Home Entertainment & Technology Resource

  1. This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn More.

Philips 9707 (46PFL9707) LED LCD 3D TV Review

Philips take a tip from Mother Nature with their new flagship TV

by Steve Withers Feb 17, 2013


Home AV review

56


SRP: £2300.00

Introduction

It's been over two years since we last had a Philips in for review and in that time the manufacturer has clearly been busy. In fact looking at some of our comments on previous reviews it would seem that Philips have addressed many of the issues that we originally raised. Now we're not saying that Philips have made these changes due to our feedback, although that would be nice, but clearly the manufacturer has benefited from its involvement with the Imaging Science Foundation (ISF). Since our reviews are based on the same industry standards and desire for image fidelity that forms the basis of the ISF's goals, it should come as no surprise that the results will be the same.

But it isn't just the ISF that Philips have been taking advice from recently, as it seems Mother Nature has also been lending a hand. Who would have thought that the unique design of a moth's eye could revolutionise the TV world? Well it seems that the light rejecting capabilities of their eyes, designed over millions of years of evolution to help them see better in their nocturnal world without attracting predators, also works rather well when applied to a filter on the front of your TV. Philips are using this exciting new technology on their flagship 46PFL9707 and once you include all the other features this particular TV has to offer, it starts to look like a very interesting prospect.

In fact Philips have pulled out all the stops as far as the 46PFL9707 is concerned, offering a complete set of features including Micro Dimming Premium, 1200Hz Perfect Motion Rate, 3D Max Clarity 1000, 2D to 3D conversion, two player full screen gaming mode, Perfect Pixel HD Engine, Smart TV platform, built-in WiFi, dual sided remote and an included Skype camera. There's also Philips' unique Ambilight Spectra XL feature, which offers real potential when used correctly in its ISF Warm White setting. To Philips' credit, they have also taken the decision to use a slightly deeper chassis in order to include a full LED array, promising a much better backlight performance. It's fair to say we've got some serious expectations as far as the 46PFL9707 is concerned, so let's see if it lives up to them.

Design and Connections

It's refreshing to see a TV design these days that doesn't copy Samsung and whilst there is a rather Apple-esque feel to the 46PFL9707, with its attractive combination of white and brushed metal, it certainly looks striking. The main chassis is constructed of hardened white plastic and measures 4cm deep, with the extra space being used for a full LED backlight array. We really feel kudos is owed to Philips for having the courage to use a deeper chassis design rather than sacrificing picture quality just to deliver another size zero variant. The bezel is brushed metal with a silver trim and measures 2.5cm at the top and sides and 3cm along the bottom. Along with the deeper chassis, it's good to see a decent sized bezel as we're not really fans of the current 'bezel-less' trend. Also at the bottom, beneath the centrally positioned Philips badge, is a largely decorative brushed metal lip about 23cm wide where the on/off light and IR receiver and transmitter are located.

The entire panel sits on an angled and rectangular brushed metal stand with the support column discreetly hidden at the rear, giving the impression the 46PFL9707 is floating in mid-air. When you first assemble the stand, there is a cable that connects it to the panel itself, this is because the 20W x 2 speakers are hidden in the stand. This might sound strange but this unusual approach certainly paid dividends in terms of sound quality, as we'll discuss later. There is also the option to wall mount the 46PFL9707 using the standard VESA holes and the panel weighs 14.6kg or 18kg if you include the stand. If you do decide to wall mount, the part of the stand that contains the speakers can also be mounted in a number of different configurations, depending on your requirements. Overall the design is aesthetically pleasing and the build quality is excellent, which is certainly befitting of a flagship model like the 46PFL9707.

The 46PFL9707 has an excellent selection of connections at the rear and when many manufacturers are cutting back on HDMI inputs, even on their flagship models, it's refreshing to see Philips include a total of five - three at the rear and two at the side. What's even better is that the three HDMI inputs at the rear are downward facing, allowing for easy wall mounting without the need to have cables poking out of the sides. Finally a manufacturer has seen the light, thank you Philips! Other connections include three USB ports, two at the side and one at the rear, a CI slot, a SCART connector, a LAN port, a headphone socket, a component video input, a VGA connector and an optical digital out. There is also an aerial socket and, on the European model at least, a satellite socket as well. Our review sample was a European model which is why the satellite socket is visible in the photo of the rear connections but we should stress this is not available on the UK model.

The provided remote control uses the same combination of brushed metal and white found on the TV itself and thus matches very nicely. The remote is also well built, with enough weight to suggest quality, whilst remaining comfortable to hold. It certainly looks like the kind of remote that you would expect to get with a flagship TV, being both well designed and easy to use. The layout is suitably ergonomic and the choice of buttons is comprehensive without appearing crowded. Best of all on the back is a full QWERTY keyboard, which makes typing into the web browser much easier. The remote has sensors to know which way round it is orientated, thus you can't accidentally hit the buttons on one side whilst using the buttons on the other. As an alternative, there is also a very well designed remote app that provides the same controls on your smartphone or tablet.

