AVForums

Our philosophy in our forums, reviews, podcasts and feature videos is to promote audio and visual excellence by gathering and sharing the best information and resources available.

Help

To begin please visit our help section »

Not a Member Yet?

It only takes a minute to start enjoying the benefits of AVForums membership, and it's free!

Member Log in

£200 player or £5000 player - much difference?

Post Reply
Old 12-08-2009, 8:31 PM   #1
Member
Join Date: Jun 2004
Location: Solihull, UK
Experience Points:
5,592, Level: 17
Points: 5,592, Level: 17 Points: 5,592, Level: 17 Points: 5,592, Level: 17
Activity: 2.4%
Activity: 2.4% Activity: 2.4% Activity: 2.4%
Thanks: Gave 40, Got 31
Posts: 876
£200 player or £5000 player - much difference?

Without wanting to stir up a hornets nest here, I just want to ask a question...

Is there a real performance benefit in buying a player that costs £2000 - £5000, over a player that costs £200?

How much better does that extra few thousand pounds make films look and sound?

The reason why I ask is because whenever I went into HiFi stores in years gone by and saw the latest and greatest Denon beast playing on a plasma, although it looked very good, it didn't look £4000 worth better.

Can someone offer an objective opinion?

Ben.
  Quote
Old 12-08-2009, 8:40 PM   #2
Senior Member
Join Date: Oct 2005
Experience Points:
6,944, Level: 19
Points: 6,944, Level: 19 Points: 6,944, Level: 19 Points: 6,944, Level: 19
Activity: 0%
Activity: 0% Activity: 0% Activity: 0%
Thanks: Gave 193, Got 132
Posts: 2,106
Re: £200 player or £5000 player - much difference?

In a nutshell i would say no!

I would not pay that amount unless i literally had money to burn, i have a LX51 and it does a fine job, cant see how the picture could be much improved upon, its near perfect on the kuro

This is the player i would recommend to people alough the panasonic bd35 is meant to perform pretty much as good i think

Than again as i say above, IF i won the lottery i would consider it, but only if it had real features that made it stand out.

The money would be much better spent on a new amp for most setups

(there was a review of players on here at tlc broadcast, goes into detail of this subject and they test the units too)
  Quote
Old 12-08-2009, 8:48 PM   #3
Eminent Member
 
kingfats's Avatar
Join Date: Dec 2006
Location: Windsor
Experience Points:
106,213, Level: 79
Points: 106,213, Level: 79 Points: 106,213, Level: 79 Points: 106,213, Level: 79
Activity: 0%
Activity: 0% Activity: 0% Activity: 0%
Thanks: Gave 1,193, Got 7,647
Posts: 36,273
Re: £200 player or £5000 player - much difference?

Quote:
Originally Posted by Captain_Danger View Post
Without wanting to stir up a hornets nest here, I just want to ask a question...

Is there a real performance benefit in buying a player that costs £2000 - £5000, over a player that costs £200?

How much better does that extra few thousand pounds make films look and sound?

The reason why I ask is because whenever I went into HiFi stores in years gone by and saw the latest and greatest Denon beast playing on a plasma, although it looked very good, it didn't look £4000 worth better.

Can someone offer an objective opinion?

Ben.
Hi Ben.
Some feedback here on three BD players Denon A1UD costs £4500.
Plus TLC BD player shootout video.
Main thread.

Last edited by kingfats; 12-08-2009 at 8:56 PM.
  Quote
Old 12-08-2009, 9:01 PM   #4
Senior Member
 
sapper's Avatar
Join Date: Jul 2000
Location: Southgate, North London
Experience Points:
20,094, Level: 34
Points: 20,094, Level: 34 Points: 20,094, Level: 34 Points: 20,094, Level: 34
Activity: 19.3%
Activity: 19.3% Activity: 19.3% Activity: 19.3%
Thanks: Gave 432, Got 139
Posts: 2,210
Re: £200 player or £5000 player - much difference?

Quote:
Originally Posted by kingfats View Post
Hi Ben.
Some feedback here on three BD players Denon A1UD costs £4500.
Plus TLC BD player shootout video.
Main thread.
LOL KF

Partially due to browser "not responding" glitches you beat me to it!

