Imminent Panny SD5 Purchase....SDHC and Software Questions

[wigwam12]

Sorry!
I have done a bot of a search a got a few answers but some clarification would be appreciated.
Plan to buy the SD5 over the weekend.
Seen a few different classes od SDHC cards: what is the diff between Class 2/4/6? What should I get?

Size wise I read someone say they use 4gb as 1 card = 1dvd [40min or so?!] which seems good logic and 2x4gb costs less than 1x8gb [etc].
Any views on capacity aspect?

Software: if I am going to splash out what would be the most user friendly way to get the footage off the camcorder, edit it simply on my pc if desired and author it to dvd?

My hardware: Panasonic THPX70 42" plasma; xbox media centre; sony vaio fz21z with blu ray writer; core 2 quad pc with 4gb ram.
Any other hardware I need? I understand even "normal" disc written with AVHD need to be played on bluray so my laptop becomes my player I suppose?

Thanks

[redsox_mark]

what is the diff between Class 2/4/6? What should I get?

Speed. You need Class 2 or higher. No real advantage of anything faster than Class 2.


Size wise I read someone say they use 4gb as 1 card = 1dvd [40min or so?!]

Correct - on the SD5, 4 GB holds 40 mins at highest quality setting.

Software: if I am going to splash out what would be the most user friendly way to get the footage off the camcorder, edit it simply on my pc if desired and author it to dvd?

Probably Ulead DVD Movie Factory. It can handle AVCHD, and create both standard def DVD videos, and AVCHD discs.

[dave_bass5]

Originally Posted by redsox_mark

Speed. You need Class 2 or higher. No real advantage of anything faster than Class 2.

I would just make sure its compatible with the SD5.
I say this as on my HF10 using a class 2 SD i cant record at the highest bit rate setting.

[redsox_mark]

Originally Posted by dave_bass5

I would just make sure its compatible with the SD5.
I say this as on my HF10 using a class 2 SD i cant record at the highest bit rate setting.

I agree, the card needs to be fast enough to support the camcorder's bitrate. With the SD5 (which uses a lower bitrate than the HF10), Class 2 is enough for all quality modes. The HF10 requires Class 4 to use "FXP mode".

[dave_bass5]

I thought that might be the case as the HF10 uses higher bit rates.

[zapata]

Originally Posted by redsox_mark

[I]

Software: if I am going to splash out what would be the most user friendly way to get the footage off the camcorder, edit it simply on my pc if desired and author it to dvd?

Probably Ulead DVD Movie Factory. It can handle AVCHD, and create both standard def DVD videos, and AVCHD discs.

I'm interested in this part, what blank discs would you use for AVCHD, can you use normal dvd-r or dual layer discs.

[redsox_mark]

You can use either normal dvd-r or dual layer discs.

[zapata]

Once this HD data is burnt to a disc such as a DVD-R will it still be Hi-Def or can you only view Hi-Def through the camcorder.

[redsox_mark]

If you create a AVCHD "mini DVD" (which can play on a PS3 or some blu-ray players), this will be high def.

If you simply create a data DVD which contains the AVCHD files, that will also be high def, and can be played on a PC.

If you want to create a DVD-video which plays on any ordinary DVD player, then it will need to be standard definition.

[zapata]

Originally Posted by redsox_mark

If you create a AVCHD "mini DVD" (which can play on a PS3 or some blu-ray players), this will be high def.

If you simply create a data DVD which contains the AVCHD files, that will also be high def, and can be played on a PC.

If you want to create a DVD-video which plays on any ordinary DVD player, then it will need to be standard definition.

Thanks for the heads up Mark, that makes it a lot clearer.

[wigwam12]

Just went to Currys to physically handle an SD9 and a SD5 they have.
Just how useful/advantageous are:
-Face Detection
-5.1 Sound [vs Stereo]
which the SD9 seems to have but the SD5 lacks???

What about these guided shooting modes? mentioned in the blurb on the Sd9 but not the SD5

[redsox_mark]

I've not used a camcorder with face detection; so I can comment on how useful it is.

To me, 5.1 audio recording is not very useful. Don't get me wrong, properly mixed 5.1 audio can be great; using multiple mics and sources. But when shooting video, you generally want to audio relating to what you are shooting at, not what is behind you. E.g. if you are shooting at a wedding or a school play, do you want to hear the people sitting behind you, or what the bride/groom/children are saying?

As for "guided shooting modes", do you mean what is called on their web site "Intelligent Shooting Guide", and in the manual is called "Intelligent scene selection"? This is an interesting (but I think not very useful) feature. It applies to playback (not "shooting") on the camcorder only, and what it does is omits parts which it doesn't think you did a good job on (too much camera shake, too dark, not focussed, etc). "For data that are copied to a PC or written to media by selecting motion pictures, or edited with the easy editing function of HD Writer 2.5E, the Intelligent scene selection is disabled"

So unless you plan to use your camcorder itself as your main playback device, and trust the camcorder decide what is good enough to show, I don't think that is essential.

[wigwam12]

Excellent thanks.
I did indeed mean intelligent shooting guide.
You have banished that little worm of doubt tugging me towards splashing out more than the £349 I was intending.

Also the Sd5 is slightly bigger than the SD9 and infact it is more comfortable in my hands than the newer smaller offering.

[wigwam12]

well I just bought it from Amazon. now just sourcing SDHC cards. Just in time for summer kids fun and games

[daggad]

The intelligent shooting guide is not something that will be missed. It's like having you wife built into the camcorder and telling you what to do all the time !

The face detection was good, but not worth the pricegap.