The 46PFL9707 comes with two pairs of active shutter 3D glasses which, if the logo on the side is anything to go by, are made for Philips by RealD. With their glossy black frames, the design is a little '1960s Michael Caine' but they are robust and not too heavy, with reasonably wide sides to block out ambient light. The glasses can be recharged and whilst the lenses are darker than some other makes, at least they're neutrally tinted. There is an on/off button on the inside, between the two lenses at the top of the frame, and this button is also used to select player one or two when using them for two player gaming. This feature allows one pair of glasses to see one image whilst the other pair sees the second image in a two player game, a useful feature but one we were unfortunately unable to test. Unusually these days, the glasses use infrared, so you'll need line-of-sight and we noticed that the IR transmitter interfered with our PVR remote when we were watching some pre-recorded side-by-side 3D content. Our only other comment would be that given the general size of the frames, it would be more sensible to make the lenses larger as we were sometimes aware of them at the periphery of our vision.

Menus

One of our big complaints with previous Philips TVs was that in an effort to make them as easy to use as possible, the menu systems became impossibly frustrating to navigate if you actually knew what you were doing. There comes a point where simplicity actually begins to work against you and, whether intentionally or not, it would seem that Philips have taken this feedback on board. The menu system on the 46PFL9707 is vastly superior, proving both comprehensive and intuitive to use and, thanks to the dual core processing, it's also fast and responsive.

Most features can be accessed from the single Home screen, which in turn is accessed by just pressing the Home button on the remote. In this screen, along with the inputs you can also access the TV programmes, TV guide, the smart features, networked devices, recorded content, Skype and the Setup menu. In the case of the inputs, TV programmes, TV guide and Smart TV, these can also be accessed separately using dedicated buttons on the remote. Within the Setup menu there are five options - TV Settings, Channel Settings, Satellite Settings (Europe only), Network Settings and Software Settings. Each offers the choice of a simplified or more detailed versions, thus catering to both neophytes and the season user.

Within the TV Settings there are choices for Picture, 3D, Sound, Ambilight and General Settings. The 3D menu includes some basic setup options for 3D, the Sound menu includes the setup audio options and the General Settings include options for language, clock, timer etc. The Ambilight menu can also be accessed directly using a dedicated button on the remote and provides a choice of Off/Dynamic/Static/ISF Warm White. For reasons we will discuss later you should choose ISF Warm White if you plan on using the Ambilight feature. In the Picture menu is the Picture Format sub-menu which gives you access to the different aspect ratios and again these can be accessed directly using a dedicated button on the remote. If you watch high definition content you need to ensure it isn't being scaled, so selected the appropriately titled Unscaled aspect ratio. All the other key picture controls can be found in the Picture menu, including the advanced ISF calibration controls.

The advanced calibration controls are under ISF Expert Settings and here you can choose the Colour Temperature, with a choice of Normal, Warm and Cool. There is also a Custom setting which gives you access to the two point white balance control, which will allow a professional calibrator to accurately set the greyscale. Also within the ISF Expert Settings is the Colour Control which is actually a colour management system. Here you can control the hue or saturation of the three primary and three secondary colours, again allowing a professional calibrator to accurately set the colour space.

Audio and Features

We've become so used to modern TVs sounding terrible that, when one comes along that sounds really good, it's almost shocking. Thanks to Philips ingenious use of the stand as an alternative speaker, the 46PFL9707 delivers some some of the best audio we've heard from a TV in many a long year. We've reviewed much larger screen sizes where the increased width has aided stereo separation and the bigger chassis has accommodated larger speakers, all of which can result in an improved audio experience. However we were pleasantly surprised by the quality of sound emanating from the 46PFL9707's more sensible proportions. The audio was clean and clear, with a generous soundstage that seemed more immersive than we thought possible. Not only was dialogue perfectly intelligible and anchored to the centre of the screen but music sounded open and wide, extending well beyond the screen's 46 inches. The bass response was also impressive for a TV, the mid-range was well represented and the top end never sounded harsh. Sound effects were also well rendered, often seeming to come from places where we knew there weren't speakers. You could also happily stream music to the 46PFL9707 and listen using the built-in speakers, which isn't something we get to say very often - top marks to Philips.

Thanks to the ever increasing complexity of today's Smart TV systems we now review them as a separate product. The reason for this is two-fold, firstly it allows us to cover the Smart TV system in greater detail and secondly it keeps the reviews of the TVs themselves to a manageable length. The review of the Philips Smart TV system is here and overall we found it to be very good in certain areas such as networking and connectivity but limited in others, such as the number of apps and video on demand services available. However one area that were particularly impressed with was the remote app, which is available for both iOS and Android. We found the design and interaction to be very good and for the first time with any manufacturer's app we were able to actually stream live TV to our tablet and iPhone and watch in another room - very handy.

Whilst the 46PFL9707 doesn't have a built-in camera, it does come one included as part of the package. The camera is extremely easy to setup and install and worked perfectly with the Skype app built into the 46PFL9707. This is great news if, like us, you find the ability to make Skype video calls from your TV a genuinely useful feature. If not, or you just don't like the camera ruining the clean lines of your lovely new TV, you can always take it off. We suspect that Philips, as with all other manufacturers, will be building cameras into future generations of their TVs.