Also in the Arcam Section there is a my brief comparison of a £2000 SACD/DVD-A player agasint a £600 unit!

My conclusion was that the Arcam was a better sound but not £1400 worth!!


Adrian
  Quote
Old 12-08-2009, 9:26 PM   #5
Member
Join Date: Jun 2004
Location: Solihull, UK
Experience Points:
5,592, Level: 17
Points: 5,592, Level: 17 Points: 5,592, Level: 17 Points: 5,592, Level: 17
Activity: 2.4%
Activity: 2.4% Activity: 2.4% Activity: 2.4%
Thanks: Gave 40, Got 31
Posts: 876
Re: £200 player or £5000 player - much difference?

I guess its the law of ever diminishing returns. You can't add quality that isn't there.

Is the difference between good and bad players with Blu Ray smaller than the gap between the good and bad DVD players of old?

I saw some shocking DVD players in years gone by, but also saw some really amazing cheap ones too.
  Quote
Old 12-08-2009, 9:29 PM   #6
Eminent Member
 
kingfats's Avatar
Join Date: Dec 2006
Location: Windsor
Experience Points:
106,213, Level: 79
Points: 106,213, Level: 79 Points: 106,213, Level: 79 Points: 106,213, Level: 79
Activity: 0%
Activity: 0% Activity: 0% Activity: 0%
Thanks: Gave 1,193, Got 7,647
Posts: 36,273
Re: £200 player or £5000 player - much difference?

Quote:
Originally Posted by Captain_Danger View Post
Is the difference between good and bad players with Blu Ray smaller than the gap between the good and bad DVD players of old?

.
I'm yet to see a bad Blu-ray player to be honest PQ wise anyway.
  Quote
Old 12-08-2009, 9:32 PM   #7
Assured Advertiser
 
Vipers @ Zinc-HT's Avatar
Join Date: Oct 2005
Location: Stevenage
Experience Points:
18,623, Level: 33
Points: 18,623, Level: 33 Points: 18,623, Level: 33 Points: 18,623, Level: 33
Activity: 22.3%
Activity: 22.3% Activity: 22.3% Activity: 22.3%
Thanks: Gave 338, Got 387
Posts: 2,928
Re: £200 player or £5000 player - much difference?

I guess this question will be answered when we do the Blu Ray player shootout at TLC on 20th Sept. The idea is to do blind testing so we don't know which players we are using, we are aiming to have a selection of players right across the board going upto the A1UD, should make some interesting results.

Personally I believe there is a difference, especially after seeing what an amazing picture the A1UD produces, trouble is even I would struggle to jutify the cost of £4500, doesn't stop me wanting one sooner rather than later though
Click here for PMC / Bryston Open Day; March 17th 2012
Hear the new Bryston SP3 Processor and Twenty Range @ Zinc-HT

PMC / Bryston / Naim / Linn / Spendor / Meridian / Loewe
paul@zinc-ht.com | www.zinc-ht.com | 020 8953 5522 | @zinchometech
  Quote
Old 12-08-2009, 9:32 PM   #8
Prominent Member
 
kempez's Avatar
Join Date: May 2008
Location: Basingstoke
Experience Points:
5,264, Level: 17
Points: 5,264, Level: 17 Points: 5,264, Level: 17 Points: 5,264, Level: 17
Activity: 11.5%
Activity: 11.5% Activity: 11.5% Activity: 11.5%
Blog Entries: 3
Thanks: Gave 234, Got 274
Posts: 3,490
Re: £200 player or £5000 player - much difference?

Quote:
Originally Posted by kingfats View Post
I'm yet to see a bad Blu-ray player to be honest PQ wise anyway.
And the man's seen a few players

I've watched a fair few players myself (and own a couple), and none of them have been bad, even the bargain Sammy BDP-1500 I got for the parentals is pretty darn sweet
  Quote
Old 12-08-2009, 9:36 PM   #9
Senior Member
 
sapper's Avatar
Join Date: Jul 2000
Location: Southgate, North London
Experience Points:
20,094, Level: 34
Points: 20,094, Level: 34 Points: 20,094, Level: 34 Points: 20,094, Level: 34
Activity: 19.3%
Activity: 19.3% Activity: 19.3% Activity: 19.3%
Thanks: Gave 432, Got 139
Posts: 2,210
Re: £200 player or £5000 player - much difference?

