Current Ideas So far Steering Wheel Options
The G25 is still holding up strong for me. Like many here i purchased one with a Playseat and although reasonably happy i want to go to a higher level of comfort and build particular in the pedals. I rarely use the H shifter and prefer to run with the paddles and tbh i dont bother with GT5's Clutch compatibility.
It is however very annoying that if Forza 3 appears on X360 and is expected to be a great game that swapping wheels etc just isnt a simple process particulary with a racing cockpit. With Microsofts reluctance to support the G25 (if indeed technically possible) brings me to offering alternatives
Upcoming Products:
Of course the new GT3 wheel has caught my eye and is being considered to replace the G25. See it further down as it certainly looks the part.
Will Logitech Have a New Wheel In 2009?
Their is in my opinion a position in the market for a G25 with X360 support and if anthing go even further towards build quality.
Fantec are offering such a product so why cant Logitech. Then again its all down to licenscing but you would think a G25 replacement would be coming?
Fanatec
These guys have now brought out several wheels now, which surprised me as I remember all the fuss about the original Porsche Wheel coming and it was considered the G25 was better in many respects. Since then though their has been more wheels, why they made them look similar doesnt help and although i didnt know at the time you can actually buy a Fanatec wheel seperate from the pedals etc. The other option is that they can be adapted to run with G25 pedals, ahh that might be handy for some.
Wheel Products Wheel Accessories Wheel Comparison Chart Wheel Price Comparison Product Images Fanatec Forums
Being able to mix with other products is a unique advantage so far for Fanatec.
It would be a possible benifit for someone to replace the G25 wheel they already own with an X360 compatible wheel product and not have to purchase new pedals at all but continue to use their G25 pedals. The other main benifit of this is from an installation point of view in that only the Wheel need be changed rather than like trying to swap a G25 Wheel/Pedals out for an Official X360Wheel/Pedal set its just not feasable every time you want to play the other platform. It takes alot of time to position and tighten a wheel and pedals to any racing frame.
Also the Fanatec wheels have all the required buttons on the wheel and not like the G25 on the H-Shifter.
Thats one disadvantage of the G25 in my opinion having only 2 buttons.
Also the Fanatec wheels are considerabley thicker,chunkier than the G25 so may offer further comfort.
Heres an illustration of a neat designed wheel but with how many buttons?
Yes although you wouldnt think looking at it this wheel has the exact same amount of buttons / D-PAD as a G25 has with its shifter.
Lets look at the Fanatec Options Worth Considering
Porsche 911 Turbo S Wheel -Pure edition- Approx £180
This is the product im referrring to. Being compatible with X360 / PS3 / PC
This product also has backlit illumination for the wheels buttons (see you tube videos) although the new upcoming RS wheel does not include this feature.
Fanatec have it a little confusing with their products as the "Pure Edition" comes as only the wheel.
Please see the chart what comes with what and the features/specs each has.
Content:
Force Feedback leather racing wheel for Xbox360
power supply
Adapter to connect pedals of Microsoft wireless wheel for Xbox360
Adapter to connect pedals of Logitech G25
NOT included but available optional:
pedals
shifters
RF dongle for PlayStation®3 and PC compatibility
Compatibility:
Xbox360:
The wheel is compatible to all games which support the Microsoft wireless wheel for Xbox360.
The 6+1 Speed shifter is compatible to all future racing games which support this shifter.
With the optional RF dongle (PWTRF) you can upgrade the compatibility and make the wheel compatible to PlayStation®3 and PC games with full Force feedback effects
Pedal compatibility:
Microsoft wireless wheel for Xbox360
Logitech G25
Porsche 911 Carrera wheel
Porsche 911 Turbo S wheel
Fanatec Clubsport pedals
See here for details Porsche 911 Turbo S Wheel -ClubSport Edition- Approx £450
As a complete package the
"Clubsport Edition" includes the dongle, shifters and new metal pedals but costs an approx whoppping £450
Yes that is alot but these new pedals alone cost approx £200 if purchased as an extra. At least Fanatec give you the option of buying seperatly what you will need and like me if you may not want a shifter your not going to be paying for one if buying seperate. The part problem though with this is by the time you buy the basic product in the wheel itself then the clubsport pedals, and the USB dongle then theirs only approx £40 difference from buying the complete package anyways so you may as well have the gear shifters.