Ambilight is one of the features on the 46PFL9707 that's genuinely unique to Philips and after spending some time with it, we've become huge fans. Now before anyone get's too excited, were not talking about the dynamic mode which turns the back of your TV into the equivalent of a school disco - that's just silly. No, we're referring to the ISF Warm White setting which introduces a static white light equivalent to D65 (you can read about D65 and how important it is in the Test Results section of this review) around the back of your TV. We've often spoken here on AVForums about how introducing some biased lighting into your room can reduce eye strain and improve perceived black levels when watching TV at night. We've also mentioned that ideally this lighting should be behind the TV but until now that's required you to go out and buy LED strips and add them behind the TV in some kind of custom install. Well not anymore, now Philips have done all the hard work for you and installed dozens of tiny LEDs along the rear top and sides of the 46PFL9707 chassis, so all you have to do is select ISF Warm White on the remote. The results were excellent and in the evenings we turned off all the lights and used Ambilight ISF Warm White to deliver just the right amount of biased light for a very comfortable and enjoyable viewing experience. As an added bonus, the already superb blacks on the 46PFL9707 looked even better thanks to Ambilight, what a great feature.

The other big selling point of the 46PFL9707 is the inclusion of a Moth Eye filter on the front of the panel which is designed to significantly reduce reflections. This new design of filter takes, as the name might suggest, its inspiration from moths, who have evolved special nanostructures on their surface of their eyes that eliminate reflections, thus hiding them from predators. These same properties are applied to the filter on the front of the 46PFL9707, thus eliminating most reflections and improving the perceived dynamic range of the panel. We can certainly attest to the remarkable properties of the Moth Eye filter, with almost no reflections being visible on the screen itself when watching TV with a lot of ambient light in the room. In fact, when you combine the Moth Filter with the native black level performance of the panel itself, the results are some of the most impressive blacks we've ever seen from a LCD TV - day or night.

Test Results

All TVs come with a more accurate preset that is usually either called Movie or Cinema and in the case of the Philips, it's called Movie. Full marks go to Philips here, their Movie picture style does exactly what it should do, offering a more accurate image based on the industry standards and turning off all the picture processing features. There are also ISF Day and Night presets, which are initially identical to the Movie picture style but they offer more advanced calibration controls for use by a trained professional. What a difference selecting a different mode can make! Just by choosing the Movie picture style we now have a far more accurate image with the greyscale (top left) now measuring much closer to our target. There's a shade too much red at the higher end of the scale, giving whites a warmer hue but it's vastly preferable to the blue-fest of the Standard picture style. The gamma curve is also much improved, now measuring close to our target of 2.2. The same is true of the colour space in the right hand graph, which now shows the majority of colours much closer to their ideal targets. You can see that white is measuring a little towards red which in turn is skewing yellow and magenta slightly but overall this is a reasonably good preset that delivers a natural looking image with no unnecessary processing.

The addition of ISF presets means that the 46PFL9707 will have sufficient calibration controls to allow for a far greater degree of accuracy than a factory preset can allow. The excellent starting point offered by both the Movie and ISF presets meant that we had little to do but fine tune the greyscale with the two-point white balance and then tweak the colour accuracy with the colour management system. We used the ISF Night preset for all our calibrated settings but there is also an ISF Day preset that a professional calibrator can use to create a much brighter setting for less critical daytime viewing.

The 46PFL9707 has a two point white balance control that is listed as the Custom Colour Temperature setting in the ISF Expert Setting sub-menu. As the name suggests, you adjust two points on the greyscale to vary the amounts of red, green and blue in order to set the correct colour temperature for white. There is a specific industry standard used for the colour temperature of white and it's called D65 (6500K) and the idea is to use the calibration controls to hit this target exactly. The other objective is to ensure that the greyscale has a smooth transition from black to white in shades of grey, with no obvious discolouration. If you look at the graph above you can see that amounts of red, green and blue are now reasonably close at each interval and as a result the DeltaEs (errors) are mostly less than one. A DeltaE of less than three is the cut off point at which the human eye can no really distinguish any errors, so this is an excellent performance from the 46PFL9707. The gamma curve was also improved slightly and was now hitting our target of 2.2 exactly. There was a small excess of red at the lower end of the scale but unfortunately we were unable to correct this due to the limitations of a two point white balance control. It would be nice to see Philips add a full ten point white balance control in future models to allow for greater accuracy.

The CIE Chart above shows the visible spectrum of colours and within that is the industry standard of Rec.709, represented as a triangle. This is the colour space used in all TV, DVD and Blu-ray production and the idea behind calibration is to replicate it as precisely as possible. As you can see, after the calibration of the greyscale, white is now measuring exactly at D65, the square in the middle, and as result the secondary colours of yellow and magenta are also more accurate. The inclusion of a colour management system allows us to adjust the positions of the three primary colours (red, green and blue) and three secondary colours (cyan, magenta and yellow) with respect to their targets on the Rec.709 triangle. The CMS on the 46PFL9707 provides individual controls for hue and saturation (colour) but no control for luminance (brightness). As a result we were able to get the hue measurements to an excellent level of accuracy, with most errors below one and all well below the threshold of three.

