Quote:
Originally Posted by jackal Apparently forced update will never happen unless the studios decide to flag the disc main presentation as such. This has been stated on here.
I doubted it, but just talked to an old mate in the US (works for Oracle in a senior position) and this is apparently true.
She said 1080p 24 was an unforeseen add on????????
Seems to me that HD DVD has been caught on this one
Beyond my area of knowledge, so who knows. |
I know that its been stated on the forums that a forced 24P mode will not appear until the studios build in support for it on individual disks.
However the reasons to backup such a view seemed to me to be rather wooly. Or at least I could not see a firm basis for such a view (my appologies though if I have missed something).
I also don't wish to denegrate you old friends view / feedback and can imagine that she knows a great deal about databases given his employeer but does it follow that he is anymore in the know as regards the in's and out's of 24P processing in HD-DVD ?
I'm intruigued by the statement that 1080p 24 was an unforeseen add on.
Seems incredibly unlikely to me that this is the case. Its been part of the HD-DVD standard from the start. Afterall someone decided that they would author the disks in 1080p 24, so it would logicaly follow that they would think that they would eventualy like to pull this information straight off the disk at some point rather than having to frame rate convert all the time.
Lets face it 1080p 24 has been the holy grail of the display industry for a long time, so I really doubt that its an afterthought.
I could however see how someone may build it into a standards spec before they had fully worked out how to implement it at a detailed level.
So I'm not convinced that this is a major big deal to implement.
Afterall the players can now output 1080p 24 and when set to do so can detect (sometimes incorrectly based on the displays EDID) when a display device cant accept 24p and drop back to the next lowest option. How difficult can it be to implement some code that stops the player from falling back ?
Maybe there is something in the spec that makes this more difficult than I can imagine. Would love to see the HD-DVD specification.