I FINALLY got my copy of this today and absolutely love it!! Granted, I'm a big college hoops fan but if you're into basketball at all I honestly think you'll really enjoy this.
The commentary is better than I thought, but still needs work (if Nessler goes on about good fouls one more time!!!), but the presentation is absolutely amazing. Camera angles, overlays, stats, etc. are all dead on to each network. Finally the replays don't just show the last play. Just like on tv, when there is a break in the action they'll go back to the big plays, even if it was a few minutes ago.
The gameplay is actually much better than I expected as well after reading the reviews. I'm not seeing a lot of the complaints I've read about and am seeing a lot of nice little touches. I also find the moves a lot easier to pull off than in 2K games.
Don't get me wrong, it's not perfect by any means but I can't remember the last time I played a new game for so long with a big smile on my face.