Also just finished watching Life of Pi on 3D bluray and come away not really knowing what to think. It does display some really great depth at times and has some really great shots, but it just didn't blow me away.
Still think Hugo is the one to beat for me and more recently Madagascar 3, both excellent transfers. Have to say i had to use our PS3 tonight with Life of Pi, the picture on our dedicated 3D player was all over the place, it was literally unbearable in motion, needs an update for the player ASAP.
I think maybe i need a 2nd watch.