Started playing this game last week after buying the GOY edition for £7!!
I voted an 8. Perhaps I was a tad harsh with an 8 - maybe a 9 would have been better.
Considering the game is over 2 years old, this game is astounding. It beats recent games into a pulp. The graphics are amazing, with stunning scenery and excellent face animations.
The world is very believable and totally absorbing. You can just wander around for hrs on end and not get bored with it. Love the dungeon crawling and hunting for loot.
I'm only 20 hrs in and my current quests log is as long as my arm. Only completed the first 2 quests of the main mission.
Anyway, cracking game 8/9 out of 10 from moi.