Things weren't so easy with the saturation and luminance, where a single control was being used to adjust two different elements of colour. As a result we were forced to compromise slightly when it came to green, where we chose a more accurate luminance at the expense of a slightly over-saturated colour. We did this because the eye is more sensitive to errors in luminance but it did mean that the over-saturated green also slightly affected yellow and cyan. However the overall errors for all six colours were still below the threshold of three and the luminance measurements were all spot on, as was the colour performance of red and blue. This is generally an excellent performance but hopefully Philips will add a separate luminance control in the future, which will then allow an even greater degree of accuracy.
The graph above shows how the 46PFL9707 performs at multiple saturation levels for the six different colours. The measurements in all the other graphs are taken using a saturation of 100% but here the measurements are taken at 25, 50, 75 and 100%. The result is that any issues not apparent at 100% might be picked up at lower saturation points. However, this is purely for information purposes because outside of a few high-end video processors, there are no controls for actually calibrating multiple saturation points. The 46PFL9707 performed reasonably well in this test, with most of the colours tracking close to their targets, although blue appeared slightly undersaturated and there was a slight kink in green at 25%.
Philips have made two important decisions that have both had an enormous impact on the contrast ratio and black level performance of the 46PFL9707. Firstly they are obviously using a VA panel, as opposed to the more commonly used IPS panel, which results in a much better black level. We measured the panel's native black level at 0.039cd/m2, which is impressive for a LCD TV, and we found the blacks to be among the best we had seen. The 46PFL9707 was also capable of very bright image, easily hitting our target of 120cd/m2 and as a result producing a very wide dynamic range and an excellent on/off contrast ratio of 3,077:1. Unfortunately, whilst a VA panel will deliver better blacks, there is a downside, which you can see as soon as you move off-axis. A VA panel has a very narrow angle of optimum performance and once you move outside a viewing angle of 90 degrees you will start to see a loss of contrast and colour saturation. Of course this can easily be mitigated by careful positioning of the TV but it is worth bearing in mind.

The other decision Philips took was to use a full LED array, which does mean a slightly deeper chassis but results in a vastly superior backlight performance. We can't tell you how pleasing it was to see a uniform backlight, with no clouding or bright corners and edges. Instead there was an even backlight with lovely deep blacks and once you included the micro dimming and moth eye filter into the equation, you started to see a level of performance that could give a plasma a run for its money. The excellent uniformity was evidenced by the checker board shown above, where you can see consistent measurements that delivered an impressive ANSI contrast ratio 2,637:1. The only downside to the full LED array was that very occasionally you got slight banding on camera pans but frankly that's a small price to pay for a screen uniformity and contrast performance that's this good.

We put the 46PFL9707 through our usual battery of video processing tests and overall it did very well, with one minor exception. Starting off with the SMPTE 133 pattern, the 46PFL9707 revealed cleanly scaled standard definition images without any loss of detail or unwanted ringing. The Philips also scored well when it came to video deinterlacing with jaggies only appearing when the line was at an acute angle in the test and with motion adaptive deinterlacing it was also very good, with slight jaggies only appearing on the bottom bar of the three moving bars. The 46PFL9707 also performed well in the film detail test and correctly locked on to the image resulting in no aliasing but in the cadence test it didn't do so well, failing to lock on to the 2:2 (PAL - European) format. So there is some unnecessary deinterlacing introduced and with it some resolution loss. However, the 46PFL9707 had no problems handling film material with both horizontal and vertical scrolling video text, correctly displaying the words without any blurring or shredding.

With our Blu-ray player set to 1080i the display correctly deinterlaced and displayed both the video and film resolution tests and showed good scaling and filtering performance as well as good resolution enhancement. We used the moving wedge patterns to check both the 2:2 and 3:2 patterns and again, the 46PFL9707 was unable to correctly lock onto the 2:2 cadence. However with 24p content it was absolutely flawless, with beautifully rendered motion handling and absolutely no issues whatsoever. In fact overall motion handling on the 46PFL9707 was very impressive for a LCD TV. We checked the headroom performance of the 46PFL9707 from reference white (video level 235) up to peak white (video level 255) and it was very good with absolutely no signs of clipping. As well as white, there were also no signs of clipping with the three primary colours either. In addition, the 46PFL9707 also correctly showed detail down to a video level 17 and reference black below that to video level 0.

If you're the kind of person who places great importance on responsive gaming then you'll need to select the Game mode on the 46PFL9707 or else be faced with an input lag of around 125 milliseconds. The Game mode does the trick in cutting down on any unnecessary processing by reducing input latency to around 50 milliseconds, which isn’t too bad but it's at the top end of the scale this year, with most averaging around 40 milliseconds. In 3D the lag is much bigger, measuring 129 milliseconds in Game mode, so even casual gamers might start to notice a delay that big. If you're only a casual gamer and not interested in 3D gaming then the lag on the 46PFL9707 probably won't be an issue and you'll benefit from the superb picture. If you're a serious gamer and the lag is important, there are faster and considerably cheaper options available.
  • Standby: 0W
The following measurements were taken with a full screen 50% white pattern:
  • Out-of-the-Box – Standard Mode: 48W
  • Calibrated – Movie Mode: 89W
  • Calibrated - 3D Mode: 117W

Picture Quality - 2D

This would seem an appropriate point to just come out and say that the 46PFL9707 has one of the best 2D pictures we've ever seen from a LCD TV. Why is this? Well it's a perfect storm of factors, all of which have combined to deliver a truly stellar performance and Philips are to be congratulated. Firstly the use of a full array LED backlight means we get a perfectly uniform backlight, with no clouding, bright edges or hot spots. There was some occasional banding on camera pans but we would prefer that to the kind of patchy backlight found on almost all LED TVs these days. Secondly the use of a VA panel means that the 46PFL9707 is capable of some of the best native blacks you'll see on a LCD TV. The downside is that the viewing angle is limited but this can be mitigated by careful positioning. Then there is the Moth Eye filter which eliminates most reflections delivering an even better dynamic range and the Ambilight can also help with perceived blacks in the evenings.

