Quote:
Originally posted by dave48
I'd be very interested if anyone has a few recommendations for absolute killer SACDs - something to show what the format can really do.
Dave48 |
My collection of SACD's is over 60 at this point. Sound quality varies greatly. The source material is certainly a big factor but how much is hard to quess. On the whole, Sony's titles are the weakest. They do have some thriumphs but then they have the most releases. I think the very best sound quality is coming from DMP, Heads Up, and Telarc. Rounder, AudioQuest, and Chesky are a small notch back.
Chesky could be up with the frontrunners except their multi-channel mixes are miserable. They aren't using a centre channel! Their centreless philosophy might be OK if you optimized your equipment for their discs? I'm not gonnna! On my 6.1 system their multi-channel mixes sound echoey and muffled. On the good side of the equation, their stereo mixes are outstanding.
The single best sounding SACD that I've heard is: Oscar Peterson & Ray Brown & Milt Jackson's THE VERY TALL BAND LIVE AT THE BLUE NOTE, Telarc ( CD-83443-SA ). It's pure DSD from the studio to the disc. I would not describe the performance here by these old codgers as earth shaking but the sound quality is obvious.
The Vivino Brothers' BLUES BAND is recorded live to DSD and sounds great. It sounds good played in stereo or multi-channel. It's a nice mix of jazz, R & B, and some blues. It's on the DMP label, ( SACD-11 ).
Manfredo Fest's JUST JOBIM on DMP ( SACD-05 ) is outstanding. If you like Brazillian jazz buy this disc! I hope Fest's JUNGLE CAT CD gets SACD treatment. It might not sound quite as good as JJ but it's a great album, and DMP has the rights to it.
Junior Wells' COME ON IN THIS HOUSE has been upsampled to DSD from a 1996 recording session. It's sound quality isn't quite the titles I've mentioned so far but it ain't chopped liver! It sounds excellent in M-C or stereo. There's a flock of quest slide quitarists too. Telarc ( SACD-63395 )
Monty Alexander's MONTY MEETS SLY AND ROBBIE is a nice collection of poppy sounding jazz. It's upsampled from PCM to DSD but sounds way better than average. Sounds great in stereo or M-C. Telarc ( SACD-63494 )
Spyro Gyra's IN MODERN TIMES es muy excellente. I think it's upsampled from PCM. It's a nice variety of jazz, man the horns are smooth, that sounds great in M-C or stereo. Heads Up ( HUSA 9061 ) < The cover says that it's available in CD, hybrid SACD, and DVD-A. It could make great shootout fodder?
Ana Caram's BLUE BOSSA is wonderful in stereo. If you like the 1960's bossa nova sound you'll love this album. The down side is that the M-C mix sucks. Chesky ( SACD226 )
Laura Nyro's ANGEL IN THE DARK is a great collection by the late queen of pop-swing. It features 3 more cut's than Rounder's previously issued CD of same title. This and a Alison Krauss title are their first foray into SACD. It's a good start. It's in stereo. Rounder ( SACD 11661-3176-6 )
The new Mobile Fidelity's first releases are 3 albums by Patricia Barber. I got MODERN COOL
( UDSACD 2003 ) & CAFE BLUE ( UDSACD 2002 ). Nice hybrid stereo discs. I can't find fault with them.
Sony discs that sound well above average:
Al Dimeoa & John McLaughlin & Paco DeLucia's FRIDAY NIGHT IN SAN FRANCISCO
Tower Of Power's SOUL VACCINATION: TOWER OF POWER LIVE <the horns sizzle!
Keb' Mo's THE DOOR
Joe Satriani's ENGINES OF CREATION
I hope this gives you a starting point to test drive the format. Best wishes!