Quote:
Originally Posted by keithr59 There is nothing in the update that I can see that addresses a fan noise issue but then not everyone has experienced this problem. In fact, reading the various postings on this forum it only seems to be a minor issue which a few people like yourself have experienced and apparently can't live with.
If you are now proud owner of a TVOnics PVR I suggest that you move yourself to that forum as it is of little interest to the Digital Stream community. |
Oh dear!

I'll get me coat!

I'm not one to stay where I'm not wanted.

....However, I don't agree that my last point was of little interest to this community. Some of the people who've had major fan noise problems have asked about an alternative PVR. Indeed, I discovered the fanless model on another Digital Stream forum where various fan-noise-afflicted people had asked for a quieter alternative. I was grateful to the person on that forum who brought the DTR-Z500HD to my attention, and I wanted to pass on that information, in case anyone here might benefit from it if they found the DS fan noise unbearable. (A few random samples below just to illustrate that it's more than a minor problem...)
Anyway, my intention was purely to be helpful to anyone who'd given up on the DS due to the fan noise. Genuine good intentions, and certainly no offence intended. Apologies if recommending a quieter model is considered unacceptable around here, but I'm new to the thread (....and I've only lasted three weeks on it before being banished!)
Quote:
Originally Posted by ciderspace I went through 4 DS's before finally finding one that works properly. The 1st's fan would come on quite soon after powering on and it was unbearably loud. The replacements were much improved (further helped by v3.57 of the OS) but I could still hear them, even with the current 4th. . |
Quote:
Originally Posted by Boogersa Just thought I would add my tuppence worth regarding fan noise.
I thought that the fan on my DS was loud and it was a bit of a distraction. I tried the unscrewing tip but it had minimal effect. I certainly could hear it above the noise of the tv. I took it back to JL at the weekend and was expecting to have one which was silent but it has fan noise too although it is not as loud as the first one. I can't hear it as badly whilst the TV is on and it is not too intrusive but it is still there. |
Quote:
Originally Posted by ads43 I didn't ask for a quieter PVR, I asked for a for a different quiet PVR because I am having no luck with the Digital Stream.
I think it is a major flaw if customers have to buy a product and replace, and replace to get something that should be right in the first place (and is pot luck if you get it). I will speak to MIT London and see what they say.
Isolated incidents are understandable but this isn't especially if people are wanting the option to turn off the fan in the March update. |
Quote:
Originally Posted by ads43 Just an update from my original post about fan noise.
I ended up getting my Digital Stream replaced by John Lewis (excellent service - within 2 days).
However the replacement is just as bad as the first one I had, so is likely to go back as well! It actually had the latest update on it.
It's such as shame a great box can have such a major flaw and it appears to be pot luck if you get a quiet or loud one.
I think I'll try the Humax unless anyone can recommend a different quiet PVR. |
Quote:
Originally Posted by Canis Major DonnyMark,
Interesting you should say that you bought it in november last year. I noticed a loud fan noise on the DS that I bought. I sit just under 3m away from the tv and yet during quiet periods of a show I could clearly hear the fan buzzing away. My 9200t on the other hand is very quiet - I can only hear the fan when I stick my head right next to it. Even though I bought my DS quite recently (from John Lewis) it had a fault indicative of the earlier batches so I've since returned it and I'm sticking with my 9200t for the time being, even though I am itching to go HD. |
Quote:
Originally Posted by DonnyMark I have mine on an open shelf, with nothing next to it at all, and can honestly say that when the fan kicks in, it is nearly as loud as the xBox that is on the shelf above. I have tried to slacken the screws to see if this helps, it does a little but the noise is still clearly heard unless there is music or constant sound on the program I am watching.
It spoils my enjoyment of watching the program as I am constantly listening for whether the fan is on or off.
I guess some people can live with it more than others.
Its not that I have the sound low either as I turn it up to try and hide the fan noise.
I read about the option to turn it off in the next update, I hope so as this is my only complaint in what is otherwise an excellent product.
Heres hoping......  |
Quote:
Originally Posted by ads43 Hi
I have purchased this PVR and been using it for the last couple of days. I really like it apart from the fan noise.
I have installed the latest updates, but there is still a lot of regular noise from the fan.
The PVR is silent for about 30 mins, then the fan kicks in for another 30 mins, then it goes silent again for 30 mins, then the fan comes on and carries on like this.
Unfortunately the fan noise can be heard above the TV.
Is this how the fan normally works or have I been unlucky and should try and get a replacement?
I have read about loosening the screws but don't want to play around in case it has to go back.
Would the fan on the Humax work the same way or is it quieter?
Thanks in advance |