opinion

[mr jones]

which looks better, same image, exactly the same post processing

which one looks better?


i was trying to make a rather grained up black and white image that put empthesis on the band and the venue, what do people think, i like it

a

b

[seany]

I like grain in black and whites.

They look so identical to me mate i can't tell them apart. Post one with no grain in to compare

[mattym]

i reckon the first......


no really.

[mr jones]

i wasnt sure if the mic stand was attracting unwanted attention or not so i disposed off it

[RobertP]

I've never been into B/W but in the spirit of trying to understand why everybody else seems to like it I've been reading this POTN thread which goes into different methods of conversion and controlling contrast.

I have even seen a few B/W images that I like there!

What makes grain in the image was discussed somewhere too though I wasn't paying too much attention to that.

Might be worth a read.... but it's very long.

[Radiohead]

Originally Posted by RobertP

Might be worth a read.... but it's very long.

You're not wrong!

[mattym]

there is a good tutorial on the different methods of conversion on HERE

[mr jones]

i use the second to last method on here http://www.eyesondesign.net/pshop/bw...ting_to_bw.htm

i liike the results

[seany]

I never noticed the mic The first one for me to Jamie , the two mics frame the drummer

Quick and easy one here
http://www.luminous-landscape.com/tu...w_better.shtml

[paulc1]

two mics deffo..it makes the stage look busier and more showbiz...just my 2 penneth worth.

[mr jones]

im leaning that way as well, just wasnt sure what the general opinion was