film for me and always has been. Whichever cut I watch wont change that.Decent enough review, but only 8 for the movie itself?
Hard to understand, given that virtually every film critic worth reading reckon it's the best Vietnam war film ever made, (and arguably one of the best films ever made, period).
Especially when dross like Iron Man 3 and Shazam get a 9 rating.
That aside, looking forward to viewing this.
Even if it is only as good as Deadpool 2 if we're to take your ratings seriously![]()
Given that you’ve probably watched it enough times to do your own edit from memory,which will be your favourite Jim?Its a 10/10 film for me and always has been. Whichever cut I watch wont change that.
The US version arrived for me last Friday, its a cardboard case. Looks pretty good, but has super annoying little flaps that wrap over the top and bottom that do nothing and naturally want to stick out forwards making it look as if its about to spring open. That's my only gripe thoughDo the discs come in a gatefold cardboard boxset or are we treated to a decent plastic case for the price?
This is how people differ as I personally do not like the redux version and the reviewer prefers the theatrical over final cut .This is the best war film ever made the most realistic, the most atmospheric, with great cinematography, the iconic Brando scenes regardless of the version to be rated an 8 for the film its a 10 for me, the redux review got a 10 for the extended scenes but this cut will not take any of the enjoyment away so should remain a 10
The redux version i have has one of the the best picture qualities i have seen on a 1080P disc. So can imagine how good this is on 4k
I'm curious about the UK packaging because I also got the US release last week, and while the discs are awesome the actual packaging is very poor.The US version arrived for me last Friday, its a cardboard case. Looks pretty good, but has super annoying little flaps that wrap over the top and bottom that do nothing and naturally want to stick out forwards making it look as if its about to spring open. That's my only gripe though
Yeah I'd start with the Theatrical. Then Redux. Then the new cut.Given that you’ve probably watched it enough times to do your own edit from memory,which will be your favourite Jim?
And as someone who confesses to never having watched it properly;which version should I start with?Theatrical?
The only and only time I watched it, my first thoughts where "that was overrated.."I'm ashamed to say this, as a HUGE movie fan....... but I have never seen this film!
I have now put it right at the top of my 4K UHD birthday (later this month) list though if that is any consolation?!
Yes it seems odd that the raft of doppelganger franchise/monster/comic book hero mixed with comedy films could be considered in the same rating ballpark as this film.Decent enough review, but only 8 for the movie itself?
Hard to understand, given that virtually every film critic worth reading reckon it's the best Vietnam war film ever made, (and arguably one of the best films ever made, period).
Especially when dross like Iron Man 3 and Shazam get a 9 rating.
That aside, looking forward to viewing this.
Even if it is only as good as Deadpool 2 if we're to take your ratings seriously![]()