Quote:
Originally Posted by vipers View Post
I guess this question will be answered when we do the Blu Ray player shootout at TLC on 20th Sept.
Very interesting indeed..

Enjoy!!
  Quote
Old 12-08-2009, 9:44 PM   #10
Prominent Member
Join Date: Sep 2008
Location: Hertfordshire
Experience Points:
13,310, Level: 27
Points: 13,310, Level: 27 Points: 13,310, Level: 27 Points: 13,310, Level: 27
Activity: 3.4%
Activity: 3.4% Activity: 3.4% Activity: 3.4%
Thanks: Gave 343, Got 335
Posts: 3,429
Re: £200 player or £5000 player - much difference?

I really think you need to see for yourself, I bought a Denon 3800 over a Pioneer 51 after intending to buy a 51. The A1UD is fabulous and better than the 3800 and although I hanker after one at £4.5k its no go.

People who believe that a £1000 system (not BluRay player) is not compromised are not living in the real world. Then again those that spend £100k on a system probably aren't either.

There are step changes at certain price points and the law of diminishing returns applies but those who buy budget and kid themselves that the only difference is brand and casework often haven't listened to higher quality kit.

If your enthused, interested and passionate about film then your buying decision will be different to others
  Quote
Old 12-08-2009, 9:51 PM   #11
Member
Join Date: Jun 2004
Location: Solihull, UK
Experience Points:
5,592, Level: 17
Points: 5,592, Level: 17 Points: 5,592, Level: 17 Points: 5,592, Level: 17
Activity: 2.4%
Activity: 2.4% Activity: 2.4% Activity: 2.4%
Thanks: Gave 40, Got 31
Posts: 876
Re: £200 player or £5000 player - much difference?

Will be interested to find out the results of the blind test...
  Quote
Old 12-08-2009, 9:56 PM   #12
Prominent Member
 
kempez's Avatar
Join Date: May 2008
Location: Basingstoke
Experience Points:
5,264, Level: 17
Points: 5,264, Level: 17 Points: 5,264, Level: 17 Points: 5,264, Level: 17
Activity: 11.5%
Activity: 11.5% Activity: 11.5% Activity: 11.5%
Blog Entries: 3
Thanks: Gave 234, Got 274
Posts: 3,490
Re: £200 player or £5000 player - much difference?

Quote:
Originally Posted by IWC Dopplel View Post
If your enthused, interested and passionate about film then your buying decision will be different to others
Whilst I agree with the rest of your post (components/build/quality is cheaper in lower end players, Amps, speakers etc), not all of us who are passionate about films can afford the exact players they want. I know I certainly want to replace my BD35 with something else but cannot afford to right now

I also think there's far less noticeable PQ difference between the low end, mid range and high end in BRD players than there was (is) in DVD players.

I am not, however, denying that there is a difference Again the law of diminishing returns comes into play.
  Quote
Old 12-08-2009, 9:56 PM   #13
Eminent Member
 
kingfats's Avatar
Join Date: Dec 2006
Location: Windsor
Experience Points:
106,213, Level: 79
Points: 106,213, Level: 79 Points: 106,213, Level: 79 Points: 106,213, Level: 79
Activity: 0%
Activity: 0% Activity: 0% Activity: 0%
Thanks: Gave 1,193, Got 7,647
Posts: 36,273
Re: £200 player or £5000 player - much difference?

I think you can enjoy and be passionate about film at any level money shouldn't really be a factor there.
  Quote
Thanks from:
kempez (13-08-2009)
Old 12-08-2009, 9:59 PM   #14
Prominent Member
 
kempez's Avatar
Join Date: May 2008
Location: Basingstoke
Experience Points:
5,264, Level: 17
Points: 5,264, Level: 17 Points: 5,264, Level: 17 Points: 5,264, Level: 17
Activity: 11.5%
Activity: 11.5% Activity: 11.5% Activity: 11.5%
Blog Entries: 3
Thanks: Gave 234, Got 274
Posts: 3,490
Re: £200 player or £5000 player - much difference?