Is it worth paying approx £160 more for this product to have X360 support and fancy backlighting?
It would nearly be as feasible like me if you didnt want the gear shifters in buying the GT3 Clubsport wheel below with the pedals and a seperate Turbo S wheel on its own with only then the USB dongle @ £30 to buy. Confusing as it is but this way you would have 2 wheels and X360 support and the Clubsport pedals with needed dongle for approx £499. Yes its spending then £50 more again than the Turbo Clubsport package cost but hell for £50 you get 2xWHEELS almost seems better value doesnt it?
Content:
Force Feedback racing wheel with leather wheel rim for Xbox360
RF dongle for compatibility to PlayStation®3 and PC
Clubsport pedals (metal)
6+1 speed gear shift
Sequential gearshift
1 GB Porsche USB stick with software
Steel Plate (for pedals)
power supply
quick guide
drilling template
Compatibility:
Xbox360:
The wheel is compatible to all games which support the Microsoft wireless wheel for Xbox360.
The 6+1 Speed shifter is compatible to all future racing games which support this shifter.
With the RF dongle (PWTRF) the wheel is compatible to PlayStation®3 and PC games with full Force feedback effects
pedal compatibility:
Microsoft wireless wheel for Xbox360
Logitech G25
Porsche 911 Carrera wheel
Porsche 911 Turbo S wheel
Fanatec Clubsport pedals
See Here For Details Porsche 911 GT3 RS Wheel (Due March 2009) Approx £169.95
The weird thing though with this new wheel is the price:
What do i mean?
Well the Clubsport pedals are approx £200, ok hold that price in your head, the GT3RS wheel on its own is approx £169 so youd expect the Clubsport version with the pedals included to cost approx £369, but for some reason its £289 so you save £80 buying pedals as a set in the Clubsport GT3RS.
Its funny how the same discount isnt applied to the 911 Turbo S wheel unless they later revise their pricing.
Content:
Force Feedback racing wheel with belt drive
Quick guide
Power supply
Adapter cable to connect the pedals of the Logitech G25 or pedals which are compatible to the G25
Note: Driver and manual must be downloaded from
www.Fanatec.com -> Support
Recommended aceesories:
Clubsport pedals
Shifter set for Porsche wheels with sequential shifter and 6+1 shifter
Clubsport table clamp to adjust the angle and improve stability.
Rennsport Wheel Stand
RennSport Cockpit
Compatibility:
PC: All racing games which support Force Feedback racing wheels.
The vibration motor on the brake and the LED display need special plug-ins which can be downloaded from the support section.
PlayStation 3: Most popular racing games which support Force Feedback racing wheels.
Porsche 911 GT3 RS Wheel -Clubsport- Approx £289
Great looking wheel and it offers the same specs as the more expensive "Turbo S" apart from having the new Alacantra Leather and of course this product isnt X360 compatible.
Content:
Force Feedback racing wheel with belt drive
Clubsport Pedals
USB cable to use pedals as stand alone product
connection cable from wheel to pedals
Quick guide
Power supply
Note: Driver and manual must be downloaded from
www.Fanatec.com -> Support
Recommended accessories:
Shifter set for Porsche wheels with sequential shifter and 6+1 shifter
Clubsport table clamp to adjust the angle and improve stability.
Rennsport Wheel Stand
RennSport Cockpit
Compatibility:
PC: All racing games which support Force Feedback racing wheels.
The vibration motor on the brake and the LED display need special plug-ins which can be downloaded from the support section.
PlayStation 3: Most popular racing games which support Force Feedback racing wheels.
Note: Not all games support the clutch and the optional 6+1 shifter
ClubSport Pedals Approx £200 If Bought As a Seperate Item
G25 owners may decide to upgrade to these as the build quality and feel is certain to be in a new league.
However at the price what else would you expect considering these cost approx £30 more than a full G25 set would.
An old saying applies here, if it dont look cheap it probably isnt.
See You Tube for lots of videos including a close up look at these new pedals.
Anyone interested can get comparisons between Fanatec Wheels & G25
At this point i would consider doing what i explained above unless the Turbo S Clubsport package reduces alot from £450.
If not ideally then for me:
1. Buy the GT3RS wheel in Clubsport Package
2. Come the time for X360 support if required buy the "Turbo S Pure" wheel with dongle and swap the wheels over on the racing frame when needed.