The accuracy of both the Movie and ISF picture styles is another major factor, as is the addition of calibration controls which can deliver a near reference level of image accuracy. Te micro dimming also played its part, help to deliver deeper blacks without robbing the image of shadow detail. The quality of the video processing is also excellent and the motion handling, especially with 24p content was absolutely superb, whilst the high definition panel itself delivered a wonderfully detailed image. The result is a picture that at times didn't look like an LCD TV at all, which is surprising. We use Pioneer Kuros as our reference TVs and so we become very used to the look of plasma, as a result LCD can often look very digital or processed. This wasn't the case with the 46PFL9707, we found ourselves really enjoying the images it produced and even in side-by-side comparisons with the Kuro it held up to scrutiny.

There really is no greater praise than that for any TV and we found ourselves perfectly happy watching anything and everything on the 46PFL9707. In fact regardless of what content we watched, the 46PFL9707 did a fantastic job, from the best Blu-rays to standard definition TV broadcasts. Of course when it came to Blu-rays, the 46PFL9707 could really show what it was capable of, with the Avengers Assemble, for example, looking absolutely stunning. The beautifully rendered images were no surprise given the source content but high definition TV broadcasts were equally as impressive, with the gorgeous vistas and camerawork on the BBC's recent Africa being expertly delivered by the 46PFL9707. The same was true with Six Nations Rugby, where 46PFL9707 handled details like the crowds or the pitches wonderfully but also had no issues with the fast motion, even with all the motion enhancing features turned off. The same was true of a DVD double bill of Sweeney! and Sweeney 2, where the image accuracy brought the nicotine stained late seventies vividly back life!

Picture Quality - 3D

So is the 46PFL9707 perfect? Well no, and in the case of this particular TV it's Achilles heel is 3D. The panel was certainly bright enough to deliver 3D with plenty of punch and the image was surprisingly accurate in the Movie preset, with the ISF modes offering the opportunity to improve that accuracy still further. As with the 2D performance, the motion handling was also very good, surprisingly so for a LCD TV. The problem seemed to be with crosstalk, especially in the backgrounds of scenes. Whilst there was undoubtedly plenty of 3D 'pop', especially in foreground scenes, this seemed to be achieved at the expense of the backgrounds which often had crosstalk. Using Avatar as an example, in the flying scenes those objects near the screen had plenty of detail and three dimensional depth whilst the floating mountains in the background suffered from crosstalk. We tried the 46PFL9707 with a number of different 3D Blu-rays, from old favourites like Hugo to more recent acquisitions like Pirates! but the results were always the same. We also tried adjusting all the 3D controls but nothing solved the problem, backgrounds always suffered from crosstalk. So the upshot is that if you're a huge fan of 3D, then the 46PFL9707 isn't the TV for you, which is a shame because it's great in every other respect.

Conclusion

8
AVForumsSCORE
OUT OF
10

Pros

  • Respectable black levels
  • Impressive dynamic range
  • Excellent backlight uniformity
  • Good out-of-the-box performance
  • Excellent performance after calibration
  • Superb video processing
  • Moth Eye filter is a definite winner
  • ISF Ambilight setting has real potential
  • Surprisingly good built-in sound
  • Comprehensive set of connections
  • Attractive and well built
  • Great remote control
  • Dual gaming feature
  • Well designed and intuitive menus
  • Good networking and smart features

Cons

  • Limited off-axis performance
  • Occasional minor backlight banding
  • 3D performance suffers from crosstalk
  • Unable to detect 2:2 cadence
  • Input lag is a bit high
  • Pricey

I own this 0
I want this 0
I had this 0

Philips 9707 (46PFL9707) LED LCD 3D TV Review

Quite simply, the Philips 46PFL9707 delivers the best 2D picture we have seen from a LED LCD TV to date. We'll explain why we think that in greater detail later but if you're looking for a one sentence summary, there you go. However, before we cover the picture quality in more depth, let's quickly go through the 46PFL9707's other attributes. The design is refreshingly different, if a little Apple-esque and the build quality is excellent, as befits a flagship model. There are plenty of well positioned connections, including 5 HDMI inputs, 3 of which are at the rear facing downwards.

There is a clever double sided remote with a well laid out set of buttons on one side and a QWERTY keyboard on the other. In addition to the remote, the 46PFL9707 comes with a Skype camera and two pairs of rechargeable active shutter 3D glasses. The menu system is attractively designed, intuitively laid out and thanks to the dual core processing, it's quick to navigate and responsive. The Smart TV system is not as comprehensive as some of the competition but it handles networking and streaming well and the remote app is excellent. The speakers are built into the stand but this unusual approach certainly works and the 46PFL9707 has some of the best audio we've heard from a TV in a long time.

