Perry Mason Season 1 Review
HBO's Perry Mason is a challenging slow-burn, eschewing what fans might know of the character in favour of a blend of Chinatown and a period-set Goliath.
Some may remember the classic 50s black and white TV show Perry Mason (and its later - numerous - TV movies that ran all the way through to the mid-90s) with the imposing Raymond Burr playing the eponymous ace defence attorney who always takes on the most impossible, seemingly clear-cut, case, leaving it to the 11th hour to uncover a final piece of the puzzle which not only sees his client vindicated but exposes the real culprit in the process. Based on a series of novels by Erle Stanley Gardner, the franchise caught the attention of HBO and indeed Iron Man's Robert Downey Jr. back in 2016, with True Detective scribe Nic Pizzolatto expected to write it and Downey Jr. cast in the lead.
A third season of True Detective and Downey Jr.'s busy filming schedule (Dolittle?) soon saw them both drop out of the production, with The Americans' Matthew Rhys cast as the title character, but the end result is curiously detached from anything anybody even vaguely familiar with the name Perry Mason would expect - so much so that it's hard to understand why this attempts to present itself as a reboot at all, and doesn't just stand on its own as an original - reimagining the attorney as a broken, drunken and tortured soul, disgraced following his actions in WWI, now working as a down-and-out Private Investigator, crawling the sewer-like streets of 1932 Los Angeles in search of a juicy bit of dirt he can use for extortion.
It's a shame someone with a little more spark - like the originally cast Downey Jr. - didn't get the chance to turn this into a more interesting role
It kicks-off with a feature-length pilot whose story is clearly going to carry on for several more episodes - if not the entire first 'limited' series - and is still in search of its groove come the midway point. There's promise here, for sure, with an all-star cast and some depth of storytelling, but viewers should prepare themselves for the long haul, with the truth only coming out in the literal 11th hour. Its biggest sin, however, is not the writing or dark and unforgiving style, replete with some impressively reimagined shots of 30s LA (director Tim Van Patten brings some of what he's learned from Boardwalk Empire over to this production), all of which audiences may well have found refreshing in an age of tempered content, and which is certainly in-line with the HBO model. No, it falls down on the casting of the lead. Rhys - who came to fame in Brothers and Sisters, and achieved acclaim in The Americans - plays it tortured for torture's sake, without even the slightest glimmer of charm or wit, or really any character beyond what you'd expect from, say, Eeyore. It's a shame someone with a little more spark - like the originally cast Downey Jr. - didn't get the chance to turn this into a more interesting role.
Eventually, this series - now greenlit for a second year - comes good on the expectations of its titular character, clearly painting a very slow-burning origin story for someone who didn't really need one, particularly since they could have just told any period feature with the same story but without the name, and avoided inciting such comparison. Nevertheless, it's a rich, seedy, playing field, which fosters the nourishment of this dark noir, and it's peppered with interesting peripheral characters, and, even if neither the long-winded convolution of the plot, nor the perpetually glum Rhys do it any favours, the HBO quality just about wins out in the end.
Perry Mason Season 1 Blu-ray Video
HBO's Perry Mason Season 1 comes to UK Blu-ray courtesy of Warner. The disc presents a 1080p/AVC-encoded image in the film's original aspect ratio of widescreen 2.00:1.
We reviewed the UK Blu-ray release of Perry Mason Season 1 on an LG 55B7 Dolby Vision 4K Ultra HD OLED TV with a Panasonic DP-UB450 Dolby Vision HDR10+ 4K Ultra HD Blu-ray player.
Many fans will be pleased to be able to pick HBO's slick new period noir in more impressive shape
After having to endure 720p NowTV quality, many fans will be pleased to be able to pick HBO's slick new period noir in more impressive shape. Although its extremely dark sensibilities may have been best served by full 4K with HDR, the 1080p Blu-ray does a stand up job avoiding crush, rendering a very pleasing and frequently very impressive presentation of the source material, with excellent detail that revels in the worn visages, hair and clothing, and occasionally lavish, occasionally gritty and grimy colour palette. The texturing is superb, and those aforementioned inky blacks impress too. More recent a production than Boardwalk Empire, Perry Mason makes the most of the improved technology whilst revelling in an even darker, more shadow-strewn landscape, and this Blu-ray does a commendable job rising to the challenge to deliver largely excellent video.
Perry Mason Season 1 Blu-ray Audio
Perry Mason Season 1's Blu-ray release enjoys a strong DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track which does an impressive job crafting a heady and at times really quite immersive atmosphere for the proceedings, enjoying the scoring, the mood, and the period nuances.
A strong audio track
Dialogue gets decent prioritisation, clearly and coherently rendered throughout despite Rhys' slight chewing of words (and frequent shouting), with the period landscape brought to life courtesy of era-specific engine sounds, infrequent gunshots, the echoing pounding of a gavel, and the bustle of the streets, with the crowded court sequences in particular quite lively, although nothing really compares to the furore of the heaving church. The score - particularly contemplative during the closing credits - provides welcome support to the proceedings, and whilst it's hardly a conventional demo track, it does sound very good indeed.
Perry Mason Season 1 Blu-ray Extras
Warner deliver a small but decent selection of extras spread across the discs, both Featurettes and Interviews.
A small but decent selection of extras
The Featurettes and Interviews dip into the rebooting of the character, but - perhaps most interestingly - have Robert Downey Jr. on hand for a couple of Interviews to talk about his production work on this project.
Perry Mason Season 1 (HBO) Blu-ray Review
HBO's Perry Mason Season 1 is one of those productions that requires some not insubstantial patience and may or may not reward it depending how much you can forgive it its distance from what you might expect from the eponymous character. It eventually builds, Goliath-style, to a reasonably good courtroom climax, but Rhys is not a great choice for the lead, and the greenlit second season will have to spark up a different line of questioning if it hopes to have some legs.
Even if neither the long-winded convolution of the plot, nor the perpetually glum Rhys do it any favours, the HBO quality just about wins out in the end
Warner's UK Blu-ray release of HBO's Perry Mason Season 1 does a very good job despite the extremely dark material, delivering frequently excellent video and very strong audio, as well as a few nice extras. Fans should consider a solid purchase, particularly those who want to wash the taste of NowTV's rendition from their palates.
Our Review Ethos
To comment on what you've read here, click the Discussion tab and post a reply.