Quote:
Originally Posted by John Martin Have you ever tried putting those awful cardboard things over your spectacles? Also, if you do, what happens with those red/green ones is a nasty washed out image almost totally devoid of colour. |
you are totally out of date



No more cardboard, no more red/green foil stuff.
Shutter glasses. Proper fancy electronics crap.
I saw the Panasonic 3D Roadshow in Germany, way before Avatar etc. were released in 3D. I was very impressed with how "real" things looked. As if you could actually touch them.
It's a bit like looking at an object from behind a window vs. standing in front of the object.
BUT that's only for normal 3D, not the "in your face jump out of the screen" nonsense that a lot of people associate with 3D.
The latter is utterly useless. Image gets blurry and unless you are 1m from a 3m screen the effect sucks because you can see the object being cut off where the screen ends.
I also saw "Alice" in 3D and I have to say, the loss of colour, the loss of brightness and contrast was awefull. The image was rather dull. The shutter glasses, and not just on this particular movie nor this cinema, but also on 3D plasmas, swallow lots of contrast/brightness and colour. You have to really crank up your display to get half-decent image quality and even then it's a huge compromise between an enjoyable, vivid image and a more three dimensional image.
Personally, right now, I prefer the vivid 2D image.
Plus those glasses are much heavier and bulkier than cardboard ones and after a 2+hour movie my ears actually hurt a bit from the weight of the (non-adjustable) glasses.
I hear Zeiss/Carl-Zeiss or someone is working on a shutter-glasses-less display. Two displays in one frame somehow being moved/rotated or something so you actually get a 3D image without any glasses. But I doubt it's financially viable and most likely it will only work for a small sweet-spot and few people.
Nevertheless, the life-like 3D effect (again the non-in-your-face part) is something I am looking forward to....in 3-5years time.