[mrtbag]

I was thinking about players who have had an impact on their teams season.

If I have forgotten any, please be sure to give them a mention.

[Sirkerz]

Can only be Berbatov

[DJT75]

Berbatov followed by McCarthy & Mascherano.....

[mrtbag]

Damn. Forgot McCarthy. Anybody know a way to add him?

[GBDG1]

I think that Adebeyor came in January last season.

[Tom Tom]

I said Tevez,

I mean the impact on the team could be huge.....
Not on the field.
Just in the bank books, or points....

[mrtbag]

Originally Posted by Lawrenzini

I think that Adebeyor came in January last season.

You are right, but he played all his first team games this season. So he is new, sort of!!

[Speedoguy]

The Berbmaster for me.Great first year and playing for a few years in the Bundesliga was a help as one of the more physical leagues in europe.

[madcyril]

Can only be Berbatov for me too,why we didnt chase him I dont know.If Utd do try to force TH's hand we will end up paying 3times what they paid.

[Rich]

Some you missed out are.....

Joleon Lescott
Sol Campbell
David James
Andy Johnson
Ben Foster (I'm not sure if he counts)

I'm undecided between Tezez and Berbatov.

Definitely not Carrick......he could have been bought in 2004 for about £3.5 million, But I suppose his signing did improve Man U's prospects of winning the Premiership.

[po_man]

I reckon Berbatov just shades Tevez followed closely by ... Baptista ...

[eFGee]

Ooh Mr t Bag

Blatently stolen from my thread. Is nothing sacred to you Spuds.

[mrtbag]

Originally Posted by eFGee

Blatently stolen from my thread. Is nothing sacred to you Spuds.

I prefer to give people more that one option to discuss.

[Greg]

I would vote for Andy Johnson.

[Steven]

He's got long flowing hair, good looking and the can play!

[dc007]

I'm admitedly biased, but it has to be Berbatov.

On a strictly 'pounds per goal' basis, Bennie McCarthy would win. But Berbatov has also had 9 or 10 assists, and has done so much more than just score.

I've also been impressed with Dirk Kuyt and think he will do better still next year. He has a never-say-die, never stop running, work ethic that I very much admire.

Credit to Harry Redknapp for his signings of Judas and David James - both have been superb.

Michael Carrick has done well, very well if you ignore his inflated price tag.

Joleon Lescott deserves a nod, too.

[rio1981]

Berbatov would probably get my vote, with Tevez and McCarthy running him close.

Surprised - unless I've missed it - that no-one has mentioned Woodgate?

[ash]

How the hell does Babtista get a mention?

Oh yhh... his Carling Cup run

[Marc]

from the list Berbatov definitely, he is the main reason Spurs finished as high as they did.

For value though, McCarthy at Blackburn £100,000 per goal isn't a bad price

Tevez deserves a mention as well, because i don't think West Ham paid a lot, if anything, for him and he saved them from relegation.

Can i call Ronaldo the signing of the season? It might not have been this season but he's the signing of all seasons!

[johnscarlet]

Mikel was a great signing for UTD , we made £10mil on him without him even setting foot in Old Trafford

[Steven]

Originally Posted by ash

How the hell does Babtista get a mention?

Oh yhh... his Carling Cup run

Yeah, some of the Gooooooooners need to take the spectacles off Off the top of my head, Derbyshire and Arteta are 10x more deserving than the Real reject. Goals and assists over the whole season and have been integral to their respective teams (something you can't say about the Brazilian) - what has he done? Oh right, a couple of goals in the minority cup that they didn't win anyway

And the top two must be the jokers

[sdb123]

Originally Posted by mrtbag

You are right, but he played all his first team games this season. So he is new, sort of!!

He played 13 league games for Arsenal last season....

[po_man]

Originally Posted by LFC_SL

Yeah, some of the Gooooooooners need to take the spectacles off Off the top of my head, Derbyshire and Arteta are 10x more deserving than the Real reject. Goals and assists over the whole season and have been integral to their respective teams (something you can't say about the Brazilian) - what has he done? Oh right, a couple of goals in the minority cup that they didn't win anyway

And the top two must be the jokers

Hmmm, the only mention of Baptista, apart from in the opening post, was made by me and i can assure you it was written with tongue firmly in cheek!!

[Steven]

Don't mind me. I was posting directly in response only to ash - hence the quote. Had it been directed to other posters, I would have made it clear

[hottstuff]

Voted Babtista , its Baptista OP
But seriously , it has to be Berbatov without a doubt.

[gosties]

In my opinion it has to Berbatov. He is far more complete player than I imagined when he signed for Tottenham. He reminds me of Berkgamp in the way that he plays the game. He always seems to have the ball under control, he has a good awareness of what is around him. Robbie Keane has a looked a far better player since his signing.

Been impressed by Arteta and Kuyt also.

Dodgy Signings

Khalid Boulharouz (The Cannibal) - top class signing for Chelsea
Shevchenko/Ballack (The Retirement fund) Neither player has a kicked a ball for Chelsea in my opinion this season.
William Gallas (Sicknote) Quality player but injured almost as much as Anderton

[Steven]

Originally Posted by gosties

Dodgy Signings

Khalid Boulharouz (The Cannibal) - top class signing for Chelsea

lol, understatement of the year You can almost trace each penalty he has given away to the number of points Chelski ended up finishing behind Utd

[Woodywizz]

Why has noone mentioned Corradi

Seriously though, it has to be Berbatov - great player who will only get better.

As for Carrick being suggested

[INSOMANiAC]

This poll is unfair. There is no Samaras

[gosties]

Nicholas Anelka has done quite well for Bolton this season. He is always a risky signing for any club involved. Quality finisher and his pace always makes him a threat.

Who knows how his career would have gone if he had stayed at Arsenal.