The 46PFL9707 includes Philips' Ambilight feature, which we found to be particularly useful when set to ISF Warm White. The inclusion of ISF calibration controls is a welcome addition, allowing for a highly accurate image but we were glad to see that Movie and ISF picture presets also offered an excellent level of accuracy out-of-the-box. The video processing was superb, as was the motion handling and the black levels and dynamic range were very impressive for a LCD TV. The use of a full array LED resulted in a fantastically uniform backlight and the Moth Eye filter worked brilliantly, eliminating reflections and improving blacks. As a result of all these factors the 2D images produced by the 46PFL9707 were absolutely superb, making any content we watched look wonderful.

Unfortunately the same wasn't true of the 3D images, which suffered excessively from crosstalk. The 3D images were accurate and certainly bright enough but although objects near the screen had plenty of detail and three dimensional depth, those in the background were marred with crosstalk. So as good as the 46PFL9707 is with 2D content, if you're a huge fan of 3D then sadly it isn't the TV for you. Otherwise any other issues are all minor such as an inability to lock onto 2:2 cadence, some occasional banding, a limited viewing angle and a slightly high input lag. The only other issue is the price tag, which is at the higher end of the scale but, realistically, all this technology and performance was never going to come cheap.

Highly Recommended

The Rundown

Contrast/Dynamic Range/Black Level

8

Screen Uniformity

8

Colour Accuracy

9

Greyscale Accuracy

9

Video Processing

9

2D Picture Quality

9

3D Picture Quality

5

Sound Quality

9

Smart Features

7

Build Quality

8

Ease Of Use

8

Value for Money

7

Verdict

8

Our Review Ethos

Read about our review ethos and the meaning of our review badges here.


    1. The News Bot

      The News Bot News Supplying Robot Staff Member

      Joined:
      Sep 15, 2004
      Messages:
      17,504
      Trophy Points:
      103
      Ratings:
      +445
      Reviewed by Stephen Withers, 17th February 2013. Quite simply, the Philips 46PFL9707 delivers the best 2D picture we have seen from a LED LCD TV to date. For this reason alone it deserves a demo but once you include all its other features, the 46PFL9707 becomes a very attractive proposition and as long as you're not into 3D it's highly recommended.
      Read the full review...
    2. vaktmestern

      vaktmestern Active Member

      Joined:
      Apr 20, 2012
      Messages:
      2,390
      Trophy Points:
      86
      Ratings:
      +288
      How is the gaming lag? and did u test the dual gaming function with the ative glasses? :cool:
    3. Fabienr

      Fabienr Member

      Joined:
      Jun 1, 2012
      Messages:
      99
      Trophy Points:
      11
      Ratings:
      +8
      I have the 60inch model and this is an outstanding TV, was looking for a new TV for months before getting this model which is not available in the UK (got it from France).
      For the 3D I didn't find any issue usingflicker free setting, maybe due to the size or the firmware update, but no real crosstalk for me.
      Input lag, I play a fair amount of game and didn't find it an issue.
    4. pragmatic

      pragmatic Active Member

      Joined:
      Nov 9, 2004
      Messages:
      9,644
      Trophy Points:
      133
      Ratings:
      +1,031
      Can this actually be bought anywhere or is like ever other top end Phillips model of the last few years where loads of UK reviews but 'not available in the UK'?
    5. scrapbook

      scrapbook Active Member

      Joined:
      Jan 12, 2002
      Messages:
      6,703
      Trophy Points:
      106
      Ratings:
      +441
      What causes the banding you see in this TV and seems quite common amongst all TV's these days?
    6. Christoffero89

      Christoffero89 Member

      Joined:
      Jan 13, 2009
      Messages:
      111
      Trophy Points:
      18
      Ratings:
      +3
      Is this model much better then 8007? I am thinking of buying 55pfl8007. Is it better to buy that or 46pfl9xxx?
    7. Steve Withers

      Steve Withers Assistant Editor

      Joined:
      Oct 18, 2009
      Messages:
      4,878
      Trophy Points:
      136
      Ratings:
      +1,831
      The input lag is discussed in the Test Results section. Unfortunately I wasn't able to test the dual gaming feature.
    8. Steve Withers

      Steve Withers Assistant Editor

      Joined:
      Oct 18, 2009
      Messages:
      4,878
      Trophy Points:
      136
      Ratings:
      +1,831
      In the case of the 46PFL9707 it was caused by the columns of LEDs directly behind the panel but it was very minor and definitely didn't detract from a fantastic image. It certainly shouldn't be confused with the terrible banding seen on many TVs that use edge LED lighting.
    9. Steve Withers

      Steve Withers Assistant Editor

      Joined:
      Oct 18, 2009
      Messages:
      4,878
      Trophy Points:
      136
      Ratings:
      +1,831
      I can't answer that I'm afraid, this is the first Philips I've reviewed in over two years.
    10. Steve Withers

      Steve Withers Assistant Editor

      Joined:
      Oct 18, 2009
      Messages:
      4,878
      Trophy Points:
      136
      Ratings:
      +1,831
      I'd love to see a 60" version!

      I tried the Flicker Free setting but it didn't make any difference to the crosstalk on my review sample.

