| Re: Manchester Home Entertainment Show 2006
Just got back from the Manchester Home Entertainment show, and I have to say it was a bit of a let down after last year, last year there was a real energy and buzz about the place, and of course the girls in hot pants! This year there were fewer exhibitors, no girls, and I detected a bit more cynicism amongst the exhibitors.
I was REALLY looking forward to seeing Blu Ray this year, WHAT A DISASTER! The split screen demo was utterly appaling, the SD TV had it's colour calibration so far off it was untrue, the sunset looked green, it was a joke, I don't know who Samsung thought they were fooling with that disaster. The Blu Ray demo was dreadful, just really slow pans over watches and landscapes, told me nothing about how Blu Ray handles fast motion, multi way pans etc. In short it was designed to make the player look good, but told me nothing about how it would perform on real world movies. It would have had value if they'd brought over a handful of US titles which are now available, but this was laughable. In Curry's or Comet I'd expect this, but come on, this show appeals to enthusiasts like us, do they really think we're so stupid as to not realise what they're trying to pull off? There was no Panasonic (I really wanted to see their Blu Ray player and new 1080p projector), I was also very dissappointed there was no HD-DVD on show from anyone, and with no Toshiba to fly the flag it made the demo of Blu Ray even less relevant.
Sony's new SXRD rear projection set did look very impressive, I saw a VPL-VW50 in the flesh and was impressed with it's compact size, in comparison with the Qualia 004. I really couldn't be bothered waiting around for the demo, but as a friend of mine has purchase on of these from Europe I am looking forward to seeing it next week.
The Big Fujitsu panels looked impressive, pity they haven't admitted that the game is up for plasma given their limited service life in comparison with LCD, ditto Pioneer. Probably my vote for the most awful product at the show is Pioneer's new mains networking product, it places modulated crap on the mains and screw up your mains supply for Hi Fi and home theater, and probably that of your 10 closest neighbours. I hope to god this fails hideously, the last thing we need are manufacturers deliberately polluting the mains supply.
Denon had some interesting new equipment on show, but I really wished it would have been working, I think their new format of having a huge range of equipment on static demo really doesn't work as well as their huge 'Grand Slam' demo's of previous years. I would have really liked to have seen their new £1K Realta HQV equipped DVD player, along with their £650 mini HQV player, but their wasn't a single player connected up to a display, sadly a wasted opportunity.
I went in to Quad's room to hear the new panels. I really cannot see what all the fuss is about, the image had mediocre focus, and yes, the bass is better, but it's still lagging far behind the Martin Logan Summit's and Vantage's I've heard previously. If you go to the UKD room on the second floor you can hear the Final 600 panels, and they killed the Quad's in every respect and they cost £3,400, gorgeous design, well made, great imaging, overall truly excellent sound, and they were playing real music when I got there, not plinky plonky Hi Fi stuff. Henlet had some new amps, I think they called them Platinum, they're built like the Audia equipment they distribute, but they sounded great, and they had some of the best sound at the show playing KraftWerk 'Tour De France' on Vinyl!! I've never heard a Roksan turntable sound so musical.
JM Lab had some new 800 series floorstanding speakers, they're going to be £1K but sounded great driven by the new Sugden A21 MK.II amps (yes they've finally updated them after about 15 years). Wish they'd have had the Beryllium Elektra's there, they are meant to be great but I've never managed to hear a pair yet. Talking about Sugden, heard ProAc with the big Sugden Masterclass amp and CD player, they sounded very good, but I felt the speakers they were using (D28 £3,500) seemed very expensive in comparison with the Final panels and the JM Lab's.
Killer demos of the day came from Dali and Townshend Audio. Dali had the BEST image at the show, some Hi Def downloads off the 'net courtesy of a UVEM HTPC. I don't know much about UVEM, but this was superb. The Dali bookshelf speakers sounded really good, but the video was amazing, the guys on the ground floor could learn a lot from this demo. Townshend Audio had some new speakers there, smaller than their previous Glastonbury models and much cheaper (£6K) but the whole system, all using Townshend VSSS stands, had a speed, clarity and transparency which just killed every other demo there.
Overall then, for stereo enthusiasts it wasn't bad, for HT and video though it was something of a disaster, I would give it a miss this year and hope they put some effort in next year, with truly impressive video demo's using commercially available material.
Dave
|