Quote:
Originally Posted by Triggaaar EDIT - agoing to start answering my own questions here:
I would like to buy a book on photoshop, but I'm not sure if it matters what version of photoshop I use |
.
In general it doesn't but newer versions have a lot more and over time the GUI has had subtle but real changes..Get a book for the version you have or latter version
Quote:
|
What is the advantage of Photoshop CS2 or 3, over Photoshop Elements 3?
|
There is a list (Too long to detail) but If you read Scott Kelbys book youll find there are workabouts for many of the features CS has.
Quote:
|
EDIT - Looks like ELements 5 is a good upgrade from 3 (curves included to some extent, although maybe not as thorough as in CS2). Not sure about Elements 6 yet, any advice?
|
Simplistic comparison

Its not just curves. Elements is designed to be easier to use . Some of its effects / Filters (ect) are a bit more automated.
Layer Masks ect are also better implemented in CS
But speaking as one who has various flavours of PS
and Elements on several machines some Mulltiboot. ( Elements 3-6) and CS to CS3). I wouldnt worry too much about the version differences. Most recent versions are more than capable. the only limiting factor is the user (and hardware)
Quote:
|
I have Elements 3 and will no doubt spend weeks learning how to use it, and if there was much advantage for an amateur to use the pro version, I'd consider it. That may then influence which book I buy,
|
Read the above
Quote:
Scoot Kelby's:
"The Photoshop Elements 5 Book for Digital Photographers (Paperback)" would probably be fine for Elements 3 that I have.
|
Yes.. but their GUIs are rather different.. Ver 6 even more so ( I've been "trialling" ver 6 for only the past 3 weeks now)
Quote:
Steve Caplin's
"How to Cheat in Photoshop CS3: The Art of Creating Photorealistic Montages"
|
This is a bit too specialist for now I think
Quote:
|
EDIT - I'll get a book that matches the exact photoshop I settle on.
|
..
You can actually have both Elements and PS itself you know.
The slightly older versions cost far less ..
The reason for having CS ect would be to perhaps use it with tutorials to do "intermediate to advanced stuff". Elements is IMHO far more than capable for most simple to intermediate things and even then it is mildly amusing that by the time you get to actually master one version, another is out!
I have some video tutorials Id promised to send to several folk on here but have been so hamstrung by work and life Issues , I've stopped offering until I honour past offers


. maybe this weekend
Many magazines run very useful tutorials on thier cover mount CDs ( Digital Photo is one of the better ones) but even they have a tendency to repeat the same topics periodically and may not feature what you particularly want a any one time