Quote:
Originally Posted by kingfats View Post
I think you can enjoy and be passionate about film at any level money shouldn't really be a factor there.
Yep, pretty much what I meant
  Quote
Old 12-08-2009, 10:26 PM   #15
Senior Member
Join Date: May 2009
Experience Points:
5,603, Level: 17
Points: 5,603, Level: 17 Points: 5,603, Level: 17 Points: 5,603, Level: 17
Activity: 1.4%
Activity: 1.4% Activity: 1.4% Activity: 1.4%
Thanks: Gave 70, Got 70
Posts: 1,241
Re: £200 player or £5000 player - much difference?

Even if there is a difference the decision whether to buy the 5K player should depend on the value of the rest of your set-up. If I had 5K to built a home cinema I would consider a 500£ player. A 5K player would require at least a 60" Kuro or a 5K-10K PJ to begin with othewise you should rather spend on getting a high end PJ/TV first instead of a high-end player and there is more to add to that list.
  Quote
Old 12-08-2009, 10:50 PM   #16
Member
Join Date: May 2007
Experience Points:
4,362, Level: 15
Points: 4,362, Level: 15 Points: 4,362, Level: 15 Points: 4,362, Level: 15
Activity: 0.3%
Activity: 0.3% Activity: 0.3% Activity: 0.3%
Thanks: Gave 56, Got 80
Posts: 980
Re: £200 player or £5000 player - much difference?

Quote:
Originally Posted by kingfats View Post
I think you can enjoy and be passionate about film at any level money shouldn't really be a factor there.
Couldn't agree more.
  Quote
Old 13-08-2009, 2:53 AM   #17
Prominent Member
Join Date: Sep 2008
Location: Hertfordshire
Experience Points:
13,310, Level: 27
Points: 13,310, Level: 27 Points: 13,310, Level: 27 Points: 13,310, Level: 27
Activity: 3.4%
Activity: 3.4% Activity: 3.4% Activity: 3.4%
Thanks: Gave 343, Got 335
Posts: 3,429
Re: £200 player or £5000 player - much difference?

Quote:
Originally Posted by kempez View Post
Whilst I agree with the rest of your post (components/build/quality is cheaper in lower end players, Amps, speakers etc), not all of us who are passionate about films can afford the exact players they want. I know I certainly want to replace my BD35 with something else but cannot afford to right now

I also think there's far less noticeable PQ difference between the low end, mid range and high end in BRD players than there was (is) in DVD players.

I am not, however, denying that there is a difference Again the law of diminishing returns comes into play.

I agree with you on all points, the point about the buying decision is its a personal decision. The personal decision will be about how important to us the item is in the context of how much we are prepared to spend on AV verses say clothes, cars, football tickets or whatever. This is about choices we make, not about how much we spend.

My personal decision on affordability and the value to me of a £4,500 bluray player is it's a no go. For me if it was £1,500-2,000 then I would buy. We all go the same decisions, if I was less passionate about film, the price point would be lower. If I had a greater income it would be higher and visa versa.

I agree wholeheartedly that passion and enthusiasm have nothing to do with money, peoples shopping list obviously does (unfortunately so otherwise I would have the A1 !).
  Quote
Thanks from:
kempez (13-08-2009)
Post Reply

Powered by  
 Latest popular product prices
Toshiba SD5010 
8 prices from
 £36.54 Click to show/hide the offers

LG BD650 
4 prices from
 £69.99 Click to show/hide the offers

LG DRT389H 
6 prices from
 £112.99 Click to show/hide the offers

Samsung BD-D5100 
8 prices from
 £64.00 Click to show/hide the offers

Sony BDP-S185 
9 prices from
 £68.81 Click to show/hide the offers

Sony BDP-S380 
5 prices from
 £94.95 Click to show/hide the offers

Panasonic DMP-BDT110 
7 prices from
 £99.99 Click to show/hide the offers

Sony BDP-S480 
10 prices from
 £99.95 Click to show/hide the offers

 Updated February 13th at 6:30am. Prices include delivery.


Thread information and display options
Thread Tools

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts
BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are Off
Pingbacks are Off
Refbacks are Off