Greatest Hits Albums

eviljohn2 · 01-06-2005, 3:32 PM

Who really buys greatest hits albums these days? I've found that with CDs generally being a lot cheaper now than they were a decade or so ago that I don't bother and spend a bit longer getting to know a bands full back-catalogue. Of course this also avoids the problem of most GH albums being a shameless marketing ploy and often miss out many of a bands best songs either through choice or rights issues.

I do like live albums though.

Kenny Glasgow · 01-06-2005, 3:42 PM

These days most GH albums come out for Christmas and usually have 2 or 3 new tracks to catch both the hardcore fan and the more casual fan

sh18 · 01-06-2005, 6:55 PM

i buy them only if ive just started to get into a band and missed a lot of there older stuff, i bought Iron Maidens 'Edward The Great' GH which definately contains some of the bands best songs.

MarkE19 · 01-06-2005, 7:18 PM

I've got a few GH CD's by bands/singers that have released a couple of singles I like, but would not say I was a real fan, or they have also released some real rubbish that I have tried to avoid.
I also have the 3 Queen GH albums simply because I have all their others and this just makes the set is complete. Same with a few other bands as well. Also as mentioned, they do oftain contain new tracks these days to get people to buy them.

Mark.

KoThreads · 01-06-2005, 7:34 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by MarkE19

I've got a few GH CD's by bands/singers that have released a couple of singles I like, but would not say I was a real fan, or they have also released some real rubbish that I have tried to avoid.
I also have the 3 Queen GH albums simply because I have all their others and this just makes the set is complete. Same with a few other bands as well. Also as mentioned, they do oftain contain new tracks these days to get people to buy them.

Mark.

Which to me normally shouts record company rip off. I avoid them and try to find a bands back catalog on the cheap.

Floodedstatue · 01-06-2005, 7:46 PM

I'll usually try to get the back catalogue, unless the band is a complete 'singles band' and the albums aren't up to much.

The last great Greatest Hits album I bought was Supergrass - 'Supergrass is 10' Absolutely brilliant from start to finish, and a good example of a great singles band with some mediocre albums

KoThreads · 01-06-2005, 8:14 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Floodedstatue

I'll usually try to get the back catalogue, unless the band is a complete 'singles band' and the albums aren't up to much.

The last great Greatest Hits album I bought was Supergrass - 'Supergrass is 10' Absolutely brilliant from start to finish, and a good example of a great singles band with some mediocre albums

Oh Flooded no. Supergrass. Please tell me it's not true. I really had begun to trust your judgement

Floodedstatue · 01-06-2005, 9:16 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Idoexist

Oh Flooded no. Supergrass. Please tell me it's not true. I really had begun to trust your judgement

I was surprised that it was as good as it is, but I stand by my decision

Idoexist - I'm sorry if I've stooped to a new low. I'll get my coat

Chox1988 · 03-06-2005, 4:38 PM

I'll only get a greatest hits album if its a band I have been told are good but haven't heard them myself, and relatively old so have a greatest hits album to release. Then there is always the internet

KoThreads · 04-06-2005, 12:13 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Abu

Then there is always the internet

True, but I dislike MP, MP3 Pro or WMA. Or any other music compression. It takes a lot of the feeling and space out. I only hope it never gets to the point where record companies switch to downloads as the only way of buying music. It would be terrible and the end for me.

04-06-2005, 2:21 PM

The most recent GH album I bought was Seal--Best of 1991-2004 DVD-A. Not a huge fan, but I've enjoyed his singles. Moreover, the MCH mixes are well done (and artist approved) AND on the DVD-A is a bonus album of many of the same songs (and few others) recorded in an acoustic setting (also MCH--and, I might add, quite nicely done). Plus a collection of 7-8 videos (it's in the next room, don't recall the exact number). Essentially, I've waited to buy any Seal music until a GH package was available, as my level of enthusiasm for his music doesn't warrant a full catalogue investment. With this set, I'd have bought it in standard CD if there wasn't a hi-res version--as I don't have any other of his albums.

A few other GH packages I've bought in the past couple of years are the REM--In Time collection and The Police collection--each because it offered hi-res MCH mixes. Would not have purchased them in standard CD format as I have what I like of their respective catalogues already.

For some of my favourite artists, if a GH package contains new material, I consider buying it (depends on how much of it there is and if it's any good).

04-06-2005, 2:21 PM	#11
Ovation Guest Posts: n/a	The most recent GH album I bought was Seal--Best of 1991-2004 DVD-A. Not a huge fan, but I've enjoyed his singles. Moreover, the MCH mixes are well done (and artist approved) AND on the DVD-A is a bonus album of many of the same songs (and few others) recorded in an acoustic setting (also MCH--and, I might add, quite nicely done). Plus a collection of 7-8 videos (it's in the next room, don't recall the exact number). Essentially, I've waited to buy any Seal music until a GH package was available, as my level of enthusiasm for his music doesn't warrant a full catalogue investment. With this set, I'd have bought it in standard CD if there wasn't a hi-res version--as I don't have any other of his albums. A few other GH packages I've bought in the past couple of years are the REM--In Time collection and The Police collection--each because it offered hi-res MCH mixes. Would not have purchased them in standard CD format as I have what I like of their respective catalogues already. For some of my favourite artists, if a GH package contains new material, I consider buying it (depends on how much of it there is and if it's any good).
	Quote