      As I said in the review, most people probably won't be bothered by a 50ms input lag.
    11. Barrovian

      Barrovian Member

      Joined:
      Oct 29, 2002
      Messages:
      882
      Trophy Points:
      31
      Ratings:
      +47
      I've got the 46pfl7007 and have been trying to track down the pre set ISF settings that higher end models such as this one seem to come with. I don't suppose you ( or anyone else who has this set ) can remember them and would mind posting them here please?:lease:

      JP
    12. gaaron

      gaaron Member

      Joined:
      Feb 8, 2013
      Messages:
      42
      Trophy Points:
      11
      Ratings:
      +8
      What a wonderful read. But I must, I must stay within my budget & go for the 46pfl8007t.:thumbsup:
      • Thanks Thanks x 1
    13. pragmatic

      pragmatic Active Member

      Joined:
      Nov 9, 2004
      Messages:
      9,644
      Trophy Points:
      133
      Ratings:
      +1,031
      The moth eye lens is only on the 46 series 9 model. Other than that no idea, there is a comparison tool on the Philips site, but its pretty difficult to find people who sell them never mind demo them.
    14. Steve Withers

      Steve Withers Assistant Editor

      Joined:
      Oct 18, 2009
      Messages:
      4,878
      Trophy Points:
      136
      Ratings:
      +1,831
      Doesn't your 46PFL7007 have a Movie preset?
    15. Christoffero89

      Christoffero89 Member

      Joined:
      Jan 13, 2009
      Messages:
      111
      Trophy Points:
      18
      Ratings:
      +3
      I went for the 50pfl8007. Wanted a good tv. Don't need the best one. Bigger size also and cheaper:). The store can only order the 9 series and I never buy something I can't see first. The 8007 picture was amazing. The demo model was showing Spider-Man, wow
    16. Dorset Dave

      Dorset Dave Member

      Joined:
      Feb 21, 2007
      Messages:
      652
      Trophy Points:
      28
      Ratings:
      +29
      Why oh why can't Philips solve the problem of crosstalk? Other manufacturers, notably Panasonic, have pretty much got to grips with it so why is Philips finding it so difficult? It's so frustrating as I was seriously considering this model until I read the otherwise excellent review. I know for most people 3D is not foremost in their mind when chosing a tv but I am a big fan of it as, when done properly, 3D can add so much more to our viewing pleasure.
    17. Fabienr

      Fabienr Member

      Joined:
      Jun 1, 2012
      Messages:
      99
      Trophy Points:
      11
      Ratings:
      +8
      a - Maybe Firmware update is or will be improving 3D performance
      b -My TV is not affected by cross talk, other reviews like "Les numeriques/DigitalVersus" or HD-Fever have also panels with good 3D performance.

      This TV is probably not as good in 3D as Panasonic or Samsung however.
    18. gaaron

      gaaron Member

      Joined:
      Feb 8, 2013
      Messages:
      42
      Trophy Points:
      11
      Ratings:
      +8
      Hi, I can only find 46pfl8007t at 'brighthouse?' Luckily I was able to have a 40pfl7007t for a short while..it looked smaller than my tv. So after researching and reading this brill forum I'm plumping for 46/8007. Can you say where you got yours from please?:confused:
    19. Christoffero89

      Christoffero89 Member

      Joined:
      Jan 13, 2009
      Messages:
      111
      Trophy Points:
      18
      Ratings:
      +3
      I live in Norway. So it can be an expensive trip for the tv
    20. gaaron

      gaaron Member

      Joined:
      Feb 8, 2013
      Messages:
      42
      Trophy Points:
      11
      Ratings:
      +8
      Ha ha...suppose I could have a trip :laugh: but I suppose I'd have only enough money to buy a CRT (saying that, mine had a brill pic)..
      Last edited: Feb 18, 2013
    21. Barrovian

      Barrovian Member

      Joined:
      Oct 29, 2002
      Messages:
      882
      Trophy Points:
      31
      Ratings:
      +47
      Yes, it does. Am I being thick here?:blush: Are you going to tell me they're one and the same?:facepalm: :)
      Last edited: Feb 18, 2013
    22. Christoffero89

      Christoffero89 Member

      Joined:
      Jan 13, 2009
      Messages:
      111
      Trophy Points:
      18
      Ratings:
      +3
      Well. Norway have som pretty good CRT tv:)


      I hope my new 55pfl8007 is a good tv. In worst case scenario I have 30 days return right here so I can return it and go for the smaller 46pfl 9707:). Win win
    23. Steve Withers

      Steve Withers Assistant Editor

      Joined:
      Oct 18, 2009
      Messages:
      4,878
      Trophy Points:
      136
      Ratings:
      +1,831
      Based on my testing of the 46PFL9707, yes they are the same, so just use the Movie mode.
      • Thanks Thanks x 1
    24. Christoffero89

      Christoffero89 Member

      Joined:
      Jan 13, 2009
      Messages:
      111
      Trophy Points:
      18
      Ratings:
      +3
      The banding issue. Is it a big problem that wil irritate me when I watch movies?
    25. gaaron

      gaaron Member

      Joined:
      Feb 8, 2013
      Messages:
      42
      Trophy Points:
      11
      Ratings:
      +8
      I'll let you ponder:laugh:
      • Thanks Thanks x 1
    26. gaaron

      gaaron Member

      Joined:
      Feb 8, 2013
      Messages:
      42
      Trophy Points:
      11
      Ratings:
      +8
      From reading these threads, it appears that you all appear to be able to return your tv's if unsatisfied? Which shops are these? I only thought shopping channels did that....my confession as to why I was able to have a go at the 7007t ;
      Last edited: Feb 18, 2013
    27. tomy14

      tomy14 Member

      Joined:
      Feb 18, 2013
      Messages:
      1
      Trophy Points:
      1
      Ratings:
      +0
      Why did you test the black level without activating the LEDs? That does not make sense for a Full LED TV. In other tests the TV measured excellent blacks levels of 0,015 cm/2 with activated LED dimming.
    28. Steve Withers

