exactly the thread I was waiting for !
Hope GORDON can fill in the missing details...
I am looking to upgrade in order to eliminate the horrendous MOTION ARTEFACTS that I have with my current 3 yr old Philips 32" 100Hz 32PW9763/25.
<
http://www.homecinemachoice.com/test...PW976325.shtml>.
Loewe with progressive scan is my current favoured option.
(1) PRO SCAN on the LOEWE...
I've talked to 2 techies at Loewe UK and at Owl Video (for the silicon image iScan pro). Here's what I found out:
- Feed an already processed ProScan signal through the VGA module.
- iScan pro has 3 inputs and auto detects NTSC and PAL. It also outputs the ProScan signal at the same frequency as the interlaced input signal. (i.e.: doesn't output PAL 60).
- Fitting an extra Loewe gizmo on the back of the tube allows 800 x 600 resolution. (costs about 50 quid) Not confirmed yet if this would also allow de-interlaced / ProScan at the higher resolution.
- Current chassis (2400) will only lock onto a 60Hz ProScan signal. They believe the forthcoming 2500 chassis will lock onto a 50 Hz ProScan signal, but this chassis is only available now in the 28" Vitros at the moment. Other Vitros & Aconda sizes should follow fairly soon with the new 2500 chassis.
What I still find confusing is - how different would the picture look when using a VGA vs SVGA resolution with ready processed Pro Scan input. Not having had the good fortune to see all this set up (yet) I can only go off experience with PC display settings.. (!!)
(2) on MOTION ARTEFACTS
Where from ?
For me, these are most noticable on Sky Digital... but the more I look the more / easier I see them... and even see it on a few of my DVD's now. Mainly three things:
- edge distortion / shimmering, typically / most easily noticed around edges of moving objects / people. Looks a bit like heat haze
- picture crawl. Parts of an image (eg.: parts of a face) seem to float around relative to each other. Very disconcerting (and unnatural)
- general tizziness. Stand about 2' from screen and tilt your head sideways 90°... you see it all better.. including scan lines
This is with Noise Reduction and Natural Motion off
Why ?
Guy at Owl Video said artefacts are caused by low bit rate on some Sky channels, and I guess ultimately it's down to how much the digital processing in the set is 'upset' by low bit rates (as 50 Hz sets don't do it). I think low bit rate may more often cause the picture crawl effect, whereas my Philips has bad motion edge effects all the time (to various extents) on Sky channels... even after I recently upgraded from Pace Mk 1 Sky Digibox to a new Panasonic Digibox. so it's obviously the TV
I just spent some time looking at a 28" VITROS (with 2500 chassis) with a Mk 1 Pace digibox and still saw some (but much reduced) edge motion effects on Sky channels - but it was still there, so either the Loewe is not infallible here, or it was the old Pace digibox - or both.
What I need to see is - using the Silicon Image iScan pro feeding ProScan signal (from DVD and Sky) through a Loewe VGA (SVGA ?) input.. do you ELIMINATE the motion artefacts which plague the in-set digital processing ?
is the SIL503 chip set doing a better job that the gubbins inside the TV...
I assume that the LOEWE VGA input module totally by passes the set's digital gimmickry and basically send the signal "straight to the 3 guns".
Besides any other improvement from the iScan - this will be the acid test for me.
Also recently saw the iScan in action on a ceiling mounted SELECO CRT projector with (non-proScan) DV88... very impressed.
Guy at owl video even said he prefers the look of the iScan picture compared to the ProScan output on a ARCAM 27 FMJ.. surprising, as it's the same chip set.
Gordon ????!!!!! any more to add ????
Steve