|
OK, it wasn't exactly scientific but I made sure all the common components were the same and tested each item. They were the £9.75 item mentioned above and also the chrome and black Hitachi item available for £14.99. I also had a third model but the idiots at Argos gave me the more expensive auto switching model, which did not have RGB, instead of the cheaper (by a tenner) manual model. No RGB - no thanks!
I was expecting to write a really indepth review but having tried both of them, I really couldn't tell the difference between the non-switched signal and the switched signal! Bear in mind that I only have a 28 inch Sony Wega though, and that the only source I used was my ageing Sky Pace Digibox.
The Hitachi may have given a less sharp picture but I can't be 100% sure, this could have been a consequence of the in-bult scart lead which connects the switcher to the TV. Since the cheaper model did not include such a lead, I used my expensive QED RGB only lead instead.
Colours and brightness level also seemed unaffected by the addition of the switchers. I didn;t test sound quality.
For value for money and build quality, the cheaper model wins hands down. It is made of metal and also has sockets for composite video plugs. It is very sturdy. It also allows the VCR to be routed to a different source by way of a switch. Its major pitfalls is the styling and its size, and also the fact that you have to have access to an extra lead to run the signal to the TV.
The Hitachi on the other hand is much more pleasing to look at, if a little lightwieght. Suction caps at the base allow you to plant the item securely on the equipment stand without fear of it falling off. Its construction is plastic but uses oxygen free copper cable!
Both items are good and in the end i Chose the £9.75 item. Your choice might be different depending on whether you have the spare scart cable or not.
Last edited by jian; 22-02-2005 at 5:38 PM.
|