      Steve Withers Assistant Editor

      Joined:
      Oct 18, 2009
      Messages:
      4,878
      Trophy Points:
      136
      Ratings:
      +1,831
      We always measure the native black levels of a panel because that is more informative. If you turn the LEDs off then obviously you'll get a very low or even zero black level but what does that actually tell you? The micro dimming was highly effective though, among the best I've ever seen.
      Last edited: Feb 19, 2013
    29. Steve Withers

      Steve Withers Assistant Editor

      Joined:
      Oct 18, 2009
      Messages:
      4,878
      Trophy Points:
      136
      Ratings:
      +1,831
      No it's very minor and I don't think you should worry about it. The banding on my Kuro is much more noticeable.
    30. Steve Withers

      Steve Withers Assistant Editor

      Joined:
      Oct 18, 2009
      Messages:
      4,878
      Trophy Points:
      136
      Ratings:
      +1,831
      I have been speaking to Philips and they are going to provide me with an email address for people to ask directly about where to buy the Moth Eye and the 55PFL8007.

      The reason it's difficult to find the Moth Eye in stores is because not many dealers want to stock a 46" TV costing £2300, so they just order them up when they need them. The 55PFL8007 is in a few of the hi-end independents but apparently it should become more widely available in the near future.

      With regards to the differences between the Moth Eye and the 8007 - the main differences are that the Moth Eye is direct micro dimmable, whilst the 8007 is edge lit and the 9707 obviously has the Moth Eye filter and a Premium version of the Bright Pro system for higher peak light output, so consequently the Moth Eye has a wider dynamic range. The Moth Eye also has a wider gamut panel and a higher 1200hz v 800hz motion processing but all other processing is the same.
      • Thanks Thanks x 3
  • Screen

    Display LED
    Backlight Type Full
    Display Format 1080p Full HD
    Screen Size 46 In
    Resolution 1920 x 1080 Pixels
    1080p24 Support Yes
    Claimed Contrast Ratio 150,000,000:1
    3D Technology Active
    Refresh Rate 1200 Hz
    Aspect Ratio 16:9
    Picture-in-Picture PiP
    Image Enhancement Engine Perfect Pixel HD

    Digital-TV

    Tuner Freeview
    Freeview HD
    Freesat
    Freesat HD
    EPG Yes

    Features

    3D Accessories Active Glasses
    PVR Features External PVR Ready
    Smart TV Yes
    Smart TV Features WiDi
    Miracast
    DLNA
    Skype Ready
    Video on Demand Access
    Media Player
    Web Browser
    App Store Access
    Remote App
    File Formats WMV9
    MPEG1
    MPEG2
    MPEG4
    MKV
    AVCHD
    AVI
    WMA
    MP3
    AAC
    JPEG

    Sound

    Speakers Stereo
    Speaker Output 40 Watts
    Supported Sound Formats Dolby Digital
    Dolby Digital Plus

    Product Properties

    Energy Efficiency Class A
    Power Consumption 80 watts
    Power Consumption (Standby) 0.1 watts
    Release Year 2012
    Warranty Yes
    Screen Size 117 cm
    Width (With Stand) 1070 mm
    Height (With Stand) 691 mm
    Depth (With Stand) 241 mm
    Weight 20.7 Kg
    Width (Without Stand) 1070 mm
    Height (Without Stand) 629 mm
    Depth (Without Stand) 46 mm

    Connections

    HDMI Type HDMI
    HDMI with ARC
    HDMI with MHL
    HDMI 1.4
    HDMI Inputs 5
    Scart Connections 1
    Component Inputs 1
    Composite Inputs 1
    USB Ports 3
    Common Interface Slot Yes
    Ethernet Port Yes
    Digital Audio Out Yes
    Headphone Socket Yes
    Analogue Audio In Yes
    Wi-Fi Built-in
  • Philips to maintain TV brand in the UK following takeover

    by Mark Hodgkinson

    The Philips brand is to live on in the UK as they confirm to us that it's going to be business as usual

    Jan 23, 2014

    Home AV News

    Philips to transfer remainder of TV business to TPV

    by Mark Hodgkinson

    Philips are to take exit of the TV manufacturing business altogether after agreeing to transfer its remaining stake to TPV technology. It looks as though the brand will live on but who will be next to go?

    Jan 22, 2014

    Home AV News

    IFA 2013 - First Look at Philips New Cloud TV

    by Steve Withers

    Philips revamped Smart TV portal is all about the Cloud

    Sep 10, 2013

    Home AV News

  • Philips and TP Vision - The journey continues...

    by Steve Withers

    Philips introduce their new TV line-up for 2013 at a press event in Amsterdam.

    Feb 28, 2013

    Home AV Article

  • Loading