CRT vs plasma - oops!

[Fergusd]

Hi guys.
I feel like an imposter in this forum, because I've spent the last 3 months looking for a plasma (to get a bigger TV).

My 5 year old Sony KV-29X5U is a fantastic telly, but from my viewing distance, it is too small. I was all set on a Panasonic TH-37PE50 or the 42", but after seeing demos at numerous places, I have not yet seen any plasma that gives crisp, bright, smooth and lifelike pictures like my Sony. However, all the demos I've had were in stores where the feed was questionable.

Now this is where I need an honest answer (from the CRT forum!):-
I get excellent freeview reception where I am, but I still I don't know whether a decent plasma screen can produce the superbly vibrant and stable images that I'm used to from my CRT. I was waiting for the new (PX60) Panasonic plasmas, but at around £1600, I may have lost my nerve.

Please can anyone convince me one way or the other, or will I have to wait for SED to become an affordable alternative?

IF picture quality is your main concern then FWIW try a specialist hi-fi shop. ie The sort of place that sells £600 cd players not £60 ones. Most of these places went into home cinema a long time ago and can offer advice and set up that just doesn't exist elsewhere.

I have seen plasma's and lcd's on demo with a freeview feed (admittedly fitted with very good interconnects and mains leads) that I thought were playing DVD's.

Because these places sell to a much smaller audience and on a much lower turnover they can only afford to stock models that they know can sell easily just on the quality they offer, and quality remains long after the price is forgotten

Although these stores cannot match someone like JL for a guarantee beyond the one that comes with the set as standard, the prices are usually very competitive.

The dealer I went to in November only stocked 3 makes and one of those only came in 42". I watched a HD demo and felt I could almost reach in and pick the people and objects up the picture was that good.

One thing to consider is perhaps just go for a screen then in theory all the money is going on picture quality. You can them add your own taste in speakers to get the best of both sound and vision.

I have deliberately not mentioned any brands to leave you with an open mind if you decide to walk through the door.

[Fergusd]

Originally Posted by richarles

I have seen plasma's and lcd's on demo with a freeview feed (admittedly fitted with very good interconnects and mains leads) that I thought were playing DVD's.

That's just what I wanted to hear, thanks.

Now got to convince myself that plasma is a reliable technology.

I did see a slim tube CRT alongside some other CRTs and it had the most awful distortion. Am I right in thinking that a conventional CRT is the only kind of TV which scans the picture directly onto the screen without having to 'decode' or 'digitise' the information first?

[satinder]

If you really want a plasma then take a look at the new Pioneer 43" as it has a really good picture & sound. Theres a review of 40-43" flatscreens in this months What Tv & Hi-fi which the pioneer wins.

Sat

[mctech]

In my opinion you will never get an LCD/Plasma to show as good a picture as a CRT

[hamster]

Originally Posted by Fergusd

Am I right in thinking that a conventional CRT is the only kind of TV which scans the picture directly onto the screen without having to 'decode' or 'digitise' the information first?

If it's a 100Hz CRT it will still digitise the information.

As for no plasma or LCD as good as CRT...hmmm.

CRT is fantastic at motion, colour saturation, but panel technologies have superior geometry, corner sharpness, and convergence.

There's no such thing as a perfect technology. Buy what pleases you most.

[sparticus]

I have a 36" tv in a two bedroom house. I would love to hang a screen on the wall but have yet to see a pic as good, from any panel. I have had a good look round specialist shops running expensive dvd players, and on occassion been very disappointed. In fact a very good mate has a new pioneer 505 and while it is about the best ive seen, it isnt as good as my crt. Although High def screens running HD material blow away everything imho.
cheers

[CJROSS]

Originally Posted by mctech

In my opinion you will never get an LCD/Plasma to show as good a picture as a CRT

I have to agree with this chap, when I was looking there were none that came close to a CRT being fed a RGB scart from say a Sky or Freeview box, they all looked terrible. Depends how long away HDTV is from normal TV, but I reckon a good few years away. FWIW I also have struggled to see a better plasma/LCD HDMI/DVI picture than what I see from PAL/PS and my 36” CRT, the only thing was last week when I saw a HD DVD-V demo from Sony on a 37” Sony Plasma, quite breathtaking, but that was a DVD demo and I will have to see what Sky and the HDTV freeviews boxes outputs before suggesting them.

At this point and for the next couple of years - CRT to me has the edge.

[SillySausage]

I used to say that I would never buy a plasma or RP until the quality came close to my Sony KV32FX60 widescreen CRT.

I've had a plasma for 18 months now

I still play the same DVD occasionally on the CRT and Plasma to give a comparison, and I think that the plasma is easily an equal for the CRT.

However, I have never seen a plasma set up in a shop as good as mine,so maybe this is a good reason behind the general concensuss (sp)

[LV426]

Show me pretty well any regular production retail CRT set from any maker, and I'll show you a whole raft of things wrong with its picture, none of which will (or can, even) be wrong with a Plasma or LCD.

That's not to say that flat panels are perfect, or even "better" than CRTs, nor vice versa. All technologies, including CRTs, have their shortcomings. Which is "best" depends almost entirely on which shortcomings the buyer/viewer can bear most easily.

[Fergusd]

Well, thanks all of you for the wise words.
That has clinched it, and I've decided to try a plasma.

I have just ordered a Panny TH-37PE50ped from H Preston for £799 + £30 delivery. I figure at that price, if it turns out to be a disappointment I'll just put it on fleabay and recoup most of the cash. At least then I will have a better idea of PDP and CRT pros and cons!

I will post my comments on this thread after doing some direct comparisons.
(Arrives later this week)

[SillySausage]

Now you've done it... Saying your getting a plasma in the CRT forum

Seriously though, good luck with the screen. Remember to turn the brightness down to below zero for the first 200 hours.

Happy viewing

[satinder]

I am a true supporter of CRT tv's but the latest 7th gen. plasmas like the Pioneer (was at Bristol Show) are starting to win me over .

Sat

[Hudson]

I too think the new crop of Plasma sets are very very good and in most cases as good as CRT, my only concern at the moment is price and the number of HD connections, i find most only have one HDMI input and with the price of boxes which give more inputs costing around the £200 or so mark i think i will just stick with my Panny 36PL32 for a while longer, at least until HD broadcasts are actually with us (Not just on SKY), or until HDDVD or Blueray come out on top of the soon to be format war.

It depends, if you want 32" or less you'll NEVER beat a crt for standard def. However, when hd is available you cant have it! If you want the option of hd then the best flat screen for you is the sharp p50 range or upcoming p70 range. Best lcd that compares with crt but still gives you the option of hd. Excellent too for dvd and hd (like most lcds). Still wont beat a crt for sd pq. If you watch a lot of sports such as football you may want to test first and decide if any motion smearing is visible for fast camera pans. Some advice, stay clear of Sony lcd.

If you would like a good pq for sd and plan to go hd then:

If you are sitting 3m - 3.5m from the tele you'll be happy with a 37" panasonic plasma (pv500) - I have one and really regard the pq as better than my old jvc 36" crt (it was rubbish btw!) on all formats sd, dvd, hd. I wouldnt swap it for the world.

If you are sitting well over 3.5m from the tele you may be happy with a 42 or 43" panasonic or pioneer plasma